14 Best Italian Restaurants near Plumsted

“I experieced eggplant par.with peni noodles garlic and olive oil tasted good. My son had california cheese steak and enjoyed it. Waitress was very pleasant and went out of her way to make sure we had everthibg we need to have an enjoyable dinner.“

“Food was excellent! I’m a foodie, and have had seafood Alfredo at many places. This was by far De Best!!“

“We had a Birthday party here oct 5, 2024 in a private room and we were very pleased with everything from the food to the service. Our servers were fabulous!!!! would definitely recommend to everyone.“

“Friendly staff, large portions! Excellent food! I enjoyed the food and will b back!!“

“Visited here for lunch with my children as we were passing through NJ on our way home from a holiday visit with family. Saw the great reviews and decided to try it out. We got Italian subs and pizza. The subs were absolutely delicious. Crisp, toasted bread, fresh meat and veggies, yummy sauce. We all loved them. And the pizzas were great too! We will make this a regular stop whenever passing through NJ again.“

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!“

“Whenever I am home visiting family and friends ITALIAN VILLA is my go to spot! The food is superb! The staff is very knowledgeable if you are unsure of the homemade pasta types or want to try something different on the menu. All of the food is delicious and appealing to the senses. If you haven't been here before you should visit when you are in the area. Trust me as we drive up from Virginia several times a year and replenish our souls! Special thanks to the Scoto Family & staff for creating such a welcoming environment with great food !“

“This place has THE BEST PIZZA in Jersey. It reminds me of the great pizza I used to eat growing up in Brooklyn. If you want great pizza this is the place to get it!“

“Enzo , his wife, Anna and their sister-in-law are the nicest people you would want to meet along with some really delicious pizzas. The pizza, as my cousin from South Carolina would say "is blazin' cuz" with a crispy thin crust, a delicious homemade sauce along with generous toppings. With each bite, you can taste every ingredient in and on the pizza. Nothing gets left on the plate with the crust being just as good. Also, try their meatball sandwiches which will surely fill you up and have you coming back week after week. Nothing says "New Jersey" like "Bella Napoli"! Try getting a taste of that in other states. HA!“

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!“

“It was our first time here but we will be back dinner was delicious! Service was great ! We loved it here!“

“The salads are BIG and there are severals options to choose from. My favorite it the House salad and Yordanas salad. The bruschetta is always fresh and delicious. Chicken Saltimbuco is my dh favorite. Also a great place to buy catered meals!“

“OMG. I tried Phil’s MULTIPLE times over the years and was so disappointed. My BF stopped on Thursday and brought me the most AMAZING PUPUSAS 🤤. And MAGICAL PLANTAIN EMPANADAS. I would have never tried it because I really didn’t like one thing any of the times I went before. I will DEFINITELY be going back. A LOT. This is a good and bad thing. Did I mention PUPUSAS??????!“

“mangias Jackson is the very best in food!!! Great service on top of their delicious food . Our families #1 stop when we don’t want to cook . Their buffalo chicken pie is the best , and the wraps are always fresh so stop in or call you will not be disappointed !!“