Cupily Coffeehouse

339 Franklin Ave, Nutley
(973) 939-5770

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Natale Santacroce III

Big fan of this place me and my wife often go here and always enjoy what we get. Great spot for a fair priced local coffee, cold brew is what I get personally it’s strong, but I like it. They also have house made syrups with great flavors like French Toast. If you’re local definitely stop in.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

daphne mika

it’s so hard to find places with REAL food. everything nowadays is like frozen and warmed or premade but this place makes it fresh! it felt like i cooked it at home in my own kitchen and i love that so much!! it was also delicious. i stumbled across this place on accident in a rush to work and im so glad i did. the girls are so cute & friendly too i love a community driven place so much 10/10 will be back

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michelle Arevalo

BEST COFFEE SHOP IN NUTLEY!! The vibe is very cool and artsy, the food and coffee is SO tasty and the staff are always so friendly. My peppermint mocha was amazing and this is my go to spot whenever I have time in between meetings. 10/10 every time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andreea Petrescu

I debated whether to write this, but after what transpired, I don’t believe staying silent is appropriate.

I left a one-star review based on my personal experience at this coffee shop. In response, the owner chose to publicly post my full name on the business’s social media, encouraging ridicule and mockery from followers. I did not consent to having my name used for content or “clout,” and I would not have even known about these posts had multiple people not sent them to me.

To clarify why I left the one-star review:
From the moment I walked in, I did not feel welcomed. The atmosphere felt uncomfortable, and the interaction at the counter was cold and uninviting. I ordered an iced coffee, took a sip, and genuinely could not drink it—I threw it out. That was my experience, and reviews exist for that exact reason.

Rather than addressing feedback professionally, the owner chose to screenshot my review history, misrepresent it publicly, and create a false narrative suggesting that I target local businesses with negative reviews. That is simply untrue.

What is most troubling is the decision to escalate this situation repeatedly—multiple posts, sarcasm, and victim-playing—while continuing to publicly single me out by name. That behavior is unprofessional and inappropriate for any business owner, especially one who publicly promotes messages of kindness and anti-bullying.

This is a local business in the town I live in. I never intended for this to become public drama, but once my name was put on blast, I felt compelled to respond. I stand by my experience, and I stand by my right to share it without being harassed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

carlos reyes

Love this place! Everything was wonderful, from the coffee to the atmosphere. It’s cozy with friendly service and really good drinks definitely going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jackie Rizzi

One of my favorite cafes. The drinks and food have always been spot on, and the service and vibe even better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julia M

Amazing coffee and quick bites and pastries and the friendliest staff! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Denise Martinez

Pleasant staff, the breakfast sandwich I got was flavorful and the experience was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mariel Montana

This cafe is cute, cozy, and delightful. The baristas are very friendly and the coffee is delicious. I had their spam sandwich which hit the spot. There's a shelf that's filled with adorable journals, stationery, stickers, etc. that I can't help but look through every time I visit. Their ube brownies and brown butter chocolate chip cookies are the bomb. The park is down the street from it too. Highly recommend checking this place out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aon

I randomly stopped at this coffee shop, and I'm so glad I did. The latte I ordered was really good. Perfect texture and flavor. The staff were extremely friendly and I loved the overall vibe. There was something about the atmosphere that was really relaxing, maybe it was the great latte !!! Either way, I'd love to stop by here again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carl Picillo

Great coffee

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Alexa Bustos

Delicious food and wonderful service :)

James David Redding

Great coffee, cute shop, really nice people working there.

Enjoyed and planning to do so again.

Nick Maloney

Love this cafe! Great americano and the chocolate chip cookies smell AMAZING when they come fresh baked out of the oven.

adriel

I’ve become a regular here

The coffee is solid with a solid menu and a great rotation of seasonal options. I’ve tried all of their desserts too, and they’re all good at their worst and I’m eating 5 of their best in one sitting. The seating and atmosphere are great too, with lots of art and little decorative details.

Loading...