Brown Sugar Cookie Shop
$ • BakeryAbout Brown Sugar Cookie Shop
Add a Menu
Customers' Favorites
Black and White Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Brownie
Brown Sugar Cookie Shop Reviews
17 ratings
Share your opinion about Brown Sugar Cookie Shop
I asked Tricia to help me think of a way to surprise my brother with a Happy Pride treat, and she created the most FUN, delicious, and beautiful dozen of cookies! She quickly executed the order and is an amazing communicator! My brother is loving the cookies and I’ve been enjoying the photos wondering why I didn’t order a dozen for myself too! lol! Highly recommend
Got cupcakes made for a birthday party and they were very yummy! Would order again!
The cookie cake was moist and soft-perfect for a birthday celebration and you can add a custom happy birthday message on the cake by request.
Oreo cookies and oreo Brownies were great oarty treats. Peach cobler and Banana pudding flavors were standouts as well. Promt communication and clear instructions for pick-up as well. Would recommend for any party or event where you want cookies/brownies etc.
Oreo cookies and oreo Brownies were great oarty treats. Peach cobler and Banana pudding flavors were standouts as well. Promt communication and clear instructions for pick-up as well. Would recommend for any party or event where you want cookies/brownies etc.
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Brown Sugar Cookie Shop in Maplewood, NJ, is known for its delicious and fresh baked goods, including cookies, cookie cakes, and cupcakes. Customers appreciate the shop's helpful and accommodating staff, with prompt responses and reliable delivery, even on holidays like Labor Day. The cookies are consistently praised for their taste and quality, making them a favorite for special occasions and last-minute orders. Overall, Brown Sugar Cookie Shop is a trusted, friendly place that delivers tasty treats and excellent service.