Big Jim's Pizzeria
281 Main Street, New Milford
(201) 262-4600
Customers' Favorites
Sicilian Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Knots
Sauce
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Okay pizza, but very overpriced. Charged $8.75 extra for vegetables on half a large pie, which was not disclosed to us when we ordered over the phone. It was over $50 for a large cheese pizza and a half pepperoni/half vegetable pie. Will not be going again.
Big Jim’s
279 Main St.
New Milford, NJ 07646
Rice Balls
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
The rice ball was packed with peas and chopped meat, but it could have been a tad bit bigger especially since the marinara cup actually looks bigger than the appetizer itself.
But the taste was pretty good and it was great starter to the meal.
The wrap did have a good chicken to lettuce ratio. The...
279 Main St.
New Milford, NJ 07646
Rice Balls
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
The rice ball was packed with peas and chopped meat, but it could have been a tad bit bigger especially since the marinara cup actually looks bigger than the appetizer itself.
But the taste was pretty good and it was great starter to the meal.
The wrap did have a good chicken to lettuce ratio. The...
Been getting pizza from this place for 40+ years, and the food is good most of the time. Biggest issue is their hours. 7:30 on a Monday night and you can’t get food delivered to your house. Gone are the days of ordering a late night snack, now you can’t even get dinner when you get home late from work.
You May Also Like
Lantern Chinese Take Out - 235 Main Street
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Pancho's Burritos - 214 Main Street
![]()
Mexican, Pet Friendly, Vegan
What's Cookin' - 201 Main Street
![]()
Caterers, Coffee & Tea, American