Nutley Bagel Boy
Customers' Favorites
Pork Roll Egg and Cheese on an Everything Bagel
Bacon Egg and Cheese spk Extra Bacon
Lox and Bagel with Cream Cheese
Rainbow Mini Begal
Chicken Salad
Dozen Bagels
Muffins
Turkey
Recent Reviews
Lots of room for seating and extremely clean! The staff was super nice, and Khushal at the counter recommended a latte to add to my order. I’m so glad I got the French Toast Latte because it was SO good! I also got the eggplant parm, which was really tasty, and it came with a side of chips and salsa. I’ll definitely be coming back!
Nutley bagel boy has the greatest coffee of all time (GCOAT!). I love their hazelnut iced coffee. It’s delicious and I’m obsessed. They always seem to get the cream to hazelnut flavor ratio perfectly. I’ve been coming here a lot lately and today received my usual chocolate chip bagel with plain cream cheese. The amount of smear of cream cheese is an abomination if you reference this photo. This is the type of smear you’d only get at a regular...
I love this place and so does my family. The store is always clean, the food is always fresh and delicious, and the staff and owners are always super kind and accommodating. We door dash sometimes or go there to eat in or take it home. And noatter how we order, the food and service is consistently good!