Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery
42 Lincoln Pl, Madison
(973) 377-9515
Customers' Favorites
Pizza Slice
Greek Salad
Menu
Photos
+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Right as you walk in you can order. You walk down to pay. Sometimes it can be crowded and it seems a little confusing on where to get drinks and pay (if it’s your first time here) Old man with white hair rung me up, didn’t say a word, doesn’t say my total either. That was somewhat a throw off. I basically tell him what I ordered then just paid with no word or anything. People who prepped and had my food were more enthusiastic. The food is really good, especially the size...
Superb staff, cute area and great food! The person at the counter greeted the locals in such warm friendly way, I can tell they enjoy going there. He knew them by name. He asked me if we were there before, after hearing no he was prompt to tell us about the menu and what comes with what. Good prices also.
Lovely atmosphere with amazing customer service. The person taking my order, Joel, was very helpful and recommended the penne vodka with grilled chicken. I’ve tried the same thing at various restaurants, and this one definitely beats them all! The penne was al dente and the chicken had perfect seasoning. The sauce was not too heavy nor was there too much. Also, I arrived at around 8:30, which is right before closing at 9. Joel kindly told me it was ok for me to dine in. Other...
You May Also Like
L'Allegria Restaurant - 11 Prospect St
![]()
Italian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
The Prospect Tavern - 14 Prospect St
![]()
American, Pubs, Bar, Vegetarian
Nautilus Diner - 97 Main St
![]()
Diner, Vegetarian