Formaggio's Pizzeria
36 Main St, Madison
(973) 377-7161
Customers' Favorites
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Chicken Scarpariello
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parm
Pizza Kit
Sausage
Appetizers
Sausage
2 pieces.
Meatballs
2 pieces.
Chicken Fingers with French Fries
Add blue cheese dressing for an extra charge.
Chicken Fingers
Served with french fries.
Fried Calamari
Crispy calamari served with a side of sweet or hot marinara sauce.
Mussels Marinara
Served in sweet, medium or hot marinara sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
6 pieces.
French Fries
Cheese Fries
Buffalo Fries
Fries tossed in hot sauce and baked with mozzarella topped with blue cheese.
Hot Wings
Spicy chicken wings served with a side of ranch. Add blue cheese for an additional charge.
Garlic Knots
6 piece.
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Zucchini Sticks
Rice Balls
2 piece filled with rice, chopped meat and peas.
Bruscheta
Toasted Italian-style bread topped with a medley of chopped tomatoes, fresh basil, onion, garlic and balsamic vinaigrette.
Broccoli Rabe with Garlic and Oil
Broccoli Rabe with Sausage, Garlic and Oil
Shrimp Peeps
Served with spicy marinara sauce.
Fire Cracker Calamari
Tossed in hot cherry peppers with a side of marinara sauce.
Mac and Cheese Bites
Soups
Tortellini In Brado
16 oz. Cheese tortellini in rich chicken broth.
Pasta e Fagioli
16 oz.
Stracciatella
Chicken Soup
Salads
Antipasto Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, salami, provolone, ham, giardiniera, peppers and eggs.
Mozzarella Caprese Salad
Sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and house-made roasted peppers, drizzled with balsamic.
Caesar Salad
Made with traditional Caesar dressing and homemade croutons.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Our traditional Caesar salad topped with freshly grilled chicken.
House Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, oil and vinegar
Grilled Chicken House Salad
Our traditional house salad topped with freshly grilled chicken.
The Alexa Salad
Grilled chicken, black olives, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.
The Olivia Salad
Pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, cucumbers, tomatoes and black olives, all chopped up.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Bed of greens topped with breaded Buffalo chicken and blue cheese dressing.
Greek Salad
Feta cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes, black olives, red onion and lettuce, all chopped up.
Mixed Green Salad
Fresh tomatoes and mozzarella.
Chef Salad
Ham, turkey, provolone and American over a house salad.
Cranberry Romaine Walnut Salad
Romaine, sweet dried cranberries, fresh mozzarella and house dressing.
Family Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, carrots, peppers and onion mixed with house dressing.
Chopped Family Salad
Same as family salad but chopped.
Mixed Green Salad with Salmon
Madison Salad
Crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, cucumber, roasted red peppers, romaine and balsamic vinaigrette.
Arugula Salad
Red onions, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, black olives and balsamic vinaigrette.
Spinach Salad
Fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes and balsamic vinaigrette.
Wings
Wings
Extra blue cheese for an additional charge. Sauce on side or mixed.
Hot Subs
Meatball Sub
Sausage Sub
Meatball Parmesan Sub
Sausage Parmesan Sub
Eggplant Parmesan Sub
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Chicken cutlet tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with lettuce and ranch.
Belly Buster Sub
Steak, french fries, mozzarella sticks and chicken fingers with lite tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Grilled Chicken Sub
Freshly grilled chicken with lettuce, tomatoes and onion.
Chicken, Broccoli Rabe and Provolone Sub
Sausage, Peppers and Onion Sub
Cheesesteak
Served with peppers and onion with french fries.
Grilled Chicken with Fresh Arugula Sub
Fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers, drizzled with balsamic glaze.
Grilled Chicken Florentine Sub
Sautéed spinach with melted provolone cheese and balsamic glaze.
Eggplant with Fresh Mozzarella Sub
Fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers drizzle with balsamic glaze.
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Veal Parmesan Sub
Chicken Parmesan with Vodka Sauce Sub
Italian Sausage Sub
Peppers and onions.
Pepper and Egg Sub
Sausage, Pepper and Egg Sub
2 Brothers Sandwich
Cheesesteak, peppers and onions with potatoes.
