50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pittsgrove

“Great service & weather Rode on our Harley“

“My Favorite place to eat. know the owner since he bought the place from Papi.“

“Best pizza in the whole area family owned and operated.we go here twice a week“

“Not since I have moved from South Jersey have I experienced a pizza as good as Big John's. My son graduated high school in June and we had our family pick up 4 party tray pizzas. All of our guess here in Nazareth, PA went nuts over the pies. Ever since, people always ask that when I make my next visit to Bridgeton, please get some Big John. I hope the people of Bridgeton realize just how blessed they are to have a place that can make such delicious pizza. Hats off to Doug, Chaz, Brian, and the rest of the crew at Big John's.“

“Just tore up a Grandma slice. Everything tasted super fresh. Hit the spot. Definitely gonna go back for another very soon.“

“we always want to stop but it's so busy. now we see why. parents can talk and kids have endless ways to play in eyesight. workers are very kind and professional. this will be a new favorite for us for years to come.“

“Excellent food and a huge selection! The people are great!“

“My family has been getting from Joe’s since we moved to the area when I was a little kid almost two decades ago so I figured it’s time to write a review. We’ve always loved it, and my grandpa has always been loyal to them usually only ever getting pizza from Joe’s and always at least once every few weeks. We’ve gotten from them probably hundreds and hundreds of times in my life and it’s always delicious and tastes like my childhood and makes me nostalgic. Never thought a pizza place could mean so much to me.
But yeah, absolutely delicious! My favorite lately that my grandpa keeps getting is one half of the pie with pineapple for me and my fiancé and we also love the Sicilian. A lot of time with pizza places I find myself either hating the sauce, or hating the crust, or the cheese. but this is one of the few places where I love them all and it just works so well. My family can’t recommend Joe’s enough!“

“As someone who loves to make pizza and truly appreciates the art of making pies and good pizza this place is fantastic! My wife’s parents live in Millville and while visiting we looked this place up, it’s a great pizza. I was mostly attracted because the story on the website was so endearing about how she started working at Big John’s in Bridgeton and worked her way up and this place was a nice ode to him. The story got me and when I tried the pizza I was so happy this was good. My toddler couldn’t stop saying mmmm good pizza, let’s say I was a bit jealous, he likes mine but loves theirs, I’ll have to step up my game :-).

I ordered the Italian Hoagie pizza, chicken parm pizza and omg they need to be on the map for how delicious they were such a creative idea for personal pan style. Also we got pepperoni, regular cheese, and veggie. My break down:

Dough- nice soft dough close to most delivery style, I definitely liked it because I didn’t leave one crust
Sauce- this was in my opinion stellar, it was a semi sweet sauce that was lite and not too heavy making it the right balance.
Cheese- excellent fresh mozzarella
Veggies- specifically my wife loves the sweet peppers on the pizza instead of the usual green pepper it was a sweeter one and I agree made all the difference.

I didn’t eat in the store but customer service was great. If it wasn’t 96 degrees out I would have eaten outside. Overall this place is a hidden gem in my opinion, surprised it’s not more famous, it should be as far as Vineland/Millville/bridgeton goes it’s my favorite spot. I wish them a lot of
Success because they deserve it!

Dietary restrictions: They do a crispy gluten free crust that looks good, my father in law is gluten free and he enjoyed it a lot.“

“Very delicious 😋 pizza and chicken sandwich“

“food is always good big portions good help Price is Right I highly recommend Nick's tell Gene and April sent you“

“Great pizza and wonderful people to deal with, I can’t get there enough! They even laugh at my bad jokes!“

“Recently moved to Millville & wanted to order pizza tonight. We weren’t sure where to order from so we read some reviews & decided to give Bim’s a try. We called up & spoke with Joe. He was fantastic! I loved his personality immediately.
We ordered one plain & one Onion, Sausage, & Peppers…. Instant hit with the whole family!! The crust was thin, crispy, & sturdy. The sauce was delicious. The cheese AND the way he distributes the cheese was perfection! My kids are literally still raving about it.
So happy we found such a good Go-To place so close to home.
Note: We are it to fast to take pictures lol.“

“Last Saturday we had a terrible accident with our cake for my nieces sweet 16 (not their work) I called Sandra at Jim Mains and she was able to make this beautiful cake out of the mess I brought in!! She did an amazing job!! Thank you all so much for your help!!!❤️❤️“

“just had a hoagie with long hot ...omg, soooo good. you need to put long hots as an option on your pizza. you will love it“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Danny's Pizza Pizzazz is a fantastic staple in Franklinville! The food is always fresh, and the traditional staff make the experience even more enjoyable with their warm hospitality. What I love most is the inviting atmosphere; it’s the perfect place to sit down and savor your slice in comfort.

They also offer delicious soups and desserts, which add to the overall dining experience. If you're looking for a great meal in a welcoming setting, I highly recommend Danny's Pizza Pizzazz!

Parking: Plenty of parking!

Kid-friendliness: Kid & family friendly!

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

“We had an incredible experience at Salvatore’s Pizza in Monroville! We ordered the eggplant parm sandwich, meat lovers pizza, and chicken wings, and each item was fantastic.The eggplant parm sandwich was perfect—was crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, flavorful, Not greasy!!The meat lovers pizza was packed with generous toppings and delicious!!!And the chicken wings? The chicken wings were a fantastic surprise. I didn’t expect wings this good from a pizza place! The food was prepared quickly, and the staff was super friendly. If you’re in Monroville and looking for great pizza and Italian comfort food, Salvatore’s is a must-try! Highly recommend!“

“Food is very good here! Good size portions. Hot and Fresh. Meatball Parm with French Fries. Boardwalk Style. And I've had Steak Quesadillas here. Both meals fed me twice. Pizza is also very good. Get a Large Plain Pie. Specials throughout the week each day! Breakfast on Sunday 8-3 which is cool. “

“great food! I really dont have anything negative to say but if I had to complain about anything it would be that they aren't open very late“

“This review is based on my one time here, so I haven't had much experience. However, the experience I did have was positive. The two pizzas I ordered did not skimp on the toppings and tasted pretty good. My favorite place is still Deli Plus, but the two I had here were tasty enough.The place was clean and the staff were friendly. They could see I had a bit of trouble walking so offered to take my pizzas to the car for me. I declined but it was nice of them to offer. The pizzas were done in a timely manner and I had no issues.“

“Unassuming from the outside, clearly used to be popular in 1996 for Dine-In. However once you get past the exterior the pizza is actually pretty solid.
I was shocked when I got home at how good it actually was. Would return next time I'm in town for a race event at NJMP.“

“This place has some of the best food in the area when it comes to pizza and subs. The Silician sub and the Meat Lover's pizza are excellent. This place is one of the few places that i would recommend getting a sub or pizza from when I use to live in that area.“

“The food here is amazing!!! I highly recommend their nachos and tacos. I know it's a pizza joint, but the quality and flavor of their Mexican dishes is a real hidden gem!“

“Great food and great people. This is my favorite spot in town to get pizza. Their Milano pie and white pizza are both top notch. Fried calzone and loaded fries are also excellent choices.“

“I am all about promoting and patronizing local businesses, and those who know me are aware of that and can verify that I never post negative anything about local businesses, until now. I received a menu with prices in the mail today offering delivery....I went on line to order and was taken to door dash which adds about $3.00 per item vs the menu I received plus charge a delivery fee. I then tried just going on Mannino's website which is powered by Slice and they also add an average of $2.50 per item vs the menu (I didn't get far enough into order to see if there is a delivery fee). Confused I called Mannino's and what a treat that was, I asked if they offered delivery from the store, well no one is here so use the on line ordering, I mentioned about being taken to Door Dash and Slice along with the price increases and delivery fees with a response of NOT their problem. I was also told to pick up my own food or don't order from them and was hung up on. This coming from the business that had a menu placed in my mailbox to solicitate more business. I can't testify to the quality of their food but can tell you they definitely lack in customer service and phone manners. Needless to say this is one local business I won't be patronizing.“

“I order from this place on average 3 to 4 times a month and sometimes even more.
Once in a while, my order is wrong some way or another, but I'll just ignore it and eat it anyway because the food is good.
This time, I ordered a cheesestake sub with Provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onions, which is $11.50 plus tax. My order was $13.00 even when I went in to pay, plus I gave a $2.00 tip totaling $15.00.
When I got home and opened my sandwich, it was just a plain Cheesestake with no L.TO.
Plain Cheesestakes are $9.50 plus tax. I couldn't call them back because by the time I got home they were closed.
I will call them tomorrow.“

“One of my favorite area places for pizza ?Great crust and flavor. I've only had their pizza and I almost always get just plain without toppings.

Parking: It in a small strip plaza so there only a few parking spots. Not usually a problem because people mostly pick up and don't dine in.“

“Romeo's Pizza & Ristorante is a hidden gem of a restaurant in Vineland

The food was amazing, the cleanliness of the area was perfect, and the service was spectacular. The staff were all friendly. One of my favorite things was that I got to see my pizza come out the oven and was cut fresh right in front of my eyes. The new limited time lemon pepper sauce was out of this world on my hot honey wings. 10 outta 10 experience. I will definitely come here again and recommend it to my friends and family!“

“I am all about promoting and patronizing local businesses, and those who know me are aware of that and can verify that I never post negative anything about local businesses, until now. I received a menu with prices in the mail today offering delivery....I went on line to order and was taken to door dash which adds about $3.00 per item vs the menu I received plus charge a delivery fee. I then tried just going on Mannino's website which is powered by Slice and they also add an average of $2.50 per item vs the menu (I didn't get far enough into order to see if there is a delivery fee). Confused I called Mannino's and what a treat that was, I asked if they offered delivery from the store, well no one is here so use the on line ordering, I mentioned about being taken to Door Dash and Slice along with the price increases and delivery fees with a response of NOT their problem. I was also told to pick up my own food or don't order from them and was hung up on. This coming from the business that had a menu placed in my mailbox to solicitate more business. I can't testify to the quality of their food but can tell you they definitely lack in customer service and phone manners. Needless to say this is one local business I won't be patronizing.“

