Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

1176 Sussex Turnpike Unit 2, Randolph
(973) 584-7482

Recent Reviews

Deepak Sukh

Quick service, many choices, delicious Italian icecream. Prices ok with coupons but otherwise too high

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Mango Gelato × 2

Jainam Shah

Forget the rest, Rita's Italian Ice reigns supreme in the world of refreshing, flavorful treats. Here's why Rita's blows the competition away:Flavor Frenzy: Walk into a Rita's and you're hit with a wave of mouthwatering options. They have a ridiculous (in the best way) variety of flavors, from classic mango and cherry to out-there picks like cotton candy watermelon. Plus, they rotate seasonal flavors, so there's always something new to try.Real Fruit Fusion: Unlike some Italian ices that taste vaguely fruity, Rita's packs a punch of real fruit flavor. You can practically taste the sunshine in every single bite.Texture that Tantalizes: Rita's Italian ice is unlike anything else. It's smooth and creamy, but with a delightful, light, and refreshing texture. It's the perfect balance between icy cool-down and flavor explosion.The Custard Combo: Rita's doesn't stop at just Italian ice. They offer delicious frozen custard, and the combo of the two, their signature Gelati, is pure magic. Creamy custard cools down the vibrant ice, creating a textural and taste bud party.Sweet for Every Sweet Tooth: With so many flavors and portion options, Rita's caters to everyone. Want a full-on brain freeze? Grab a large cup. Craving a lighter treat? They have sugar-free options too.Sure, you might find Italian ice elsewhere, but Rita's takes it to a whole new level. It's a delicious experience that keeps you coming back for more. So next time you're craving a cool treat, skip the generic and head to Rita's. Your taste buds will thank you.

Lauren Ciallella

Great ice cream, Italian ice and gelati’s . Only complaint is the parking is a bit of a hassle.

Ms. B.

how do you park there. big issue.called randolph township. still nothing done. shame on you randolph township for having them open. waiting for accidents to happen.

Lora Ann N.

Stopped in I was in the mood for some custard and mango ice. The girls were extremely nice. I will definitely be back.

Ellen Watson

Very close to my home

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Custard

Starlux Jeskopaw

Always loved their ice cream and Italian ices. Tastes great and almost never do they not have the flavor I want.

Starlux

Always loved their ice cream and Italian ices. Tastes great and almost never do they not have the flavor I want.

Helen R.

Custard ice cream cup was very creamy and had a great taste. Service was prompt. Store was clean and had a nice atmosphere. I am sure I will be back.

Wendy Perkins

The food was good, but the service was amazingly slow, and the portions were small for the price.

Stanley Moy

Always consistent and always great. Can’t get enough of their gelatis. Staff was friendly too. It’s dangerous for this to be so close to home. Will definitely be back.

Roquan Roquan

The girls working tonight turned away 8 customers that were waiting in line since 9:45 as soon at it was 10:00. ?‍♂️ Poor training. Poor customer service. Do better.At Cliff’s they’ll serve everyone in line before closing. They don’t turn customers in line away.

redbeardsaint

Line went fast, the girls were pleasant and really quick preparing the food. Parking is a little rough when busy.

Noreen S.

So happy to have a Rita's so close! They just opened so I am sure they are just getting up to speed. My wish is that there were another egress in the parking lot. Let's hope that's in the plans. Good luck to the owners!

Joe D.

Great place for a summer treat. Been to this location twice. I usually get the vanilla gelati with Swedish fish or cherry shaved ice. Service was good both times. You can only served from a service window which is similar to all locations that I am aware of. I will be back soon again

Load More