This is how they put my pizza in the box, the cheese from the slices under the paper got all stuck on the paper, WHO DOES THAT?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Samyak
The pizza tasted very bad. Sauce tasted weird, wasn’t heated up, the dough was pretty thick and uncooked, just overall a really bad slice of pizza. Would not recommend. That too for four dollars as compared to 1.5 in New York, poor taste and higher prices. If you are at Newark Penn station try other
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Jeff Bosacki
Their meatballs are amazing, and delicious dinner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
Sherene N.
Desperate situations call for desperate measures. We were running and gunning and starving. We picked the quickest thing available with 10 minutes to spare. We ordered 2 slices one mushroom and one sausage since no pepperoni was available. Service was subpar. Poor, actually. Almost as if I force them to work there. SMH. $15 for two 1 topping slices, bottled water, and a very small Tropicana juice. Absolutely flabbergasted. We pay. We eat. We are very disappointed. The sauce is straight out of a can, vinegary, and almost metallic. The mushrooms were strangely sour, almost bitter. My daughter said her sausage sliced tastes like a $1 microwavable pizza and eggs. (?!) Weird. He heated it up yet it was lukewarm. Chile, needless to say. Never again.
Henry Bastable
The pizza honestly just tasted horrible. Sauce tasted weird, wasn’t heated up, the dough was pretty thick and uncooked, just overall a really bad slice of pizza. Would not recommend.
Food: 1
Henry B.
Pizza was horrible, the sauce was weirdly bitter, and it tasted like it was reheated from last week. Crust and bottom were not cooked at all, overall, really crappy slice.
Chip C.
Pizza by the slice is good and convenient. I really enjoyed the pepperoni and sausage slice. Perhaps on the pricey side but convenience comes at a cost.
Nicholas Cirone
Utterly disappointed after a long Amtrak rude. Nothing else to day.
Equana Williams
Pizza is to thick & gross ??
J. Lamar H.
From the silent traveler to all of you welcome. So I just happen to be at the Penn station staying over at the DoubleTree One a slice of pizza they were the only thing open and close at the time. I will say the pizza is decent but just ask some reviews say get it extra heated. It helps with the flavor and the taste of the pizza. They have quite a few unique styles in there but you do get a pretty decent size at a pretty decent price. I got three slices for like 15 bucks and they run a specials so always ask what's the daily special. The atmosphere is not the greatest because it is in the subway/transit system and you got a lot of people in the area even those that are homeless. While I was there several homeless people were hanging around asking you know for food not money. So if you have a kind heart pay it forward cuz some people are misfortunate. And in summer just bums but go with where your heart tells you. All in all if you want a pizza you're in a rush this is a decent place to go now the other stuff that was there look suspect I look like it's been out for a while. So my advice get it first thing in the morning or right in the afternoon don't wait too late. From the silent travelers to all of you be safe be well be joyful.
It's the only pizza place in the station and the immediate area. It's not my first, second or even third choice but it's just there. The slices are a little heavy on the dough and the cheese isn't the best quality but again they have the advantage of being the only pizza place in Newark Penn So you are a captive audience if you want pizza well waiting for a train
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Susan Victoria
Love the Pizza! So good!!!
T. S.
This pizza is pretty bad. The sauces tastes like ragu and the crust is flavorless. I know it's a train station but it's NJ the pizza should be at least decent. A mushroom slice is $5 which I wouldn't care if it was actually good and not so small. Agree with the other reviewers to ask for it well done or else you're lucky if it's even a little warm.Also agree with the other reviewers that they should really close this place up and put in like a queen's pizza or just something else. I am 100% sure they would never pass a health inspection.(Again its train station pizza what do u expect BUT gateway is opening soon, attached to the station, and that will have a ton of food options!) The employees are nice but that's it.
Sir
The worst pizza in NJ. Wish they would close down and replace. Disgusting. Buyers beware. The dough is worse than the bottom of one's shoe.
Kyle B.
