Lake Hiawatha Dairy

79 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha
(973) 316-6686

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Zinal Rana

Ice- cream cakes available with delifferent delicious flavors.

George Faswa

Went in for a sugar free ice cream the options where vanilla or chocolate choose the chocolate but i think it was some kind of cake batter chocolate ice cream ( I do not like cake batter, cookie dough etc…..)
Which there were more sugar free options

Brian McNamara

So many flavors....so hard choices.
Great place and great ice cream

Shanmugavel SRD

🍦🍨

Fahad Idris

Great Ice Cream! Great prices! Great Service! Thanks Bianca for all your help!

Yanira M

Ice cream was denied to my friend and his son because my friends son had an accident inside the establishment. The kid is 5 years old and couldn't make it to the restroom in time. An ACCIDENT. My friend apologized and cleaned it up. Afterwards he went to ask for ice cream so he can go back home. But was denied since other people in there would be disgusted by it.
The kid cried and my friend asked again but was denied.
Horrible way to handle situations like this.

Kai Huang

I've never been disappointed. Staff always smile to you. and ice cream is always delicious.

Bobby McGuire

Great flavors!!

Kanika Ghocha

Gave them less than 24 hours notice and they turned around with an amazingly looking and tasting ice cream cake!
Loved the taste - as always! Been having their ice creams and ice-cream cakes for the last few years now and it is all soo good! Especially the “Mother Earth” and soft serves…
Highly recommend this cute ice cream place!

Meg Thorsen

We absolutely love this ice cream parlor! Highly recommended for those who live in the area.

Roseann Vryhof

Omg!!! I could not be more pleased with my cake! 💚 When ordering I said my Mom likes green and plants. Well, never did I think I’d get this beautiful creation!! 🥰🫶🏼💚 Huge shout out to Lake Hiawatha Dairy! Beautifully decorated and delicious, creamy ice cream! Thank you so much! My Mom is 92 years old and loved her cake so much! 🙌🏼💚

steven soprano

We had such a fantastic experience at The Dairy in Lake Hiawatha! Karen, the owner, and her daughter are not only incredibly talented but also genuinely kind and caring. They went above and beyond to create a stunning custom ice cream cake for my daughter's 6th birthday. From the beautiful decorations to the delicious flavor, every detail was thoughtfully crafted. You can tell they put their heart into their work.

The cake was a huge hit—my daughter was thrilled, and all the guests couldn’t stop talking about how good it tasted. It’s rare to find that perfect mix of quality, creativity, and outstanding customer service. If you're looking for a special treat or a custom cake that’s both beautiful and delicious, I can’t recommend The Dairy enough. We'll definitely be back!

Anjan Vaghasiya

Delicious ice cream
Try truffles chocolate very good

Vincent Cheung

Came in for a late night treat and the soft-serve was exactly what I was looking for!

Food: The large helping of soft-serve was super creamy and delicious down to the last bite. And even though the summer heat is starting to set in the soft serve held-up and melted very slowly.
Service: The friendly staff was very quick with our orders and with all the different ice cream flavors that enticed me, I will definitely make many return trips.
Atmosphere: This place has the energy of a local staple. It’s easy to imagine coming here with your basketball team after a game or after some finals. The seating area is also a big plus if you want to just sit, eat your ice cream, and chat.

Rajshree Mankala B

Great service, vareity of yummy flavors, that change every season to choose from!!

Loading...