Betty's Seafood Shack
9315 Amherst Ave, Margate City
(609) 246-7411
Customers' Favorites
Fish 'N Chips - Beer Battered Cod
Steamers and Lettuce Lobster Roll
Beer Battered Cod Sandwich
Yellowfin Tuna Sashimi GF
Shrimp Box blkn Grilled
Betty's Stuffed Clam
Whole Belly Clam Roll
Cold Seafood Platter
Steamers GF Dozen
Crispy Onion Rings
Specials
Sunday Family Style Meal
Renee Naame's local fan-favorite Sunday Gravy. House-made meatballs with sweet sausage in tomato sauce, with tender pork over pasta, served with Caesar salad and Formica bread {{{Feeds 4}}}
Sunday Gravy Individual
Renee Naame's local fan-favorite Sunday Gravy. House made meatballs with sweet sausage in tomato sauce, with tender pork over pasta, served with Formica bread
Canadian Salmon
Canadian Salmon {Grilled or Blackened} served w/ fries & slaw, choice of sauce
Salt Water Taffy (1/2 dzn)
Salt Water Taffy (NJ) - Bright and briny with a taffy sweet finish. Saltwater Taffy Oyster is exclusively grown for Samuels Seafood Company by the Barnegat Oyster Collective. This Oyster is grown in the bay right next to Barnegat Light.This Oyster has a nice deep cup, with a tear drop shape to hold as much of the Oyster's liquor as possible. The cup was developed over about 18 months and was well worth the wait. Served with Luis's Mignonette, Betty's Cocktail Sauce & Lemon Wedges
Caramels ($5)
Small batch scratch-made Caramels made in Vermont Choose from Vanilla Bourbon, Vermont Maple Creams, Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels, Vermont Maple Caramels
Betty Vittles
Sweet Melissa Goodness Betty's Vittles (Dog Treats) 3 per orderFlour, whole wheat flour, peanut butter, oats, milk, eggs
Appetizers
Calamari
served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Meat Cocktail GF
Jumbo lump & colossal crab served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)5 OZ CRAB MEAT
Mahi Fingers
hand-breaded mahi served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Clams Casino
6 local top necks broiled w/ chopped clam, onion, pepper, bacon & breadcrumbs
Shrimp Cocktail GF
3 colossal 6/8's served w/ cocktail sauce & lemon
Seared Sesame Encrusted Tuna Sashimi GF
served w/ wasabi, ginger & a side of ponzuAPPROX 5-6 PIECES
Steamers GF (Dozen)
local middle neck clams - bigger than little necks & smaller than top necks - perfectly sweet size, served w/ warm seasoned butter
Betty's Stuffed Clam
(one) x-large clam shell baked w/ lotsa tender chopped clam, sautéed veggies, bacon & seasonings
Betty's Mac DADDY 'n Cheese
Luis' creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese
Betty's Lobster Mac DADDY 'n Cheese
chunks of lobster atop Chef Luis's creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese
Betty's Crab Mac DADDY 'n Cheese
jumbo lump crab atop Chef Luis's creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese
Onion Rings
served w/ a spicy aioli
Fried Pickles
served w/ a spicy aioli
Chowdahs/Soups
New England Clam Chowdah
Creamy Classic New England Chowdah with chopped clams, potato & topped w/ scallion
Lobster Bisque
Slow-simmered North Atlantic lobster in a roux-thickened lobster stock with Spanish sherry, light cream & a pinch of white pepper
Salads
Outta the Parc Salad
Betty's take on the classic warm shrimp salad. 3 massive 6/8 grilled shrimp served warm w/ our beurre blanc sauce, w/ fresh greens, roasted seasoned Italian tomatoes, shaved parmesan & avocado dressed w/ our house-made champagne vinaigrette
Classic Caesar Salad
fresh romaine w/ shaved parmesan & croutons, dressed in Renee Naame's iconic house-made Maloney's of Margate Caesar dressing IYKYK!
