50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pleasantville

“Best food in town and Pizz is excellent, and very good people they treat you like family very good food 🥘 I love ❤️ it and my family to love 💕 it“

“The Garlic Knotts and 18" slices are the best. I travel from Toms River for their pizza!“

“We ordered delivery, and everyone was great-a very friendly person took our order, food was here within 30 minutes as promised, and the pizza and cheesesteak we ordered were delicious -I definitely give them 5 stars! Also, their prices are very reasonable.“

“Wonderful food I love bisteck a la Mexicana is delicious. ......“

“Totally recommend, delicious authentic Mexican food at a great price. Friendly staff, fast service. 10/10“

“It was Amazing and the server was great. Food was so so so delicious and a lot of it. We had bruschetta it was Amazing. I had a filet mignon wrap melted in my mouth. Highly recommend it.“

“First time going here this morning and I have to say 10 stars from the service to the food ..Amazing staff and the food is soooo good i recommend it and i will be returning ..thank you !!!“

“Best pizza and bonus is the super friendly staff, love coming here“

“Outstanding. We ordered 3 slices and were given a slice with pickles. Fresh squeezed 🍋 lemonade. Run to this place. Best on the OC boardwalk. Service with a smile. Thank you.“

“I ate here for the first time this summer when the first place I tried to go to had a line. I don't care how good the pizza is, I refuse to wait until a dozen or so people are done taking their time eating before I get seated. So I decided to come here and got the last available table without a wait.
Because one of my kids only eats plain, we had to get a plain pizza. It was gigantic. Biggest pizza I've seen before. The paper plates we were given were not quite enough to hold a slice, so we cut the ends off and finished them with the rest. It tasted good despite no toppings, and you can watch them make the pizza if you want.
The way you get your food is different, though. At the other pizza place we went to before, a waitress comes around like at a restaurant. Here, you have to order what you want where you walk in, and then sit down. They bring the pizza to your table, but be sure there's room. Not a big deal, but if you're not used to it, like we weren't, you could spend some time waiting for someone to take your order, and that person won't come. You have to get your own drinks to take with you, so be sure you have your entire order ready to go and pay for after you grab a table.
Between three of us, we couldn't finish the pie we got, so had to take the rest home, and it was fine the next day with a little oven reheating. Just be ready to have almost no room at your table once you get the pizza, as it's huge.“

“Wondering experience and quality of food.“

“The food exceeded my expectations. What's unique about this place is that they use a 3-day process to make the dough. And I can confidently say it's fantastic Pizza. The dough is incredibly light and airy and you dont full up too quickly. Staff and prices are also great“

“Went last week …. Best pizza and cheesesteak I’ve had in a very long time. Everything was so right about it !! Including the owners !! Amazing experience… try it ❤️👍🎉🍕“

“Stopped in for a quick slice. Was greeted with a warm smile and fast service. To my delight, there were a few extra slices added in order to try. The kindness and generosity was very appreciated. Always delicious and amazing service at Carluccios!“

“Good good, very nice peeps!“

“We try to go to Ocean City every summer, and we usually stop here for pizza. If you can get in without waiting in line, that's the best way. It's a little roomier than some of the other pizza places, and you can, of course, see the ocean from most seats, but the place is bright and fairly roomy for a boardwalk stop.
We've never had to wait long to have an order taken, and the servers have always been friendly. The pizza tastes good and the pies are actually pretty big. I can usually only finish two slices here where I could eat three or four anywhere else (but I try to avoid it). The only problem with the size of the pizza is table space. You're a bit crowded with that tray in the middle of the table, so be prepared. If you're lucky and there's an empty table next to you, you can use that and just get slices as you want them. We've taken pizza from here back home, which is an hour away, and it's been fine reheated the next day in the oven, and with the size of the pizza, there's usually some slices left over. if you can't use both hands to eat pizza, bring your own plastic cutlery, as the stuff they have is too weak and is frustrating to use. I have to cut my pizza up to eat with a fork and after this last time, now have harder cutlery ready for whenever I go back.“

“Please make sure you try Capri pizza in ventnor they have the most amazing food everything I have had there is delicious and the customer service is out of this world You would not be disappointed take my advice and order something it's a great place“

“Bought 17 pizzas for our bingo and pizza at ocean sands in seaville. pizza was a huge hit. very tasty . will definitely eat there again.“

“Great Food Great service 👍“

“Really good! Late afternoon meal and only had lunch food but all was super good. I consider myself a Burger officianado and the Hitzel burger was incredible. Fries had awesome seasoning. The small stromboli was huge. Staff was super friendly. We stopped there because it is a byob and a favorite brewery of mine is only 50 yards away so had some fresh brew with a great meal.“

“We tried their cheese pizza special and it was extremely close to Sacko Subs cheese pizza- which is very good. We haven’t tried too many other things from Eddie’s menu but so far they’ve been very good. They’re nice people that work there, too.“

