Sugar Tree Cafe Nutley

358 Passaic Ave, Nutley
(973) 437-2300

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Deed Fried Cinnamon French Toast
Deep Fried Cinnamon Toast
Buffalo Chicken Empanada
Nutley Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Club Sandwich
Chocolate Croissant
Buffalo Sandwiches
S'Mores Milkshakes
Almond Croissant
Lobster Tostadas

Menu

Milk Shakes
Red Velvet Milkshake
Chocolate ice cream with red velvet cake, topped with whipped cream and sprinkles.
Chocolate Salted Caramel Milkshake
Chocolate ice cream, crushed pretzels, and caramel blend topped with whipped cream, a pinch of salt, caramel swirl, and crushed pretzels.
Funfetti Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream with rainbow icing, jelly beans , gummy bears and fruity pebbles, topped with whipped cream and sprinkles.
Vegan Joy Milkshake
A blend of frozen bananas, oat milk, and cocoa powder, topped with vegan whipped cream, sliced bananas, toasted almonds and coconut.
Cookies and Cream Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream and crushed Oreo cookie blend, topped with whipped cream, chocolate swirl and Oreo powder.
Strawberry Vegan Milkshake
A blend of vegan ice cream and fresh strawberries on a bed of fresh strawberries topped with whipped cream strawberry syrup and a vegan cookie.
S'mores Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream and graham cracker blend on a bed of graham crackers and chocolate chips, topped with whipped cream, toasted marshmallows and chocolate chips, and dusted with graham cracker.
Banana Pudding Milkshake
Vanilla bean ice cream blended with fresh bananas poured over nilla wafers with a caramel swirl. Topped with whipped cream and a nilla cookie.

Delights
Lobster Tostada
Chilled lobster meat tossed with mayo, pico de gallo, herbs, and old bay. the tortillas are fried and salted. The avocados are mashed and tossed with salt, lime juice, and herbs.
Cafe Sticky Wings
Seasoned with garlic, onion, old bay, and spices. They are dredged in 50 and 50 cornstarch and flour. BBQ sauce consists of sweet baby rays, smoked chipotle spice, and butter. 7 wings served with a side of ranch dressing.
DJ's Smash Burger
2- 4oz beef patties, white American cheddar cheese, house coffee spiced bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion & our signature house mayo. Pickle on the side.
Avocado Toast
Multigrain sour dough, fresh avocado and tomato confit, topped with Bibb lettuce.
Nitro Fries
Cajun seasoned, fried with rosemary and thyme with a side of hazelnut coffee aioli.
Deep Fried Cinnamon Toast
Brioche bread dipped in house-made cinnamon batter, deep-fried until golden. Tossed in cinnamon and sugar, plated with whipped cream, mixed berry jam, fresh berries, house-made hazelnut cream cheese, and drizzled with house-made maple honey syrup.
Mac N Cheese Bites
4 crispy mac and cheese bits served over house made marinara sauce.
Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese
Jersey's favorite breakfast sandwich served on a Brioche Bun.
Kid's Breakfast
Fruity pebble waffle with a side of eggs, fresh fruit and whipped cream. A kid's dream!
Waffle
Nutella swirl with fresh berries, whipped cream, and powdered sugar.
Passaic Ave Breakfast
Two eggs. Served with home fries, roasted tomato, multigrain toast, and your choice of meat, bacon, or chicken sausage.
Sugar Tree Omelette
Sun dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, spinach, prosciutto, goat cheese, and herb oil.
Matcha Pancakes
Two pancakes, tiramisu frosting, and cocoa powder.
The Notorious B.L.T.
Coffee spiced bacon, Bibb lettuce, confit tomatoes, thinly sliced avocado on sourdough bread. Served with our signature house aioli.
Greens & Things Power Salad
Baby spinach & quinoa dressed with a light citrus vinaigrette, topped with cherry tomatoes, sliced avocado, roasted chickpeas, pepitos, pomegranate seeds and feta cheese. A SUPERFOOD!
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Crispy chicken tenders with our homemade French fries and side of honey mustard.
Chicken Club
Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, tomato, and sharp white cheddar cheese with homemade ranch sauce.
Nutley Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken cutlet, sliced avocado, bacon, pesto aioli, served on toasted ciabatta bread.
Chickpea 'Tuna' Salad Sandwich
Chunky mixture of crushed chickpeas with a combination of celery, dill, onion, parsley & vegan Nala mayo. Served with Bibb lettuce and tomato slice on toasted multigrain toast.
Cubano Remix
Roast turkey and honey ham slices, with Swiss cheese. Cranberry-mustard relish and garlic aioli. Pressed toasted on a hoagie roll.
Build Your Own Omelette
Choose any 3 toppings.
Loaded Egg Muffins
Two mini frittatas including ham, peppers and cheddar.
Buffalo Chicken Empanadas
Shredded chicken, celery, carrots. Herb dipping sauce.
Cheese Empanada
Three cheese blend, smoked gouda, cheddar, mozzarella.

Coffee
Espresso
Cortado
Flatwhite
Latte
Macchiato
Mocha
Cappuccino

Tea
Matcha Latte
Orange Spice Tea
Pomegranate Raspberry Tea
Lemon Ginger Tea
Decaf Breakfast Tea
English Breakfast Tea
Green Tea with Jasmine Tea
Organic Peppermint Tea
Organic Chamomile Tea

Pastries
Monkey Bread
Almond Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
Chocolate Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
Buttery Croissant
A flaky French pastry.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This was my first time trying them and I absolutely loved everything I tried. We ordered the cinnamon French toast, Passaic breakfast platter, coquito latte, and green tea mango lemonade. 10s all across the board. I’m normally super critical about food and I had no complaints!! Will be coming back frequently!!
July 2026
Beautiful and clean inside. Kenneth, May and all of the staff are friendly and provided great service. Shakes, pancakes and everything else we tried were delicious. We highly recommend Sugar Tree Cafe.
July 2026
Thank you for the wonderful experience! The food was delicious, the service was warm and attentive, and the atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. Everything was fresh and well prepared. I’ll definitely be coming back and would highly recommend Sugar Tree Cafe to anyone looking for a great meal in Nutley!
July 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sonoma Bistro Bar and Grill - 350 Passaic Ave
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, American, Bistros, Vegetarian
Chestnut Cafe & Eatery - 338 Passaic Ave
Coffee & Tea, American, Pet Friendly
Trattoria Via Veneto - 144 Chestnut St
Italian, Vegetarian

Sugar Tree Cafe Nutley

358 Passaic Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
(973) 437-2300