Italian Hot Dog
Potatoes, peppers and onions.
Buffalo Cheesesteak
Hot sauce, blue cheese and American cheese.
Hoagie Steak
American cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.
Chicken Cheesesteak
Cold Subs
Fresh Mozzarella with Arugula Sub
Served with house-made roasted peppers.
Turkey Sub
Turkey and Cheese Sub
Provolone or American.
Tuna Sub
Tuna Melt
Chicken Cutlet Sub
Served with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Italian Sandwich
Ham, salami and provolone.
Ham and Cheese Sub
Wraps
The Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken and Caesar salad.
The Tune Wrap
Provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Turkey BLT Wrap
California Grilled Chicken Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Chicken Cheesesteak Wrap
Plain or with peppers and onions.
Cheesesteak Wrap
Peppers and onions.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Hot sauce, blue cheese and American cheese.
Paninis
The Madison Panini
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, arugula, roasted peppers and pesto mayo.
Grilled Cheese Panini
American and provolone cheese, bacon and tomatoes.
Eggplant Panini
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula and balsamic vinaigrette.
Burgers
Hamburger
Served with lettuce and tomatoes.
Cheeseburger
Served with lettuce, tomatoes and cheese.
Bacon Cheeseburger
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and bacon.
Pizza
Pizza Kit
Pizza dough, sauce and cheese. Add toppings for an extra charge.
Cheese Pizza
Add toppings for an extra charge.
Cheese Slice
Sicilian Slice
Gourmet Slice
Gourmet Pizzas
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo chicken, mozzarella cheese, shredded cheddar and drizzled with ranch or blue cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, Monterey Jack cheese, breaded chicken, bacon and ranch.
White Pizza
Mozzarella, ricotta and Parmesan.
Grandma's Pizza Large
Thin crust, hand-stretched pan pizza with fresh herbed San Marzano tomatoes and mozzarella.
Drunken Grandma Pizza Large
Vodka sauce and cherry tomatoes topped with fresh mozzarella.
Veggie Pizza
Eggplant, onion, tomatoes, zucchini, broccoli and mushroom.
Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza
Bruschetta Pizza
Topped with basil, onions, garlic, tomatoes and mozzarella.
Margherita Pizza
Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Topped with steak, peppers and onions.
Paisano's Special
Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onion and mushroom.
Stuffed Pizza Personal
Sausage, pepperoni, pepper, mushrooms and onion with another dough on top.
Pizza Fina 12" Personal
Very thin crust.
12" Personal Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Gluten-free.
12" Personal Gluten-Free Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, mozzarella and no sauce.
Chicken Caesar Pizza
4 Cheese Pizza
Ricotta, mozzarella, provolone and Parmesan cheese.
Chicken Broccoli Pesto Pizza
Seasoned ricotta cheese and mozzarella cheese with grilled chicken.
Chicken Parm Pizza
Breaded chicken with mozzarella cheese and sauce.
Spinach Pizza
Spinach with seasoned ricotta cheese, mozzarella and Romano cheese.
Bianco Pizza
Broccoli with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
Pesto Pizza
Seasoned ricotta cheese mixed with homemade pesto and mozzarella cheese.
Meat Lover's Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, ham, mozzarella cheese and sauce.
Penne Vodka Pie
Brooklyn Margherita Pizza Medium
Square pan pizza with fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh basil and plum tomatoes topped off with extra virgin olive oil and Romano cheese.
Stromboli
Pizza Stromboli
Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
Vegetable Stromboli
Broccoli, mushrooms, peppers and onions.
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Breaded chicken with hot sauce and side of blue cheese.
Cheesesteak Stromboli
American and mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli
American and mozzarella cheese.
Calzone
Cheese Calzone
Spinach Calzone
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Supreme Calzone
Entrees
Veal Parmesan
Red tomato sauce in melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Francese
Lemon white wine butter sauce.
Chicken Parmesan
Red tomato sauce in melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Marsala
Chicken in a Marsala and wine mushroom sauce.
Chicken Piccata
Chicken in a lemon caper sauce.
