Chocolate In the Oven Bake Shop

I ordered a custom Oreo cake for my husbands 30th birthday and the cake turned out amazing! It was so delicious and exactly what I wanted for the event!

The most delicious key lime pie I have ever had! My daughter and I stopped by on a hot day and were happy to learn that not only did they offer delicious baked goods but also sold ice cream too! Everything was beyond delicious. Customer service first class! And I am still in awe of the decor and the cupcake guitar my daughter absolutely loved.
Hoping to pop in again if in the area next time.

Best chocolate chip ever the best in PA and NJ and you guys trust me when I said it

By far the best bakery going! If you’re anywhere near Milford NJ it’s a must stop for your sweet tooth.

high quality bakery items and desserts. Lobster tails bursting with real whipped cream are outrageously delicious.

Ordered the cannoli cake for my husband’s birthday and everyone was raving about how delicious it was. The cake was also decorated exactly as I expected. They will be my go to for the foreseeable future.

Went yesterday for some treats for after dinner. Got 5 different things, and all were absolutely delicious. The service was awesome as well.

a real homey bakery not trying to be pretentious or faux-artisanal, the bakers here are artists and the kindest. everything here is delicious, i have yet to have something even mediocre, it's incredible

I ordered a birthday gift of 2X 6 cupcakes for my niece turning 2 today through doordash. The order was sent without any packaging(not even a paper bag packaging that all the restaurants use nationwide.

The order was dropped on the floor. On asking the delivery guy, he said it was handed to him just like by the shop. Reached out to shop manager and she literally said we dont give bags because its expensive for us and that the shop owner dont care if its a gift order or any hygiene issues.

Looked like All they care is the expense and profit. I dont know what else are the jeopardizing to cut down the expense. BEWARE.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

The owner made me 2 dozen chocolate cherry cream cheese Brownies that were the talk of a inauguration party I attended. Everyone wanted to know where I got the Brownies. The Brownies are like a food orgasm meets heaven .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely spectacular bakery! Found it on a drive and go weekly now. Everything is fresh, full of flavors and enjoyable

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pies, Sugar Cookies, Sfogliatella a Top Ten Italian Pastry

Best Boklava I've ever had!! Thank you, thank you Cathy!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oh BOY! Nothing but a great experience with this bakery. They went above and beyond in decoration, timing, and their overall service to help with our gender reveal! Plus, the cake is absolutely delicious.

We've previously gotten a birthday cake from here that was also amazing, too. We will absolutely be going back for all our future baked good needs.

Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice little gem in Milford for cookies, pastries, candy and ice cream. The staff is very nice and the location has so many treats to choose from. The strawberry ice cream was very good! We also had the chocolate strawberry cake for our daughters birthday and it was excellent! The chocolate cake was perfectly moist with the sweet out strawberry frosting. I highly recommend this location!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing find!!!! Pricey but who can blame them?
Best of the Best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5