Dutch’s Sandwich Shop
16 Church St, Montclair
(973) 939-5037
Customers' Favorites
Rick & Mortadella Sandwich
The Dutch Daddy Sandwich
Pastrami Umami Sandwich
Chicken Continental
Breakfast Sandwich
Philly Cheesesteak
Breakfast Burrito
Chicken Cutlets
The Italian Job
In the Heights
BEVERAGE
12 oz Coffee
20 oz coffee
Bottled Soda
Box Tropicana
C4
Can Soda
Celsius
Chocolate milk
Coconut Water
Gatorade
Hint
Kombucha
Mexican Coke
Mott's
Pelligrino
Poland Spring
Prime
Prime Energy
Saratoga Spring Water
Small water
Snapple
Starbucks nitro cold brew
Tropicana
Yoohoo
Netro cold brew
12 inch
Premium 12'
Turkey 12'
BREAKFAST SANDWICH
Avocado Toast
Avocado Toast w/Bacon
Becky
Becky Pollo
Bessie
Blame Canada
BLT
BLT w/Avocado
Breakfast Burrito
Church
Egg and cheese
GojuChang
Grove Street
It's Always Sunny
Johnny Cakes
Ohana
Tay Tay
The Double Dutch
The Dutch Daddy
The Fair Wage
6 inch
Premium 6'
Turkey 6'
BEEF & PORK
Braisin Saddles
In the Heights
Mama Odi's Muffaletta
Pastrami Umami
Philly cheesesteak
Pho Sure
Rhaenyra
Rick & Mortadella
Run Forrest Run (Panini)
Thai Me Up
The Italian Job
The Ricky Ricardo
The Titanic
The Van Helsing
Bread
$12
POULTRY
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Champagne Supernova
Chicken Continental
Drunken Chicken
Everybody Watchung Tonight
Fairway Grilled Chicken
Hacksaw Jim Duggan
Honey Honey
My Big Fat Greek Sandwich
Oscar
Swizz Beatzz (Panini)
The Chicken or the Egg
The Claremont
The Driver
The Hanzo
The Julius
Walnut St.
Young Turks
Grab and Go
Cheese
Extras
Hero
$14
VEGETARIAN
4 Cheese Grilled Cheese
Barkley Grilled Steak
Lafayette
No Ragrets Ratatouille
Popeye & Olive
The Capri
The Falafel Waffle
The Freshman
In the heights (vegetarian)
Grilled veggie sandwich
Te Fiti
Te Ka
Merchandise
Hats
Head band
SIDES
Bacon Ranch Chs Fries
Fries
Jalapeno Poppers
Nachos
Side Garden Salad
Side Salad
Soup of the Day
Sweet Corn Nugget
Sweet Potato Fries
Salads
The Dutch mean Green supreme
My big fat Greek salad
Everybody Watchung salad
Honey, hot chicken salad
The Daryl strawberry salad
The driver salad
The Italian Job salad
The Julius salad
The Popeye N' olive salad
Wings
Wings
SNACKS & STUFF
Baked Lays
Cheetos
Cookies
Dirty Chips
Doritos
Field trip Beef Jerky
Field Trip Meat Stick
Gum
Lays
Made good bars
Mentos
Natures Bakery Bars
Oreos
Pop Corners
Pressers
Skittles
Starbursts
SunChips
Twizzler
Welch's Fruit Snack
Brownies
Rice chips
Extras
Avocado
Hash browns
Hot pepper spread
Jalapeños
Lettuce
Olives
Onions
Tomatoes
Bacon
Cheeses
Cucumbers
Photos
+18 photos
+17 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I walked in didn’t know what to order, asked lady what’s the best sandwich (cold) and she told me the Cesar wrap with cutlet meat in it . I just took a bite that first crunch was fireeeee lol and fell in love instantly best Cesar wrap I’ve ever had hands down
June 2026
This isn’t some watered-down deli lineup… these sandwiches are built with personality and flavor.
🌀 The Dutch Caesar
Maybe one of the best Caesar wraps you’ll ever have. Dill pickle crunch, juicy chicken cutlet, that tangy Dutch sauce, pecorino Romano, shredded parm, croutons, and Caesar dressing all wrapped up.
🌀 What’s The Dill?
Chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, creamy havarti dill, fresh lettuce, chopped pickles,...
🌀 The Dutch Caesar
Maybe one of the best Caesar wraps you’ll ever have. Dill pickle crunch, juicy chicken cutlet, that tangy Dutch sauce, pecorino Romano, shredded parm, croutons, and Caesar dressing all wrapped up.
🌀 What’s The Dill?
Chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, creamy havarti dill, fresh lettuce, chopped pickles,...
February 2026
Everything I’ve ever had here tastes amazing! I’m super picky about something as simple as a Taylor Ham, egg & cheese & Dutch’s is one of my favorites! Can’t wait to continue to try new & fun items on the menu.
February 2026
You May Also Like
Montclair House Grill - 12 Church St
![]()
American, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian, Salad
Bar Franco - 5 Church St
![]()
Lounges, Italian, Pizza, Bar
pastaRAMEN - 6 S Fullerton Ave
![]()
Italian, Ramen, Vegan, Japanese