“Awesome experience overall!!!“

“We ordered food for a fundraiser we got a bag of chips a drink and either a salad or a sub for a good deal! We were very pleased.“

“Today was my first time here with my friend. It was delicious! The slices are pretty big, definitely one can do the job. The owner has an amazing personality and all of the workers make it even better, especially the lady that works up front. We will definitely be back!“

“Very hearty fare made with love at great prices!“

“We started ordering about a month ago, and now it’s a staple in our take out rotation. Personable, inexpensive, completely homemade, and perfect for the nights you don’t want to cook. Great chicken tenders and the chicken bacon ranch wrap is out of this world. Great service!!“

“Always delicious, fantastic service & they know you by name!!! ❤️“

“I have never had a bad experience with Primo’s. They always answer their phones, are reasonably priced, food is delicious, restaurant is clean, and delivery staff is ALWAYS pleasant! My favorite is their Sicilian pizza. So good!“

“BEST TUNA!!! Never had a bad meal“

“good and fun，kids are happy“

“The BEST place!! Horchata is amazing! Everything is amazing!“

“The food and Service are top notch. I had stopped going years ago but am so glad we had our family Christmas celebration here and it was fantastic. They went above and beyond. We've been numerous times since and each time is better than before. Portions are insane!“

“Excellent cheese steaks drove 4 hours from Baltimore to get one“

“They make a great thin crust pizza. My husband and I usually stop there and share one before we go into the casino. The people who work there are usually very nice and friendly. The reason I gave them four instead of five stores is because their sauce is a little on the bland side. I should spice it up a little. Other than that it’s very good and always fresh.“

“Hands down the best pizza spot around! The coal-fired crust is perfectly crispy and the toppings are always fresh and generous. The staff is super friendly and the service is fast, even when they’re busy. The restaurant has a great vibe, clean, welcoming, and perfect for a quick bite or a sit-down meal. Everything we tried was delicious and you can tell they really care about quality. 🍕🔥“

“I highly recommend this restaurant, not only they have delicious food, their staff are also very professional, polite,and very well trained. Tonight I ordered food and I realized that my can of pepsi is not there and I asked the driver Tom where my pepsi is? and he said he didnt have it and he will go back to the restaurant and deliver it back to my house. So, since it is only 1 can of pepsi that was missing from my order, so I told him not to bother bringing it back because its not a big deal for me. so he said are you sure? I said yes. Few minutes later after I was done eating and really craving for my pepsi, I heard a door bell, and it was tom! came back and delivered my pepsi! I was more statisfied about my dinner! Ninos management should recognize staff like tom! he is by far the most sweet, polite and professional delivery person I have ever encountered. Great job Tom!“

“Never disappoints, get quality food, delicious and fresh! Been going here for 2 decades and it’s still the same great taste!“

“Only takeout service due to staffing shortage. But our order was brought out to us hot and we enjoyed their sidewalk seating to eat our lunch. Been here many times over the years. It has not disappointed us.“

“First time at this place tonight, I've been all over for pizza but this place here tops them all! I've learned they also have a place on the boardwalk AC which was rated number 1 out of 6 places that were tested! I'll never go anywhere else again, this was just a quick stop on the way home from work.... I found a pizza gold mine. Also it's not just the pizza, it's family owned & the owner I met tonight is one hell of a guy. Can't give this place enough credit. Class A Class A“

“Wonderful homemade pastas, sauces, mozzarella cheese and baked goods“

“Both r excellent! After reading some of the Comments I’m confused because the woman Behind the counter couldn’t be nicer. Never used Delivery or on line orders but pick up was easy and ready when I arrived. I love the pizza esp Grandmas. Def try it for urself!“

“food was so delicious & it was fast service too“

“Friendly Staff and affordable!“

“The food was delicious! Outstanding service as well! Large portions and the desert was exceptional! Would definitely go back!“

“First time there. Friendly staff and excellent food and service. Nice portions, great taste. Will be back.“

“Great pizza, great prices and they deliver!“

“WOW! IM SO HAPPY TO FIND A RESTAURANT WHERE THEY WILL PUT SAUCE INSIDE MY CALLAZONE AND THE SIZE WAS GREAT AS WELL. THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME MY MONEYS WORTH. I WILL DEFFINITLY ORDER FROM YOU AGAIN.“

“Great food great service 😋😋“

“If you value amazing food cooked with love and can get past the divey indoor seating (which is not even that bad) you will fall in love with Tony Baloneys! Unique and delicious eats. Can’t wait to eat our way through the whole menu!“

“Love this place!!! Everything I have ordered has always been great!!! We've ordered about 10 times and each time I'm blown away. They offer delivery and pick up which are super convenient. I love that they put out special menu items too!!!!! Highly recommend Nonna's!!!“