Beenie's Ice Cream

$ • Ice Cream, Custom Cakes

Hours:
38 Morris St, Morristown
(862) 260-9221

Customers' Favorites

Beenie's Ice Cream Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.8 (83)
Restaurantji Rating

The flavors were terrific! I ended up having terrible diarrhea while enjoying the ice cream, but luckily I was in my car and was able to get home without anyone noticing. This was of no fault of Beenies Ice Cream or staff, I just have really bad lactose intolerance that I refuse to let control my life. I will be back!

Restaurantji Rating

So glad I finally stepped into Beenie's! The flavor options are vast and the texture of the ice cream is so smooth and creamy. I purchased a cold brew coffee ice cream and a brownie, caramel vanilla swirl. Both were so so good! I grabbed my ice cream and left, but I can absolutely see how younger kids would want to hang out for a while longer.

Restaurantji Rating

Lots of both classic and unique flavors here. A small size ice cream comes out to $5 and it's a generous portion in my opinion. They let you sample flavors before deciding, which is great because they have a lot of flavor combos with fun names to choose from. There's also a cute sitting area on the other side of the store set up like you're outside on picnic tables. Staff is always friendly when I come here. I thought the honey lavender was the perfect flavor without tasting too...read full review

More Reviews(311)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 12 - 10:30PM
Tuesday 12 - 10:30PM
Wednesday 12 - 10:30PM
Thursday 12 - 10:30PM
Friday 12 - 10:30PM
Saturday 12 - 10:30PM
Sunday 12 - 10:30PM
Updated on: