Randy's Homemade Ice Cream
322 Wanaque Avenue Ste d, Pompton Lakes
(973) 590-9111
Customers' Favorites
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Strawberry
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The ice cream tastes amazing and the limited time flavors are a fun reason to keep coming back. Portions are absolutely humongous. I had a chance to speak to the owner and he was nice enough to gift my dog a frozen treat. The employee who served us also had great flavor recommendations and was very nice. I will definitely be returning.
Randy we love your ice cream, people who don’t like it don’t understand REAL ice cream, your firm personality makes me come back every time we need more owners in places like you! Triple threat brownie is DELICIOUS (no flakes what so ever) if you get what I mean! You will see me every weekend 😀
Having suffered a recent loss in the family, we decided to find some dopamine via ice cream tonight. On a long list of local places to try, Randy’s had been bumped to the top based on a bajillion recommendations from my neighbor. He’s obsessed. It was easy to see why! Yall. You are the sweetest people, serve fantastic ice cream, and your hospitality genuinely teleported me away from my grief for a moment. Best ice cream I’ve tried in town, and the...
You May Also Like
Mack's American Bar & Grill - 300 Wanaque Avenue
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Vegetarian
Boiling Pho - 278 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Seafood, Vietnamese, Pet Friendly, Pho
Tony's Pizza - 264 Wanaque Avenue
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Mexican, Vegetarian