10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Neptune City

Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria Pizza • $
96 Woodland Ave, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

2xl Plain Cheese Pizza & 2xl Mushroom Pizza
Jr Chicken Fingers & French Fries
Fried Calamari Takeout: Yes
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
10 Mild Buffalo Wings
Mussels Marinara
Pizza Thin Crust
Zucchini Sticks
Antipasto Salad
Specialty Pizza

“I've never had pizza that tasted like it did ever before. It was almost novel at first, the sweetness of the pie. But as I kept eating, the bites got better and better. Our large pie was finished in about 10 minutes, maybe less! And the shrimp cocktail was on point too. Was easy to get a seat at the Lima bean shaped bar. It was fun to sit like that. Overall, great experience. Next time I'm back in NJ I'll be seein y'all!“

4.5 Superb169 Reviews
Bruno's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
165 W Sylvania Ave, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza
Brunos Special Submarine Sandwich
Prosciutto Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Cheesesteak
Tortellini Soup
Meatball Parm
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Italian Sub

“I LOVE there food! I have been going to eat there for many years..Even was in the old location many years back. I have moved since, but every time I am in that area I stop. I am never disappointed! I am actually craving there pizza now...nothing in my area comes close to Bruno's.Love you guys !See you soon“

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Molinari's Italian • $
312 W Sylvania Ave, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Carbonara
Buffalo Wings
French Fries
Garlic Bread
Ravioli
Pizza

“They charge you on soda refills which was $3.50 a pop. It should be noted they charge for refills. I didn't see any notation on the menu. I may have missed it, but next time I'll order only one. It is BYOB place. I wonder if I can bring a soda??“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Il Posto Italian • $$
1129 5th Ave, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Linguine with Red Clam Sauce
Spaghetti with Clam Sauce
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Maine Mussels Marinara
Housemade Ravioli
Chicken Francaise
Fried Calamari
Chicken Murphy
Meat Ravioli
Caesar Salad

“We brought our family there who were visiting for the weekend, 10 adults and 2 babies. Sean answered our call when we asked if they could accommodate us all and he then greeted us when we got there. He was very welcoming and nice, Our service was great. I did not catch our waitresses name but she is a younger girl and was amazing. She was beyond friendly and attentive. We all got different foods. The special, butternut squash soup was a huge hit at our table. Everyone loved their dinner as well ( chicken franchise, lasagna, short ribs to name a few) and my leftovers were just as good the next day. We certainly plan to go back. Thank you to the staff there for a great family dinner.Kid-friendliness: Our waitress reviewed all of the kids menu options with us and both our waitress and Sean checked on the two little ones while we were dining.“

4.2 Good65 Reviews
Dominic's Pizzeria & Trattoria Pizza • $
2461 Corlies Ave 33 |, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak Sub
Stromboli
Dominic
Salads

“I actually found out about this place while visiting a friend in Neptune. Since then this place is slowly becoming one of my favorite spots.Their garlic knots are outstanding and are the style I love (updated to k clude a pic). Every calzone/Stromboli I have ordered so far has also been outstanding (updated to include pics of Buffalo chicken and Sicilian "regular" sized Stromboli). Pizza overall has been pretty great but I haven't tried a lot bunch other than plain or with 1, maybe 2 toppings.I am impressed so far with how many items have been great, and the consistency of how great the food is regardless of the day of week/time of day. Give em a shot.“

4.3 Superb29 Reviews
Santino's Pizza Pizza • $
35 W Sylvania Ave, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Mozzarella Ricotta
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Lombordi
Chicken Fingers
Garlic Knots
Margherita
Meatballs
Wings

“Literally the best tortellini Alfredo I’ve ever had in my life. So much so that I needed to write a review. I’m pregnant and started crying after the first bite. (Figuratively, but still) Not all heroes wear capes.Everything else is great too, but this was *chef’s kiss*“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza • $
2040 NJ-33, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Grilled Chicken
Fried Calamari
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Cheesesteak
Penne Vodka
Sausage

“Been going here for years everyone is great. In all the years I've gone there only one time was there an issue and that was when I had it delivered. The pizza was just a mess. Put in 30 years of going there I have no other complaints and even that first time was not so bad.“

4.1 Good35 Reviews
Luigi's Restaurant & Pizza Pizza • $
35 S Main St, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza Pick Up
Chicken Parmigiana
Luigi's Special
Large

“Wonderful, old school, family owned pizzeria with sterling service. Very polite staff and they even bring the food to your table with a smile. My sub was perfect, except I may not be in the mood for dinner later and that I cannot give five hundred stars. LOL. I will definitely be back when in town again. Thanks again guys for the awesome meal and service.“

3.9 Good55 Reviews
Maurizio's Pizzeria Pizza • $
2200 NJ-66, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Grandma Pizza Slice
Gourmet Veggie Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Margherita Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Beef Patties
Caesar Salad

“Do not pass up this place - it is one of the last remaining pizza parlors with such an OG feel on the inside. From the Italian music being blasted to the amazing assortment of pizzas and calzones and other specialty items on display in the case when you first walk in, this place is the besssssst and my family and I order from here weekly! And Idk what it is about their Caesar dressing but it is is almost sweet and sooooo yummy.“

3.8 Good84 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
712 NJ-35, Neptune City

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Pull-Aparts
Stuff Crust Pizza
Soda

“Having worked in retail at one time I understand how customers can act. Even though I enjoy my amazing pizza on the shore this is a good alternative. it’s conveniently located not too far from me and is always hot when I pick it up. The person who I assume is the owner is always very professional. Don’t believe all the reviews.“

3.7 Good10 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy More Tastes In Neptune City

map Map