Restaurants near Plumsted

“I remember when Tootsie had the diner in Cookstown next to the Getty station....was always great food with a fabulous smile on her face!”

“We went to this restaurant after an event. We ordered appetizers as well as pizza and sandwiches. Everything was excellent. The staff were awesome as well. I highly recommend Anthony’s.”

“My first time at this restaurant, the greeting was pleasant the atmosphere was nice, and the food was great. Thank you very much will highly recommend this place going ”

“Food was excellent! I’m a foodie, and have had seafood Alfredo at many places. This was by far De Best!!”

“This place is excellent. Keep in mind its cash only, with an ATM located inside. My first time there was sort of forced, when i was younger i was not open to different food like this. Now i find myself at this establishment multiple times a month. This time i had the saint patty day special. Corned beef with cabbage, and potato soup. Very good. Also tried the brat salad (i think it was called) which is german bologna with tomatos, onions, and maybe cucumber. It was extremely good. The kartoffelpuffers (potato pancakes) are amazing, the spatzel (fried german noodles) are my favorite. And the beef stew is like no other. Ive never had anything bad off this menu. The desserts are great as well.”

“TKs is my favorite ice cream place. I also ride a motorcycle so they're the perfect bike meet spot. They're so accommodating and friendly.”

“So glad we stopped in! Woodys was exactly what we needed after a long day of driving. Walked in and felt like home. Our server Chelsea was such a puddin’ start to finish. The hot turkey sandwich and waffle sundae put me into a perfect food coma. Best stop on our trip. Much luck to you!”

“Amazing little find off the road. The owner is super friendly and personable and went out of his way to make sure we got everything we needed. The food is all incredible, we tried three different items and liked them all. Chicken tenders were delicious!”

“Enzo , his wife, Anna and their sister-in-law are the nicest people you would want to meet along with some really delicious pizzas. The pizza, as my cousin from South Carolina would say "is blazin' cuz" with a crispy thin crust, a delicious homemade sauce along with generous toppings. With each bite, you can taste every ingredient in and on the pizza. Nothing gets left on the plate with the crust being just as good. Also, try their meatball sandwiches which will surely fill you up and have you coming back week after week. Nothing says "New Jersey" like "Bella Napoli"! Try getting a taste of that in other states. HA!”

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!”

“First time here and I was pleasantly surprised; I didn't know it was a sitdown as well as a takeaway. There was plenty of table and counter seating, and everything was clean. I was greeted and given an ETA of my food, which was spot on for the 15 minutes they promised.

I had the Monster Gyro (Lamb, chicken, and falafel) and the shrimp. The lettuce was still crispy when I got home, the proteins were evenly portioned, and the spicy sauce had just the right amount of heat. The gyro itself held up well for the trip home.

I've had Gyros at several places up and down the state and this one is a contender for my taste.”

“Always good specials and very tasty food! Everything is fresh! Just wish they had a counter to sit at!”

“We had a Birthday party here oct 5, 2024 in a private room and we were very pleased with everything from the food to the service. Our servers were fabulous!!!! would definitely recommend to everyone.”

“The best bagel store in Jersey! Highly recommend”

“Love the pizza here. It reminds me of home. Brooklyn, NY. Would recommend 10 out of 10. Try the buffalo chicken with breaded chicken, that’s my favorite.”

“This is our go to for bagels!! their desserts are great too but best bagels I've had! there's nothing like a little coffee, bagel and conversation in a small hometown shop with great people!”

“Full disclosure, i am a meat eater, but really love the vegetarian/vegan options they have here. I just had their vegan taco salad and could not tell it did not contain meat. It was delicious!”

“I love old school style family-owned restaurants. Especially when I'm visiting family in New Jersey. We don't have very many of these in Florida, hardly any at all. This is a place that my wife used to go to when she was in High School. It has a great family dining atmosphere and excellent food.”

“I am going to be honest. I Love mangia and Enzo’s BUT this pizza is honestly my favorite. It’s not too greasy and it hits the spot every single time. Most definitely will recommend to everyone. Excellent!”

“Drove over an hour to get cookiepus and fudge the whale! Order on the phone with Brooke she was so friendly and helpful and Jade helped me out when picking up she was also very friendly and helpful and a pleasure to talk to! Highly recommend this carvel ! Worth the drive!!”

“Looked a place up on the way home. Found this. Has good reviews. Drove up. First impressions uhh is this place abandoned? There's people inside. Parked and went in. The staff was friendly and inviting. We sat in. The food was good. They didn't really have drinks besides bottled water. Which is fine for me. Food came out in a good amount of time. Fairly priced.”

“the kindness of the waiters and staff! nice atmosphere. I have been there today and had a big laugh and fun thanks to w. Barbara. lol”

“The salads are BIG and there are severals options to choose from. My favorite it the House salad and Yordanas salad. The bruschetta is always fresh and delicious. Chicken Saltimbuco is my dh favorite. Also a great place to buy catered meals!”

“The crew and vibe are always a good time, they host awesome events! And we enjoy their Tractor Pullin pale ale.”

“Friendly staff, large portions! Excellent food! I enjoyed the food and will b back!!”

“This place was interesting. I went there for food, and realized it's in a top golf. The food was not as expensive as I expected, and it was also better than I expected. The atmosphere was really weird tho. It felt like I was in a new car dealership with LED lights and a smell of rubber.

With that said, I still give it an 8/10. The staff were very friendly, the food was great, it was pretty cheap, I had a good time. Just be ready to be surrounded by top golf dad's ?”

“Love this place! I’m from a small town in the middle of America, the birth place of cashew chicken and this place reminds me of home. Comfort quality Chinese food with great service!”

“Really good Mexican food in a small location. Everything we ordered was delicious and some of the best Mexican food I've had. Also happy to find out that almost everything is made with corn tortillas and gluten free.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free”

“Just had an amazing chicken Parm sub with vodka sauce.”

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!”