Joey Tomato's
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About Joey Tomato's
Joey Tomato's Reviews
195 ratings
The Best Pizza not only in New Jersey but on the East Coast The owner and staff will always provide great service on your order.The Pizza Man make great Pies with the best ingredients.Joey Tomatoes specializing in various so delicious Pizza. Also have a nice variety of cold drinks.My favorite is Sausage and Peppers slice or tomatoes and cheese.I had eaten all varieties of pizza here and the flavor is so nice and fresh tasting and the crust cooked to perfection. The place is very...read full review
Worst pizza in nj and crazy overproced... stay away
I stopped in over this past 4th of July holiday and honestly I don't understand some of the negative reviews. For boardwalk pizza it was really good and as a visitor from NYC it exceeded my expectations. The place is clean, service was fast and the staff was nice.
This place has plenty of seating, whether it is indoors, out on the boardwalk or in the back. Even though I went with just a plain slice, they have different toppings to choose from. I agree with the reviewers...read full review
This place has plenty of seating, whether it is indoors, out on the boardwalk or in the back. Even though I went with just a plain slice, they have different toppings to choose from. I agree with the reviewers...read full review
Joey Tomato's is a beloved spot on the Jersey Shore, offering an exceptional dining experience. The friendly and attentive staff provide top-notch service that makes guests feel like family. The pizza is consistently perfect, and the atmosphere is quintessential Jersey boardwalk. While prices may be higher than expected, at $6 for a slice and $42 for a pie, the quality and flavor of the pizza make it well worth the cost. Visitors and locals alike understand that running a business on the boardwalk is not cheap. With a reputation for serving the best slice in Point Pleasant, Joey Tomato's is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers of all ages. The crust has that perfect char that pizza enthusiasts crave, and the sauce strikes just the right balance of tanginess. Guests praise the Mac & Cheese Pizza and the garlic knots, which pair especially well with the marinara. Cleanliness is a top priority here, which sets it apart from many other boardwalk eateries. There is plenty of seating, indoors, outside on the boardwalk, and in the back. The vibrant atmosphere and the opportunity to watch fresh pies being made add to the overall experience.