Mamma Mia’s Pizzeria

307 Bloomfield Ave, Nutley
(973) 667-4414

Recent Reviews

Teresa Z.

This place used to be great. Consistently delicious food at reasonable prices. We ordered from there last night and it was inedible and a ripoff. A chicken tender meal for $9 contained one small petrified piece of chicken and soggy shoe string fries. Their potato and egg sandwich was the same soggy fries thrown into an egg! Don't even get me started on the disco fries. No dancing involved there I assure you. The pizza was also disgusting. Thick awful tasting sauce on a bland hard crust. I called about the chicken tender "meal" and they didn't care. Offered us a discount on a future order. Like I'd want more of this garbage? I wondered if it had changed hands and see from the reviews that it has. Mystery solved. Never again. Just yuck. If you want great pizza and all around great food, you can't go wrong with Ralph's. I should have stuck with my first instinct.

Rachie D.

Mamma Mia's, you have my heart. I have never in my life been able to heat up pizza in the microwave and it be just as good as the first time I ate it. I order from Mamma Mia's multiple times a week not only because it's by my apartment, but because it's the best pizza shop I have ever tried. I love the owners, I love the staff. They make their food with love and at a great price, too. They have the BEST disco fries in the area. They also have the best marinara sauce, which I learned from ordering their delicious fried ravioli. I have tried so much from this place, but their pizza is really top notch. The amount of pizzas I've shared with my husband on movie night would shock you. There is never a day my husband and I argue about what is for dinner and end up both saying to each other, "Mamma Mia's?" We have no shame. If I want to be healthy, I go for their salads. If I want to bad, I go for their pizza. I've tried so many menu items from the cheese steak, garlic knots, jalapeño poppers, chicken parmigiana sandwich, grandmas pie, salads, bruschetta, and desserts. I have never had a single bad thing from this place and have never had any leftovers go past 1 day. I love this pizza shop. It deserves way higher reviews than it has. They also followed me back on Instagram without knowing how much of a fan I am. I respect that. As well as their menu deals and lunch specials. Fabulous and UNDERRATED. I've never heated up a chicken bacon ranch and have the ranch actually stay on it when I heat it up. This is THE pizza shop in the area and I can crown it as such because I am the pickiest eater when it comes to QUALITY.

Emily Velez

The place is small. So I would not eat there. But the food is absolutely delicious and staff is amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Hindy Garfinkel

We came here via TooGoodToGo. Glad to have discovered them through the app. Was very happy with the surprise box we got. We had two grandma slices, a cheese slice and garlic knots. The pizza was fresh and tasty. Will definitely be back for a full pie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andres Idrovo

My meat lovers pizza was delicious and loaded! Definitely order

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Cheryl Le Boeuf

Since this place opened I have been a very loyal customer always ordering from them. I felt their food was amazing. Unfortunately I don’t know what has changed but besides raising their prices a lot their quality has declined. They have a special 2 subs for $20. I got that all the time. Now the subs are 2 for $26! Raised it $6. Plus I get the Italian sub. The sandwich used to be so full of meat and now there is literally 2 slices of ham and one piece of salami! It was awful. This is the second time this has happened. So sorry to say I will look elsewhere!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Mark S.

Terrible pizza and service.Dont waste you money or your time. To many other good pizza places in the area than eating this garbage.

Brad Kelechava

My go-to in my neighborhood. The aromas that hit me the moment I step foot into this place take me back to the joys of walking into a pizzeria when I was a kid.Cheap lunch specials are perfect for my WFH days, and the pizza is stellar for dinner any day. I don't think I've had less than 4 slices on any occasion.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza

Rolando Llerena

Best pizza, sandwiches, and dinners around! I've searched different places for a good size sandwich, and most are small for the $$, Mama Mia's has HUGE sandwiches that taste amazing! I especially love the chicken cheese steak.We've ordered from here for a long time now and I've tried other places when they are closed, no one comes close.

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizza, Italian Sub, Sicilian

anthony duy

The people work there are nice and friendly and pizza are very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

mike70282

Great food and highly recommended… a friend from work recommended and it well worth it… well done

Steven C.

Good hometown pizza prices are great with some good specials. Can't beat there lunch specials just a solid place to get a pie or a sub.

Maryjane Zuniga

Definitely recommend!I went with my baby and had the Penne vodka pasta, garlic knots and fried ravioli and had a small pie. Everything was delicious, I came to visit from Virginia and it definitely was the best I have had in a long time! They also gave me the option to put something on the Tv for my baby ? they are under new management and are so friendly!Thank you guys !Wheelchair accessibility: There is space to accommodate for a wheel chair!Dietary restrictions: I do not eat pork and was assured no pork will touch the skillet or fryer !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Ana Hernandez

Great food, and great people in the kitchen, the new owner Omar promised fresh great food and that’s whatI got. And to top it off they gave me a military discount ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Laura Harbison

I ordered the Eggplant Rollatini pizza and it was FABULOUS. It was hot and delicious, arrived in under 30 minutes, and the price was great. The sauce is good and the eggplant/ricotta combo made this a winning combination. I intend to be a frequent customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More