Cinnaholic

33 New St, Metuchen
(732) 318-6240

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Chip Banana Bread and Brownies
Cookies & Cream - Cookie Dough Scoop
Build Your Own Cinnamon Roll
Build Your Own Cinnastack
Very Berry Cinnamon Roll
Chocolate Chip Cookies
16 Oz Cookie Dough Tub
Cinnaholic Cake Roll
New York New York
Old Skool Roll

Featured items
Old Skool Roll
fresh baked cinnamon roll with vanilla frosting 730 Cal Contains the following: Soy
Very Berry Roll
cake batter frosting topped with fresh strawberries, blueberries, raspberry jam and powdered sugar Contains Soy
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Build Your Own Cinnamon Roll
customize your cinnamon roll with choice of frosting and topping(s) Contains Soy
Brownies
homemade fudge style brownie. customize with frostings and toppings! 530 Cal Contains the following Soy
Cookie Monster Roll
*customer favorite* cream cheese frosting topped with homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce Contains Soy 1107 Cal
8 Oz. Cookie Dough Tub
Chocolate Chip Banana Bread
fresh baked chocolate chip banana bread with our homemade brown sugar cinnamon mix baked in. customize with frostings and toppings! Contains the following Soy
Build Your Own - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with one frosting and one topping of your choice Contains the following Soy
Baby Buns
bite size rolls with your choice of one frosting flavor on the side. does not include toppings. serving size is 1 baby bun, 3 servings per package. 240 Cal Contains the following Soy
Caramel Apple Pie
caramel frosting topped with fresh apples, pecans, homemade pie crumble and caramel sauce Contains Soy, tree nuts Cal 960
Campfire S'mores Roll
marshmallow frosting topped with marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce Contains Soy Cal 854
Santa's Milk & Cookies Roll
French vanilla frosting, topped with 'oreos', chocolate chip cookie bites, sprinkles and powdered sugar.
Coke
Plain Roll
for the purists who want to skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness 470 Cal Contains the following Soy
Sunday's Sundae Cinnastack
Our gourmet roll frosted with chocolate frosting, topped with brownie bite, topped with a scoop of our homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, frosted with vanilla frosting, topped with sprinkles and chocolate sauce
Cinnadoodle Cookies
Hot Chocolate
Gingerbread House Roll
Gingerbread frosting topped with cinnadoodle cookie bites, graham cookies, and sprinkles

Limited Time Offerings
Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
Fresh made double chocolate chip cookies topped with crushed peppermint pieces and baked to perfection.
Gingerbread House Roll
Gingerbread frosting topped with cinnadoodle cookie bites, graham cookies, and sprinkles
Santa's Milk & Cookies Roll
French vanilla frosting, topped with 'oreos', chocolate chip cookie bites, sprinkles and powdered sugar.
Mini Chocolate Chip Peppermint Cookies By The Dozen
A dozen fresh made double chocolate chip mini cookies topped with crushed peppermint and baked to perfection.
Holiday Gift Box
Two customized cinnamon rolls with your choice of one frosting and one topping each, two mini cookies and two mini brownies. Please allow 2 hrs advance notice.
Santa's Milk & Cookies Box
DIY a gift to share with Santa or someone special this season. This box includes one plant based milk, two cookies of your choice, a piping bag filled with your favorite frosting flavor and two toppings to decorate your cookies. Please allow 2 hrs advance notice.

Signature Rolls
Build Your Own Cinnamon Roll
customize your cinnamon roll with choice of frosting and topping(s) Contains Soy
Cookie Monster Roll
*customer favorite* cream cheese frosting topped with homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce Contains Soy 1107 Cal
Caramel Apple Pie
caramel frosting topped with fresh apples, pecans, homemade pie crumble and caramel sauce Contains Soy, tree nuts Cal 960
Old Skool Roll
fresh baked cinnamon roll with vanilla frosting 730 Cal Contains the following: Soy
Very Berry Roll
cake batter frosting topped with fresh strawberries, blueberries, raspberry jam and powdered sugar Contains Soy
Campfire S'mores Roll
marshmallow frosting topped with marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce Contains Soy Cal 854
Plain Roll
for the purists who want to skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness 470 Cal Contains the following Soy
Strawberries & Cream Roll
cream cheese frosting topped with fresh strawberries and walnuts Contains Soy, tree nuts Cal 846
Shake Rattle & Roll
peanut butter frosting topped with homemade peanut butter cups, fresh bananas and pretzels Contains Soy + Peanuts
Blueberry Pie Roll
cream cheese frosting topped with homemade pie crumble and fresh blueberries
Raspberry Dream Roll
chocolate frosting topped with almonds and fresh raspberries 791 Cal Contains the following Tree nuts, Soy
Sparkle Berry Roll
chocolate frosting topped with sprinkles and fresh strawberries (sprinkle colors may vary) 738 calories
Tropical Bliss Roll
raspberry frosting topped with fresh bananas, blueberries and coconut 794 Cal