“Usually I don't review, but hands down had one of the best Steak Stromboli last night. so delicious! Was very generous & tasty. Great jobs guys! Keep up that consistency & I will always come back. Definitely a must try, if you love Steak Stombolis.“

“I'm actually from Burlington county, but I specifically drive (1hr) to Carlo's pizza for their food. Their wings are the BEST around and the pizza is good too ! If you are in Vineland or surrounding areas and looking for the best wings and pizza; THIS IS THE PLACE !!!!!“

“first time ever getting food here. got a pizza with bacon and mushrooms. they did not skimp on the toppings and the dough was great. we will be back!“

“Been going here since the 80s. To be honest I stopped getting round pizzas from them in the late 2000s because they dropped off....but not lately. Wow...have they returned to their 1980s form. The round pizzas are super soft with chewy crust and tons of sauce. S&J is once again the best pizza place in NJ. Been going there for months now and every pizza I get is PERFRCT.“

“Awesome Cheese steak salad .“

“pizza was good... cheese steak sub was disappointing , very little meat and cheese for $11.99“

“My husband gave me a big surprise 70th birthday 🎂 party here on my birthday Dec.26,2024. Everyone who came said how much they enjoyed their meals & the other goodies Eric prepared for us. Eric even gave us all a bigger surprise when he came out with his instrument & played me happy birthday on it. Thank you very much for that,Eric.That was very sweet of you & you played it well. The staff all did great on taking care of such a large crowd. Also thank you to all the cooks,waitresses & Cathy too. 🤗“

“Can I give a sixth star!?? Excellent customer service even when they are busy which is hard to do when having to do it all day long but they really treat you like your special. They make the Best Eggplant Parm Sub you will ever eat, perfectly made every time. Awesome cheesteaks very good rolls they use for their subs. Their sauce on the eggplant and pizza is delicious everything I’ve gotten is made with love and they care about the customer being happy! Finally a restaurant that is perfect!! They have a very nice sized area to eat in with your family with comfy booths and a nice view out of the windows. Take my money cause you’ll be getting a lot of it lol A+“

“Just picked up my order! I used special offer, that saved me some money. Absolutely recommend our local Pizza Hut! Customer service is spectacular (big thanks to Lisa for some extra ranch and blue cheese dips). Food is DELICIOUS!!! 10/10 ?⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Thank goodness we finally have pizza delivery in our area. Good pie, nice sauce, doughy crust. Try the chicken parm pie with their full leaves of fresh basil on top. (Our favorite item on the menu) Their wings are good - albeit hit or miss. Sometimes, they're fried until the meat is crispy and tough, which is unfortunate. Try the hot and honey sauce, trust me. The garlic knots are always delicious. Their cheesteaks are comparable to most pizza joint's, they do chop them pretty finely, so beware if you don't enjoy chopped steak. The homemade soups are delicious. We love having the option to save coupons for a free pie, that's so generous.“

“Danny's White Pizza, Subs and Cheese Steaks are delicious. Employees are friendly, 5 stars!“

“Stopped in to get some lottery tix passing through and noticed the pizza in the glass display area, thought damn I gotta try one on a day I have time to order. Well next day I was passing through again and got a pepperoni pizza. I was thoroughly pleased with the taste and overall pie. Great pepperoni bite with some subtle sweetness in the pizza sauce. Will definitely order more and will try some sandwiches sometime too. The owner was a great guy who took care of me and was very friendly. Franco's pizza is good ya'll ?“

“Been wanting to try this place for a long time… finally got the opportunity to do so yesterday with my family. The food was fantastic and so was the service!“

“Very nice people and always good service. Really good food. Excellent pizza and my GF loves the cheeseburger sub. I've been coming here since 1987! One time I needed party trays for a graduation ceremony and they opened an hour early just for my order.“

“Great atmosphere and food“

“Highly recommend. The food was so good! I raved about it the whole time I ate it!“

“We tried a small plain pie well done, and the kids chicken fingers and fries. The pizza was decent, chicken fingers were great, the fries were kinda soggy and didn't taste that good. Everything for just Under $20. We will try different things next time!“

“Little Jim’s has been our go-to for take out since we moved to the area! Everything we have tried has all been delicious! We personally love the cheesesteaks, salads, burgers, and pizza of course. All fresh, large portions, and quick delivery! Thank you!“

“The food was hot, ready to go and cooked to perfection.

Vegetarian options: I'm definitely not vegetarian

Dietary restrictions: Eat what makes you happy

Parking: Very few spaces available

Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza! There pasta is great too.

Wheelchair accessibility: Just have them bring it out to you“

“Best pizza , wings and subs anywhere. Great food and Atmosphere“

“We stopped to eat with some friends at this beautiful place. The food is really good, from the main dishes to the French fries, I ordered some chicken enchiladas ? and their flavor is exquisite, without a doubt a place to return to eat every day with family, excellent service, I recommend it ? 10 out of 10 ?“