The young lady who works there wrapped all of my olive oil accordingly. You can gift them or keep them and I intend to do both. They are personalized by artist who personally painted each individual bottle. Love them and I intend to collect more. I am having special shelves put up in my kitchen for them.I bought a couple of mini olive oil bottles and a special bottle of vinaigrette! Ready for more soon!
Lorie Continelli
Must stop in! Can get delicious olive oil plus many other Italian specialities here. They also make a great cappuccino and had awesome pannetone over the holiday. Perfect place to snag a gift for a co worker or friend
HL A
Everything sold here is absolutely delicious. From the family pressed olive oil to the yummy sauces and spreads. I've given so many items from here as gifts...the last one being the mushroom truffle sauce. The review from my friend, "It's so unbelievably good!!!" Raving fan here! Check out Sicilia Mia. You won't be disappointed!
Cindy Swabsin
Love this place. I've been going since they opened. Their olive oil and food products are great. They'll even give you recipes to try on the pesto, etc. I love the hand painted bottles. Great for gifts. I highly recommend them!
Kyra
If you’re looking for high quality and delicious Italian products, definitely come here! They have wonderful olive oil, pestos, and you have to try the pistachio cream. The owner is from Sicily and shes so nice! She lets you try everything.
Mariita DeVarona
Excellent customer service and products!
Alfredo Rainuzzo
Found this little shop while strolling through Montclair.This place is fantastic, amazing products and the owner Rosa was very kind and welcoming, their Pistachio cream is addictive and their olive oil is Gorgeous! Highly recommended.
Alfredo Rainuzzo
Awesome place, glad I found it, fantastic products and super welcoming people!
Liz Copti
Everything. It is an experience onto itself like walking into your favorite Italian store in the heart of Sicily and being welcomed by your friends.
Jessica Maarek
This place is very special! They have handcrafted specialty food items directly from Italy and you will want to try everything! We have bought their chocolate and pistachio spreads (divine), their fresh pasta and sauces (amazing), their olive tapenades (deelish), their very special Balsamic vinegar and of course, we have bought their hand painted bottles of their very own, beautiful olive oil. Also, the owners couldn't be nicer or more welcoming. We highly recommend this place!
I absolutely love this place! It is becoming the talk of the town. I highly suggest this place if you are looking for gift ideas. Everything they sell here is fantastic. I especially love their hand-painted olive oil bottles and pistachio cream! The workers are so generous and nice! They make me feel like I am back in Sicily! I highly recommend!
Yashasvi Lohia
Wonderful tiny little store with exquisite olive oil, sauces, spreads, jams, etc. with even more wonderful owners! :)
Arti Shah
Molto delicioso sums it up! This little gem is filled with delights ... authentic and artesanal! Caterina is passionate, knowledgeable and full of creative ideas. And the best part ... you can sample all of it!! It’s a must visit while you’re strolling downtown Montclair! A few of my favorite things ... truffle and mushroom sauce, eggplant caponata, pistachio cream, red pesto sauce, lemon pasta, olive oil ... and so much more!
Exquisite Woman
Today I had the chance to visit this gem located in the heart of Montclair. The minute you step into this welcoming cozy space you realize this is the Cartier of olive oil. Sicilia Mia equals quality and style. The shelves are adorned with stunningly beautiful hand painted bottles of olive oil that shine like jewels through the window. There are many other imported Italian treats for your taste buds. I picked up a jar of lucious Italian pistachio cream, and an oh so decant white truffle honey and brace yourself... a serious jar of sardines and wild fennel tomato sauce. There is a lot more to see and the wonderful family members will introduce you to every offering. See for yourself and go spend some time visiting Sicily in Montclair.
joanna parzecki
Absolutely delicious! Like a mini vacation to Sicily. Truffle sauce and pistachio cream are perfect. I got a bottle of hand painted olive oil and balsamic vinegar as well. So excited to try new recipes
The young lady who works there wrapped all of my olive oil accordingly. You can gift them or keep them and I intend to do both. They are personalized by artist who personally painted each individual bottle. Love them and I intend to collect more. I am having special shelves put up in my kitchen for them.I bought a couple of mini olive oil bottles and a special bottle of vinaigrette! Ready for more soon!
Must stop in! Can get delicious olive oil plus many other Italian specialities here. They also make a great cappuccino and had awesome pannetone over the holiday. Perfect place to snag a gift for a co worker or friend
Everything sold here is absolutely delicious. From the family pressed olive oil to the yummy sauces and spreads. I've given so many items from here as gifts...the last one being the mushroom truffle sauce. The review from my friend, "It's so unbelievably good!!!" Raving fan here! Check out Sicilia Mia. You won't be disappointed!
Love this place. I've been going since they opened. Their olive oil and food products are great. They'll even give you recipes to try on the pesto, etc. I love the hand painted bottles. Great for gifts. I highly recommend them!
If you’re looking for high quality and delicious Italian products, definitely come here! They have wonderful olive oil, pestos, and you have to try the pistachio cream. The owner is from Sicily and shes so nice! She lets you try everything.
Excellent customer service and products!
Found this little shop while strolling through Montclair.This place is fantastic, amazing products and the owner Rosa was very kind and welcoming, their Pistachio cream is addictive and their olive oil is Gorgeous! Highly recommended.
Awesome place, glad I found it, fantastic products and super welcoming people!
Everything. It is an experience onto itself like walking into your favorite Italian store in the heart of Sicily and being welcomed by your friends.
This place is very special! They have handcrafted specialty food items directly from Italy and you will want to try everything! We have bought their chocolate and pistachio spreads (divine), their fresh pasta and sauces (amazing), their olive tapenades (deelish), their very special Balsamic vinegar and of course, we have bought their hand painted bottles of their very own, beautiful olive oil. Also, the owners couldn't be nicer or more welcoming. We highly recommend this place!
Restaurantji Recommends
I absolutely love this place! It is becoming the talk of the town. I highly suggest this place if you are looking for gift ideas. Everything they sell here is fantastic. I especially love their hand-painted olive oil bottles and pistachio cream! The workers are so generous and nice! They make me feel like I am back in Sicily! I highly recommend!
Wonderful tiny little store with exquisite olive oil, sauces, spreads, jams, etc. with even more wonderful owners! :)
Molto delicioso sums it up! This little gem is filled with delights ... authentic and artesanal! Caterina is passionate, knowledgeable and full of creative ideas. And the best part ... you can sample all of it!! It’s a must visit while you’re strolling downtown Montclair! A few of my favorite things ... truffle and mushroom sauce, eggplant caponata, pistachio cream, red pesto sauce, lemon pasta, olive oil ... and so much more!
Today I had the chance to visit this gem located in the heart of Montclair. The minute you step into this welcoming cozy space you realize this is the Cartier of olive oil. Sicilia Mia equals quality and style. The shelves are adorned with stunningly beautiful hand painted bottles of olive oil that shine like jewels through the window. There are many other imported Italian treats for your taste buds. I picked up a jar of lucious Italian pistachio cream, and an oh so decant white truffle honey and brace yourself... a serious jar of sardines and wild fennel tomato sauce. There is a lot more to see and the wonderful family members will introduce you to every offering. See for yourself and go spend some time visiting Sicily in Montclair.
Absolutely delicious! Like a mini vacation to Sicily. Truffle sauce and pistachio cream are perfect. I got a bottle of hand painted olive oil and balsamic vinegar as well. So excited to try new recipes
Loading...