8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Point Pleasant Beach

“Great experience at Rosie’s. Friendly staff, clean and pleasant seating area. The pizza tastes fresh and simple. We ordered a round plain pie and a square plain pie—the square was especially delicious, with very light, flavorful dough. Would definitely come back.“

“A great restaurant that does have similarities to River Rock“

“I’m from Jersey but since moved up north. Coming back and eating here was nostalgic and delicious. Pizzas were phenomenal. So fresh. Quiet place. Shocked it wasn’t more busy. Friendly staff. Family loved it. Definitely worth the walk. Avoid the subpar boardwalk places and come here!“

“*****UPDATED REVIEW**** kept forgetting to update this. But the below old review is no longer correct. My current review is that Luigi's went back to their old recipe and it took a bit as I think they may have been changing ownership when I wrote my previous review. Luigi's has again been a staple and go to for my family when we crave some pizza. The sauce is delicious and the thin crust pizza is the reason we come back. I still stick to my old review which is the reason I am not deleting it. I also appreciate that they probably knew something was off and made the effort to change and correct their pizza recipe. Luigi's is a place that brings back all my childhood memories of grabbing a slice and going down to the beach to enjoy. If you are in the area I would highly suggest trying a slice!
***OLD REVIEW***I am a local and Luigis has been a tried and true. My family and I always ordered from luigi's because it has been our favorite pizza place for years. Unfortunately the last time we ordered pizza the quality had significantly gone down. We ordered a half white and half pepperoni pizza. Luigis is known for their thin crisp crust and their amazing sauce. There was something seriously off with the taste of the sauce along with the crust. The white pizza had chunks of garlic in it which was very off putting. Then the pepperoni side had too much sauce and cheese, which made everything soggy. It was honestly the worst pizza we had ever had. I am so sad that my once favorite pizza place has now gotten to this point. I am scared to go back and order because I don't want to be disappointed again.“

“Great food, local feel, family owned.

The owner is so friendly and generous. True Italian whose love language is feeding people!
He made fresh bolognese sauce that was his aunts recipe and gave me some to go on the house. Sweet people. Support their business! Food is great!“

“food is always excellent. recommend chicken parm sandwich pizza garlic knots and anti pasta salad all excellent.“

“The food that I ordered was amazing but idk about the pizza. My tuna wrap however was delicious like in the photo. Good place to eat if you are picky as it has SO many food options. Staff were OK but didnt really put all their effort into helping.“

“The Best Pizza not only in New Jersey but on the East Coast The owner and staff will always provide great service on your order.The Pizza Man make great Pies with the best ingredients.Joey Tomatoes specializing in various so delicious Pizza. Also have a nice variety of cold drinks.My favorite is Sausage and Peppers slice or tomatoes and cheese.I had eaten all varieties of pizza here and the flavor is so nice and fresh tasting and the crust cooked to perfection. The place is very organized,the staff is so polite, also the place is super clean and nice.AC inside and a nice Patio in the back of restaurant. After a walk on the boardwalk in Pt Pleasant Beach you should stop by Joey Tomatoes for a delicious slice or Pie with the family..The truth it's the best I ever had. This Pizza place is the best ever...To me Joey Tomatoes is a Five Star Pizza Place.Come by and try it and you will agree with my statement.“