Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co
Customers' Favorites
Ice Cream Orange Pineapple and Dulce De Leche
Black Raspberry Sherbet
Sugar Free Butter Pecan
Strawberry Cheesecake
Large Cup Ice Cream
Pistachio Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Twirl
Lemon Ice Cream
Ice Cream Flavor
Cookies & Cream
Menu
Menu
-
Junior Cup of Ice Cream $4.75
1 flavor and 2 toppings max.
-
Small Cup of Ice Cream $5.75
Up to 2 flavors, 3 toppings max.
-
Large Cup of Ice Cream $6.99
Up to 3 flavors, 3 toppings max.
-
Pint of Ice Cream $8.75
Fresh packed.
-
Quart $11.50
Fresh-packed.
-
Sundae $7.99
Comes with 1 or 2 flavors, 1 topping with whip cream and cherry. Can add up to 3 additional toppings for an extra cost.
-
Banana Boat $10.50
Comes with 2 or 3 flavors, 2 toppings, whip cream and cherry. Can add up to 6 additional toppings for an extra cost.
-
1/2 Gallon $10.00
Pre-packed.
-
2.5 Gallon Can $50.00
Party size for any occasion. Serves 30-50 people.
-
Tartufo $4.00
Classic ice cream dessert vanilla chocolate with cherry and almonds in the center covered by a chocolate shell.
-
Regular Cone $0.25
For 2.
-
Sugar Cone $0.50
For 1.
-
Waffle Cone $0.75
For 1.
-
Cup of Sprinkles $3.00
8 oz.
-
Cup of Topping $4.50
8 oz.
Beverages
-
Milkshake $6.75
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors and up to 3 toppings.
-
Malted Milkshake $6.99
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors - up to 3 toppings.
-
Root Beer Float $5.99
20 oz. 1 or 2 flavors.
Ice Pops
-
Paleton Fresh Fruit Pops $3.50
-
Character Face Pop $3.50
Spiderman, SpongeBob, PowerPuff.
Lucuma 1/2 Gallon
-
Peruvian Specialty Flavor $12.00
Pre-packed.
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The quality of the ice cream is very good and also the milkshakes are delicious … this place is priced very reasonably and I respect them so much for that …. You guys know how to run a great business congrats
August 2026
I tried them out just this past Saturday 8/8/26. Can't believe my good fortune. Someone told me about them, about how affordable they are and they were raving about the variety of flavors. They weren't lying. Thus place is tops. Thing to note though: They don't do cards. Strictly cash. Go prepared. Oh, did I mention the respectable way the guy who tended to me was? Three thumbs up 👍👍 👍
August 2026
Really great spot! Awesome service, tons of selection, and some flavors I didn't expect. It's in this cool historic building that used to be a stable and carriage house and is off the beaten path making parking easier than you would expect in this town. The owner was super nice and walked me through all the seasonal flavors they've got coming for fall and Christmas. I was also pleasantly surprised to see they make a Grape-Nuts ice cream (yes, the cereal!) that's...
August 2026