Chicken Murphy
Chicken breast sautéed in lite white wine sauce with potatoes, hot peppers and onion.
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken breast sautéed with sausage, potatoes, vinegar, onion and peppers.
Chicken and Broccoli
Pieces of chicken and broccoli sautéed a white wine or red sauce with spaghetti or penne.
Chicken Olivia
Chicken breast with eggplant, fresh roasted peppers and mozzarella in a Marsala sauce.
Chicken Alexa
Chicken tossed with penne in fresh marinara sauce.
Chicken Pizzaiola
Chicken breast sauteed with onions, peppers, black olives and mushrooms in a red sauce.
Linguine Clam Sauce
White or red sauce.
Seafood Tarrentino
Mussels, clams, shrimp and calamari served in a light tomato sauce.
Shrimp Scampi
Pasta in a lemon white wine sauce.
Shrimp Marinara
Spicy red sauce.
Shrimp Parmesan
Pasta
Tomato Sauce Pasta
Meatballs Pasta
Sausage Pasta
Butter Sauce Pasta
Marinara Sauce Pasta
Garlic and Oil Pasta
Meat Sauce Pasta
Broccoli Garlic and Oil Pasta
Cheese Ravioli
Ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Penne Alla Vodka
Homemade creamy vodka sauce.
Penne Vodka with Chicken
Cavatelli, Chicken and Broccoli Pasta
Made with sautéed broccoli in a garlic sauce.
Fettuccini Alfredo
Fettuccini tossed in rich cream sauce.
Pasta and Pesto Sauce
Fresh basil, pignoli and Parmesan cheese.
Pettanesca Sauce Pasta
Capers, garlic and olives in a light marinara sauce.
Cheese Tortellini in Tomato Sauce
Cheese Tortellini in Alfredo Sauce
Cheese Tortellini in Vodka Sauce
Cheese Ravioli
Ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Pasta Carbonara
Bacon and onion in a cream sauce.
Pasta Primavera
Vegetables in a pink vodka sauce.
Pasta Formaggio
Garlic, cherry tomatoes and sun-dried tomatoes in light garlic oil sauce.
Baked Pastas
Baked Stuffed Shells
Stuffed shells, covered in mozzarella and baked.
Baked Manicotti
Ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Baked Ziti
Ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Baked Ravioli
Covered in mozzarella and baked.
Lasagna
Layers of pasta with meat and ricotta cheese.
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
Eggplant Rollatini Pasta
Homemade eggplant stuffed with ricotta cheese, tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
House Specialties
Saichipapa
Bandeja Paisa
Arroz, carne, huevo, maduro y Chicharrón.
Pescado Frito Con Arroz y Ensalada
Especial De Bandeja
Arroz, carne, huevo y maduros.
Maribel Special Pupusas De Carne Y Queso
Ensalada Elizabeth
lechuge, tomate y cebolla.
Grilled Chicken y Aguacate
Chicken with Green Banana Chips
Chicken Tacos
Desserts
Cannoli
Zeppoli
Tiramisu
Beverages
20 oz. Bottle
Choice of flavor.
Gatorage
Can
Choice of flavor.
1-Liter
Choice of flavor.
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
New to town and tried this place twice… Really impressive… Had chicken Parm the first time and chicken scarpariello the second … both amazing ..salad… Bread… Can’t beat the price point either… Friendly staff and nice cozy atmosphere… This place is a 🏅 winner!!!
June 2025
I went for lunch yesterday and the co-owner was at the restaurant. I told him about the disappointing lunch 2 weeks ago, and he knew since he read my review, and it was his brother who responded. I thought at least one slice of pizza would be deducted from the lunch bill, but it was not. I believe I will not be returning to the restaurant.
May 2025
You May Also Like
Il Goccino Ristorante - 33 Main St
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
Nahm Thai & French Cuisine - 41 Main St
![]()
Thai, French, Asian, Vegan
Bagel Chateau of Madison - 45 Main St
![]()
Bagels, Vegetarian
my mom had their chicken noodle soup and had been raving about it since
my father got a salad with salmon on it and the salmon was HUGE and cooked amazingly
me and my friends shared a margarita pizza and it was delicious! we couldn’t get enough!!