Palmer's Bakehouse

1 Highland Pl, Maplewood
(973) 378-2027

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Keith Walcott

Outstanding baked goods. Pepper Chedder Biscuits put other establishments versions to shame !

Rosemarie Hollinger

I visited the bake house 2/19/25 it was recommended to me. I was in the area I purchased a few items. I wasn't please with the hand held pie for me it lacked moisture and flavored the corn muffin was also a little dry. The young sales girl was very friendly and pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ashley

Tried to go here a couple times, the food was disappointing for the price. Cookies and muffins were dry. Owner is always yelling at staff. Bad vibes.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Zoe

I visited this establishment today after receiving a recommendation to try it. I ordered a hot coffee and a sweet treat, but upon reaching the coffee station, I noticed there was no milk available. I requested a refill, and instead of simply refilling the milk, the owner decided to pour it directly into my already full cup. With my hands full, I struggled to secure the lid in time,
and hot coffee spilled onto my hands.

A customer in line saw what happened and showed more concern for me than the owner did. I immediately moved out the way to dry my hands and she continued to ring up the next customer, offering no acknowledgment for
the incident. She didn’t inquire whether I was okay, nor did she offer to replace my coffee.

I returned to my car, but the pain in my fingers soon intensified. My husband saw me and told me to go back inside and get some ice, as we were a distance from home. When I returned and asked for ice to alleviate the burn, there was no sign of empathy or acknowledgment from the owner.

Given the lack of care and attention I won’t be returning, nor will I be recommending this place to others.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Marta Monaco

Very nice and loved their home made bakery items

ADRIENNE

I just picked up my favorite corn muffins from Palmer's. I was using a digital gift card given to me by my staff for my bday (I know TMI lol]. Ethan showed exemplary customer service. He was friendly, made eye contact, and figured out how to use the gift card quickly. It's so important to have employees who are friendly and warm. Great hire Palmer's.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salted Corn Muffins

Mariah Steele (HolyGoldenCarter)

Got a chance to try it today and had the Rice Krispies Treat and Confetti Cookie. Great service, packaging, and taste! Will definitely be coming back again sometime.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Michele Callaham

First time experience and I would not come back. Very annoyed as I purchased two scones and a muffin - they were not cheap - and when I got home I realized the scones were totally inedible as they were stale and rock hard. It’s not unacceptable to pawn days old food off on customers pretending it’s fresh. I was really annoyed when I got home and realized. But it was too late to go back as I had made a special tripl to try out the bakery and don’t live close by. The corn muffin was just ok. Nothing special. The service was terrible. The lady was rude to me and in hindsight I should have left before even purchasing given the feeling that I was bothering the staff and given the bakery was completely empty. I couldn’t recommend.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Eliot Nelson Glenn

Yummy and beautiful cookies and donuts. Love the creative Asian flavors and innovative colors: Ube and pandan!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Alexandra Robinson

Amazing muffins (yes).

We've been coming to this location every Sunday for the past two years, but unfortunately, the service is consistently poor. The staff never greets customers—we've never received a hello, how are you, or goodbye. In 2024, I will no longer support businesses where I don't feel welcome.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Karen Herrera-Braverman

The absolute most scrumptious key lime pie I’ve ever experienced!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Olivia Biller

The oatmeal cookie sandwich was incredible— I am obsessed with the marshmallow filling!

Franklin Turner

The baked goods are amazing. Everything I tried has been extremely delicious, especially the banana bread and barbecue chicken pies. The people behind the counter are always extremely friendly and helpful. I love this bakery.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

yalda nikoomanesh

Stopped in for some afternoon coffee and ended up trying their scones. We tried the vanilla, carrot cake and cheddar/tomato scones. All three were outstanding! Such a gem. Definitely going back to try other treats - word on the street was that the quiche is also fantastic.

paul kochoa

Got the UBE PANNA COTTA. Was surprised that it was so good. A lot of Ube flavor. So sweet and tasty. Wife says, “Very good!” Also my son had the CHOCOLATE BUNDT CAKE, son gave it 10⭐️s! “That was SO good!” Wife says it was the best as well. Daughter had the CHOCOLATE MOUSSE and she loved it. The CHICKEN SPINACH HAND PIE was excellent, as per my wife. “Can we go back for more?”, says my daughter.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...