Boxes/Hand Breaded
Clam Strips Box
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Shrimp Box (FRIED)
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)4 Massive u6/8 SHRIMP
Combo - 2 Shrimp, 2 Scallops, Crab Cake (FRIED)
2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 2 large 10/20 scallops & 1 crab cake served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Fish 'n Chips - Beer Battered Cod
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Cake (1) Box (FRIED)
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Cake (2) Box (FRIED)
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Scallop Box (FRIED)
served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)5 EACH SCALLOPS
Boxes/Blackened or Grilled
Shrimp Box (GRILLED)
served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)4 Massive u6/8 SHRIMP
Combo - 2 Shrimp, 2 Scallops, Crab Cake (GRILLED)
2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 2 large 10/20 scallops & a crab cake, served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Yellowfin Tuna Box (GRILLED)
Yellowfin Tuna served rare unless otherwise requested, w/ Betty slaw & fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Scallop Box (GRILLED)
served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)5 EACH SCALLOPS
Yellowfin Tuna Box (BLACKENED)
Yellowfin Tuna served rare unless otherwise requested, w/ Betty slaw & fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Shrimp Box (BLACKENED)
served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)4 massive u6/8 SHRIMP
Scallop Box (BLACKENED)
served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)5 EACH SCALLOPS
Crab Cake (1) Box (BLACKENED)
served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Cake (1) Box (GRILLED)
served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Cake (2) Box (BLACKENED)
served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Crab Cake (2) Box (GRILLED)
served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Combo - 2 Shrimp, 2 Scallops, Crab Cake (BLACKENED)
2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 2 large 10/20 scallops & a crab cake, served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)
Lettuce Wraps (2) GF
Shrimp - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)
served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli4 EACH SHRIMP
Lobster - Lettuce Wrap
butter-poached chunks of cold water lobster meat served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli6 OZ LOBSTER MEAT
Jumbo Lump Crab - Lettuce Wrap
served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli
Yellowfin Tuna - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)
Yellowfin tuna, quickly seared served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli
Scallops - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)
served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli5 EACH SCALLOPS
Shrimp - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)
served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli4 EACH SHRIMP
Scallops - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)
served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli5 EACH SCALLOPS
Yellowfin Tuna - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)
Yellowfin tuna, quickly seared served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli
Hand Helds
Lobster Roll (ME)
Maine-style chilled lobster meat, mixed w/ very light seasoned mayo, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun add fries +4.5
Shrimp Roll
hand-breaded, grilled or blackened colossal 6/8 shrimp served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.53 EACH SHRIMP
Beer Battered Cod Sandwich
served w/ lettuce & pickles on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5
Scallop Roll
hand-breaded, grilled or blackened large 10/20 scallops, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.54 EACH SCALLOPS
Clam Strip Roll
hand-breaded clam strips, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5
Lobster Roll (CT)
Connecticut-style warm butter poached lobster meat, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun add fries +4.5
Sasquatch Lobster Roll (ME)
double the lobster meat, Maine-style chilled lobster meat mixed w/ very light seasoned mayo, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun add fries +4.5
Crab Cake Sandwich (FRIED)
served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5
Crab Cake Sandwich (BLACKENED)
served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5
Sasquatch Lobster Roll (CT)
double the lobster meat, Connecticut-style warm butter poached lobster meat served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun add fries +4.5
Crab Cake Sandwich (GRILLED)
served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5
One If By Land
Double Angus Smash Burger
w/ cheese, grilled w/ pickle & onion on a potato roll. add fries +4.5
Chicken Fingers
served w/ honey mustard. add fries +4.5
Catch & Cook
Catch & Cook
you bring us your freshly caught filets, we'll happily fry, blacken or grill up to 1lb per person. Includes Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) **reservations required | Please call ahead
Kids Meal
Kid Mahi Fingers
includes juice box & fries
Kid Chicken Fingers
includes juice box & fries
Kid Cheeseburger
includes juice box & fries
Kid Mac 'n Cheese
includes juice box & fries
Kid Shrimp
includes juice box & fries
Sides
Betty Slaw GF
Corn on Cob GF
Fresh Corn-Shucked here at Betty's none fresher, w/ side of butter
House Pickled Veggies GF
House-pickled carrots, cucumber & onion
Lamb Weston Fries GF
Lamb Weston Fries
Sautéed Garlic Broccoli GF
Desserts
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Sweet Melissa's Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie w/ delicious chocolate ganache topping
Frozen Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie
Sweet Melissa's Key Lime Pie, dipped in a hard chocolate shell, served on a stick
Extra Protein
Extra Lobster
5 oz Lobster Meat
Extra Scallops
3 each U10/20 Scallops
Extra Jumbo Lump Crab
5 oz Jumbo Lump Crab Meat
Extra Shrimp
3 each U6/8 Shrimp
Extra Tuna
available grilled or blackened 6-8oz filet cooked rare
Extra Avocado
Sauces (Additional Charge)
Ponzu
Tartar
Betty's Cocktail
Lemon Aioli
Spicy Mayo
Honey Mustard
Caesar Dressing
Champagne Vinny
Agua Fresca
Strawberry Lemonade
Cane Sugar Lemonade (no Fructose Corn Syrup) blended with Strawberries
Drinks
Diet Coke
Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry
Coke
Ginger Ale
Seltzer - Nixie
Apple Juice Box
Diet Arizona Arnold Palmer
Sweetened Pure Leaf Tea
Unsweetened Pure Leaf Tea
Cold Brew Coffee
Refill Cold Brew Coffee
Water
Pellegrino
Dr. Brown's Rootbeer
Catering + Parties
Lobster Roll BOX
Fries BOX
Corn on Cob BOX
Betty's Slaw BULK
Open Food
Open Food (NON TAX)
Service Fee (Non Tax)
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Was given this suggestion by a friend of a friend. The crab cake was all crab meat and a good size. The long island clam chowder was very good. And my beer batter cod sandwich was also very good.
October 2024
My wife and I had our wedding reception here. Steve and Robin are terrific people - they really know how to host a private event! The food was amazing (One of the best filets of my life, and crispy and scrumptious crab cakes). The appetizers (Calamari, Clams Casino, Clam Chowder & Fried Pickles) were dynamite.
Robin is a joy to work with - she made the process so easy from beginning to end! I highly recommend Betty’s to anyone interested in having a private...
Robin is a joy to work with - she made the process so easy from beginning to end! I highly recommend Betty’s to anyone interested in having a private...
October 2024
You May Also Like
Sofia Restaurant - 9314 Amherst Ave
![]()
Mediterranean, Greek, Vegetarian
Maynard's Cafe - 9306 Amherst Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
From the moment you step up to the shack, you’re greeted with the kind of coastal charm that feels like summer bottled up and served with Old Bay on top. The vibe? Effortlessly fun. The food? Off-the-charts good.
We came for lunch and ended up lingering the entire afternoon — because why would you want to leave? The seafood...