I wouldn't recommend it. The pizza is probably decent when it is warmed up. But from looks, it appeared as if it was made about a day or two ago. We eat with our eyes and my eyes said NO!!
This is how they put my pizza in the box, the cheese from the slices under the paper got all stuck on the paper, WHO DOES THAT?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza tasted very bad. Sauce tasted weird, wasn’t heated up, the dough was pretty thick and uncooked, just overall a really bad slice of pizza. Would not recommend. That too for four dollars as compared to 1.5 in New York, poor taste and higher prices. If you are at Newark Penn station try other
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Their meatballs are amazing, and delicious dinner.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
Desperate situations call for desperate measures. We were running and gunning and starving. We picked the quickest thing available with 10 minutes to spare. We ordered 2 slices one mushroom and one sausage since no pepperoni was available. Service was subpar. Poor, actually. Almost as if I force them to work there. SMH. $15 for two 1 topping slices, bottled water, and a very small Tropicana juice. Absolutely flabbergasted. We pay. We eat. We are very disappointed. The sauce is straight out of a can, vinegary, and almost metallic. The mushrooms were strangely sour, almost bitter. My daughter said her sausage sliced tastes like a $1 microwavable pizza and eggs. (?!) Weird. He heated it up yet it was lukewarm. Chile, needless to say. Never again.
The pizza honestly just tasted horrible. Sauce tasted weird, wasn’t heated up, the dough was pretty thick and uncooked, just overall a really bad slice of pizza. Would not recommend.
Food: 1
Pizza was horrible, the sauce was weirdly bitter, and it tasted like it was reheated from last week. Crust and bottom were not cooked at all, overall, really crappy slice.
Pizza by the slice is good and convenient. I really enjoyed the pepperoni and sausage slice. Perhaps on the pricey side but convenience comes at a cost.
Utterly disappointed after a long Amtrak rude. Nothing else to day.
Pizza is to thick & gross ??
From the silent traveler to all of you welcome. So I just happen to be at the Penn station staying over at the DoubleTree One a slice of pizza they were the only thing open and close at the time. I will say the pizza is decent but just ask some reviews say get it extra heated. It helps with the flavor and the taste of the pizza. They have quite a few unique styles in there but you do get a pretty decent size at a pretty decent price. I got three slices for like 15 bucks and they run a specials so always ask what's the daily special. The atmosphere is not the greatest because it is in the subway/transit system and you got a lot of people in the area even those that are homeless. While I was there several homeless people were hanging around asking you know for food not money. So if you have a kind heart pay it forward cuz some people are misfortunate. And in summer just bums but go with where your heart tells you. All in all if you want a pizza you're in a rush this is a decent place to go now the other stuff that was there look suspect I look like it's been out for a while. So my advice get it first thing in the morning or right in the afternoon don't wait too late. From the silent travelers to all of you be safe be well be joyful.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
It's the only pizza place in the station and the immediate area. It's not my first, second or even third choice but it's just there. The slices are a little heavy on the dough and the cheese isn't the best quality but again they have the advantage of being the only pizza place in Newark Penn So you are a captive audience if you want pizza well waiting for a train
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Love the Pizza! So good!!!
This pizza is pretty bad. The sauces tastes like ragu and the crust is flavorless. I know it's a train station but it's NJ the pizza should be at least decent. A mushroom slice is $5 which I wouldn't care if it was actually good and not so small. Agree with the other reviewers to ask for it well done or else you're lucky if it's even a little warm.Also agree with the other reviewers that they should really close this place up and put in like a queen's pizza or just something else. I am 100% sure they would never pass a health inspection.(Again its train station pizza what do u expect BUT gateway is opening soon, attached to the station, and that will have a ton of food options!) The employees are nice but that's it.
The worst pizza in NJ. Wish they would close down and replace. Disgusting. Buyers beware. The dough is worse than the bottom of one's shoe.
I wouldn't recommend it. The pizza is probably decent when it is warmed up. But from looks, it appeared as if it was made about a day or two ago. We eat with our eyes and my eyes said NO!!