Tony Boys Sandwich House Montclair

Big sandwich, excellent bread, very tasty. Really hit the spot. I typically save the second half of the West Coast (personally hold the bacon) for the next day and it’s even delicious cold.

Tony Boys is a sandwich lover’s dream! They have an insane selection of sandwiches — and as a vegetarian, I was so impressed by how many options there were for me. I went with friends, and the way we demolished our sandwiches says it all.

We tried the Eggplant Parm, the Angry Bird with eggplant, and the Lumpy with chicken — every single one was packed with flavor and seriously satisfying. My mouth is watering just thinking about it again. If you’re anywhere near this spot, do yourself a favor and go. You won’t regret it!

Memorial Day weekend just the wife and I. Ordered for the first time, enjoyed the food we will be back for more. Highly recommend

The salads are our favorite. Salad bowl can feed two people, chicken is well seasoned and the chop in the avocado.
small dining area
great staff

Let me try to make this concise because i’m quite passionate about Tony Boys. I . Love. This. Place. Work nearby and go out on the strip to buy lunch at least 3 days a week & TB’s has become a regular stop for me. The all-around good quality: from taste, to price, to time it takes to wait for an order, to the staff, ugh- everything. They’ve got multiple great menu items, the pickles are to die for, and its one of the most afforable places to go for a filling, tasty lunch around. *as i finish my #33 happily.*

Drunk Chicken sandwich is excellent. My girlfriend has had some different sandwiches and she loved them.

Super good! The service was great and the food was excellent. Super recommended

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Welcome to Montclair Tony Boys! Had the pleasure of stopping by here yesterday to try out one of many sandwich options on their menu. Opted for the avocado toast & a side of fries & it didn’t disappoint. Was filling without being too heavy & very tasty! The fries were also not oily or greasy. Browsing the menu you’ll find alot of different flavors & combos…and the manager also shared that all the cutlet options can be created with an eggplant substitute! Definitely give this place a try. The vibe is chill & artsy, lots of seating, great central location & 3 parking lots within a 5 min walk. You definitely won’t regret it :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Me and my family were in the area and came across this restaurant, and it did not disappoint. The sandwich's are huge ! You're getting what you're paying for. The french fries were fresh, and since I have a sweet tooth I had the milkshake, and it was bomb !

The service was friendly and quick. If you're looking for a good sandwich or even a salad, this is a great place to go to.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very impressed with the sandwiches! Found a new favorite sandwich spot. Highly recommend the chicken parm with vodka sauce!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had the Lumpy and it was excellent. The staff were really nice as well! Highly recommend!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Lumpy, Cheesesteak, Drunk

Phenomenal food being served in this brand new spot in town where I can honestly say there's alot of other sandwich shops in the area but very little competition to match the quality I found at Tony Boys. I personally have had the turkey & provolone sandwich and the Marra salad---both were freshly made to order, exactly to my specifications with quality ingredients and absolutely delicious. I need to also highlight on the sandwich, the obviously fresh baked Italian sub roll that was perfectly soft on the inside with a chewy, flavorful crust on the outside...yum, yum, yummy! For the salad, I asked they include eggplant and the chopped slices were impossibly thin, lightly breaded and seasoned to the gods. And they don't skimp on portion size either; I could have easily split both into separate meals. My latest order was the Boardwalk cheesesteak sandwich that I bought for my husband's lunch recently and he LOVED every bite. Basically, they checked off all the boxes: clean shop, great customer service, and of course outstanding food. If I could note any negative, I tried their signature lemonade and it seemed to have a funny aftertaste to me, so that drink was not to my liking. But other than that, I highly recommend giving them a try if you want an excellent, reasonably priced meal option for lunch or dinner. No pictures because we were focused on eating, lol.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Montclair’s hottest new sandwich shop. Gotta try the egg plant parmesan sandwich. They have a full menu of salads, subs, wraps, and even milkshakes! Glad we decided to stop by. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’m truly impressed with the presentation of the Sloppy Joe sandwich and French Fries on my first time ordering from Tony Boy’s new location in Montclair. Delicious and tasty 😋 Definitely going to be a regular customer and Welcome to Montclair.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandwiches are incredible! I absolutely love the excellent service and how spotless this place is. My favorite is the steak sandwich with onions and peppers, but the chicken cutlets are just as amazing. I’ll definitely be coming here more often!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5