27 Best American Restaurants near Pitman

“When my mom goes on vacation she always likes to get breakfast at a diner. Many diners these days are very expensive making it hard to go out for breakfast. We saw a review someone online posted saying George’s Family Restaurant was affordable and that they really liked the food so we decided to try it. Both my mom and I ate for only $24.45. We both got the creamed chipped beef, my mom got coffee and I got cranberry juice and a water. The food didn’t take long to come out once we ordered, the creamed chipped beef looked and tasted fresh and not like it had been sitting in the kitchen awhile. The home fries were crispy and not mushy. The waitress was nice and she refilled my mom’s coffee without being asked. It was an affordable breakfast with a quiet and peaceful atmosphere. George’s Family Restaurant is definitely a place to stop and eat. I hope to try one of their lunches and dinners sometime.“

“Fantastic early dinner tonight! Guinness Pot Pie for the win! 🙌🏻“

“We went after a show at the theater. It was very busy, but we were at the register in under 5 minutes. The staff working today (5:30pm) were all so friendly, and kept the line moving efficiently. My daughter loved her ice cream!“

“This place has a nice, relaxed vibe, great food with good prices. We just had light appetizers including crab bisque, salad, chicken tenders and bread. The bisque was creamy and flavorful, the vinaigrette was tasty, and the bread soft and warm. We can't wait to go back and try more offerings!“

“Lula is a gracious host with friendly staff and great food. We just had a party of 18 and they just crushed it with the service, the food, and the atmosphere during a very busy night. Highly recommend for your parties or just grabbing a nice dinner before a show.“

“Our first visit there since before they closed down for COVID. Still excellent, courteous and efficient staff, quick service, generous portions, high quality. Five stars, highly recommended.“

“Me and My lady went here on a whim. I mean literally Caraba’s next door had over an hour wait and this place caught my eye. It was something different outside of our norm. So we went, the experience was amazing. The service was top notch, actually some of the best customer service I ever had. Was way beyond expectations, can’t say enough good things about Bree our server. She was quick, on top of things and had no problem explaining anything we wanted to know about the large variety of stuff they have on the menu and us never going there before. She talks to you and treats you like you are part of the family and she knows you,very friendly. Now for the food, again fast food but definitely better than expected. Very reasonably priced and good. Everything was fresh and good. The shakes were some the best we ever had. If I could give this place ten stars I would. Has an arcade and mini golf! What more could anyone ask for. Keep it up! Everyone there was friendly and wanted to be there. I told the host when we were walking out this place is excellent. He said that’s what we wanna hear,hope to see you here again next week at the same time Jokingly. This all Says a lot! We will be going back here many times to come. 👌“

“We had our daughter’s bridal shower there last weekend , the Wait Staff and Food were AMAZING !!!! We highly recommend for all your special occasions !!!!!“

“Great food and excellent service! The renovations look amazing!“

“Best service and the best drinks around!!!“

“My mom comes every two weeks and the last two weeks I decided to join her. We stop at each individual shop so I could check everything out. We always enjoy anything we ever buy from the Amish Market. I could not recommend them more. From their produce, to meat, to salad bar, wine and even their milkshakes will make you keep coming back for more!“

“Fantastic service! Our server Shannon is the best! She always remembers us and how we like everything! The food is very good but it’s the service that makes this Fridays a great experience!“

“Happy Hour is one of the best! Food is awesome and a great atmosphere!“

“friendly staff, yummy food, cool view! Had a great time with the kids!“

“My friend and I finally made it to the Barnsboro Inn for lunch today-really wish we had discovered this gem a long time ago. We couldn’t stop talking about how charming it was inside, beautifully decorated for autumn. Our waitress was perfect-attentive but not hovering. My friend ordered the chicken quesadillas and I had the tavern cheese steak and both were scrumptious. Next time, we plan on going for dinner hopefully when it’s decorated for Christmas.“

“I went to a wedding last night here. Eric the bar tender was AWESOME!!!! Dana the server was AMAZING!!!!! Their attitudes and customer service was outstanding! They are truly the definition of people who show up cause they love their job!!!!!! Shout out to them and i hope they get the recognition they deserve!!!!!“

“had the turkey meatball wrap with brown rice.....yup ill sure get it again“

“Great food and ice cream. We all had a lot of fun !!! Thank you.“

“If it wasn’t for Martina, we would have left but Martina is amazing and she made our day with her hospitality and service & phenomenal personality! She’s the best in this restaurant.
The atmosphere would have also been given a 5-star review but unfortunately the tv remotes were locked in the safe that no one could open. Hopefully the tv remotes can be accessed soon.

But just know the food is amazing and please make sure to go visit Martina at the bar.“

“The food is amazing here I love the mussels and the bacon scallops!

Sam the bartender is so sweet and makes the experience even better with such great service and a friendly personality. I also love the outdoor patio and bar area. Such a great atmosphere to relax, eat, and enjoy drinks!“

“Absolutely great for large parties, Baptism and weddings food is amazing and also newly remodeled“

“Best experience at a Friendly’s in a long time. Fast, friendly service. Very clean. Excellent customer service.“

“We got in late and we couldn't have had a better experience. My friend and I had our young kids with us after her son's kindergarten graduation. Our waiter was so gracious and helpful. Even the hostess was super accommodating when I asked if we could sit in a different location. The rest of our party arrived maybe 30 mins after, us but Christian (the waiter) didn't make us feel rushed or a bother. He was super kind, and patient with all the chaos we brought. The food also was on point. We would have mentioned it to the management personally, but I guess they were doing inventory. I just wanted to mention my friend lost her husband this past August, so last night was a hard one. Her son graduating kindergarten and his dad wasn't there to see it. You never know who you're serving, and your restaurant gave us a beautiful memory and I attribute much of that to the waiter who served us. Please pass the message on. Thanks!“

“This was such an amazing experience. From the food to the service to the atmosphere, everything was incredible. Perfect thing for an intimate dinner party with friends/family. Chef Shelby really knows what she’s doing, every course was absolutely delicious! Already thinking about when I’m going to plan my next one :)“

“Everything is pretty good here! Got the new grilled cheese burger…. good but cheese wasn’t melted!!! Half prices apps are the best deal. Good prices too, overall good but def went downhill throughout the years. Covid ruined everything!!“

“A great place to take kids to have fun“

“This was my first visit to a First Watch. And I must say that I was more than pleasantly surprised. The food was fresh and delicious. I was a bit skeptical about the Lemon Blueberry Cornbread, but was I way off on my skepticism, it was amazing, as was the rest of breakfast. Our server was equally as delightful. All around, a wonderful dining experience.“