Local
Cinna-smackdown Roll
Cinnastack with caramel frosting, apples, pie crumble, cinnadoodle cookie dough scopp, old skool frosting and caramel sauce
Sunday's Sundae Cinnastack
Our gourmet roll frosted with chocolate frosting, topped with brownie bite, topped with a scoop of our homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, frosted with vanilla frosting, topped with sprinkles and chocolate sauce
Welcome To The Black Parade
Chocolate frosting with brownie bites, chocolate chips, and chocolate sauce
Can't Keep My Eyes Off Of You
Cake batter frosting with cookie dough, oreos, and chocolate sauce
New York, New York
Cream cheese frosting with fresh blueberries, graham cookies, and powdered sugar
Higher Love
Strawberry frosting with fresh strawberries, bananas, and seasonal sprinkles
Glory Days
Banana cream frosting with brownie bite, chocolate chips, and powdered sugar
Wanted Dead Or Alive
Caramel frosting with homemade peanut butter cups, pretzels, and chocolate sauce
Baby Buns Variety Pack
Baby buns by the dozen with a variety of toppings

Rolls By The Dozen
1/2 Dozen (6) Old Skool Rolls
our classic old skool rolls. (vanilla frosting) does not include toppings
1/2 Dozen (6) Plain Rolls (no Frosting)
skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness, plain cinnamon rolls by the dozen
1 Dozen (12) Plain Rolls (no Frosting)
skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness, plain cinnamon rolls by the dozen
1 Dozen (12) Old Skool Rolls
our classic old skool rolls. (vanilla frosting) does not include toppings
12 Pumpkin Shaped Rolls
pumpkin shaped cinnamon rolls topped with light old skool vanilla frosting
6 Pumpkin Shaped Rolls
pumpkin shaped cinnamon rolls topped with light old skool vanilla frosting

Beverages
Hot Chocolate
Iced Coffee
we proudly serve Gregory's Coffee - freshly brewed and locally sourced coffee
Hot Tea
Hot Coffee
we proudly serve Gregory's Coffee - freshly brewed and locally sourced coffee
Coke
Sprite
Dasani
Mini Milk - Chocolate
Silk Mini Milk
Mini Milk - Vanilla
Silk Mini Milk
Apple Juice
Orange Juice
Coffee Carrier
Gregory's Coffee - conveniently served in a 96oz portable & pourable box. --includes cups, lids, sugar & stirrer (no milk)

Cookie Dough
Build Your Own - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with one frosting and one topping of your choice Contains the following Soy
Confetti - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cake batter frosting and sprinkles (colors may vary) 459 Cal Contains the following Soy
8 Oz. Cookie Dough Tub
S'mores - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of marshmallow frosting, marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce 495 Cal Contains the following Soy
Mocha Madness - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of coffee frosting, chocolate sauce and a sprinkling of coffee dust 453 Cal Contains the following Soy
PB&J - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of peanut butter frosting and a drizzle of strawberry jam 450 Cal Contains the following Soy, Peanuts
16 Oz. Cookie Dough Tub
Cookies & Cream - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cream cheese frosting and "oreo" cookie morsels 498 Cal Contains the following Soy
Salted Elvis - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of peanut butter frosting, pretzel sticks and a slice of banana 468 Cal Contains the following Soy, Peanuts
Strawberries & Cream - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cream cheese frosting and fresh strawberries 439 Cal Contains the following Soy
German Chocolate - Cookie Dough Scoop
our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting, a brownie bite morsel, pecans and coconut 606 Cal Contains the following Tree nuts, Soy

More To Love
Brownies
homemade fudge style brownie. customize with frostings and toppings! 530 Cal Contains the following Soy
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Chocolate Chip Banana Bread
fresh baked chocolate chip banana bread with our homemade brown sugar cinnamon mix baked in. customize with frostings and toppings! Contains the following Soy
Baby Buns
bite size rolls with your choice of one frosting flavor on the side. does not include toppings. serving size is 1 baby bun, 3 servings per package. 240 Cal Contains the following Soy
Cinnadoodle Cookies
Small 2 Oz. Side Of Frosting
Side Of Topping
Build Your Own Cinnastack
when 2 become 1! choose a frosting and topping for the cinnamon roll then a frosting and topping of choice for the full-sized cookie dough scoop on top.
Large 8 Oz. Side Of Frosting
Apple Base Build Your Own - Not A Roll
Banana Base Build Your Own - Not A Roll

Trays
Yogurt Parfait By The Dozen
For a lighter and gluten friendly alternative, with layers of dairy-free vanilla yogurt and your choice of our gluten friendly toppings. Please allow 24 hours notice. This item has a prep time of 24 hrs. It may change when your order is available.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+77 photos
Photo credit: google
+76 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

✨Pretty… but is this just decoration?

Bright, clean, open space—very much a casual, in-and-out dessert spot. Big menu, lots of options, definitely gives “build-your-own sweet treat” energy. Staff was polite and let me know it’d be about 13 minutes for a fresh roll… which I didn’t mind at all because who doesn’t want a fresh cinnamon roll?

And the smell?
Cinnamon, sugar, warm dough filling the air—yeah, I’ll wait...
March 2026
Such a cozy little bakery! The cinnamon rolls are fresh, gooey, and made exactly how you want them. The staff was so kind and patient while I picked my toppings. Loved my experience — can’t wait to come back.
March 2026
We ordered Old Skool and Shake, Rattle, & Roll.

Overall they were too sweet for me (I still prefer “Asian-style sweet level”) but their peanut butter icing is delicious!!

Soft cinnamon roll base with many icing flavors and toppings to choose from.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Che Pizza - 21 Pearl St
Pizza, Seafood, Burgers, Vegan, Vegetarian
Menya Ramen House - 399 Main St
Ramen, Vegan, Vegetarian
Meximodo Metuchen – Cocina Mexicana & Tequila Bar - 5 Pearl St
Mexican, Comfort Food, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian

Cinnaholic

33 New St, Metuchen, NJ 08840
(732) 318-6240