11 Best Bakeries near Port Murray

Tree Licious Orchards Bakery • $$
135 Karrville Rd, Port Murray

“I would highly recommend TreeLicious Orchards. Had a fabulous dinner with our family here tonight. The food and hospitality was beyond EXCELLENT. Due to this whole Covid situation things can be weird, but we felt very safe and comfortable here. The farm is owned and run by the family who is extremely polite and friendly. They make you feel as if we were right at home, like you were part of their family (who happen to be separated by 6 ft -(thank you covid)) The food is made fresh right from the farm in their own home and then brought out for dinner. There is a wide range of food to choose from. They serve everything to you. I am a huge veggie lover and the purple cabbage was my favorite dish. Now the baked goods... OMG the apple pie and peach pie are SOOOO good. We couldn’t leave there without stopping In the barn for some fruits and veggies. Of course we got some apple, peach, & blueberry pie that we are dying to dig into when we get home. I would recommend this place to everyone. There is a huge difference In going to a chain place than going out to a mom and pop place. So happy our family introduced us to this farm- we will defiantly be back soon! Can not recommend them enough!“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Cookie Maven Bakery • $
233 Main St, Lebanon - 11.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Bars with Shortbread Crust
Gluten-Free Cookies 6 Pack
Specialty Cookies 12 Pack
Specialty Cookies 6 Pack
Classic Cookies 12 Pack
Giant Cookies 3 Pack
Linzer Torte

“Excellent cookies. Great assortment. The Cranberry Orange Shortbreads are amazing. My wife said their Pecan Sandies are the best she's had. Ginger Molasses and Oatmeal are also excellent.“

4.9 Superb47 Reviews
Sweet Bite Delights Bakery • $$$
199 Main St, Hackettstown - 6.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tres Leche with Dulce De Leche and Peach
Birthday Cake

“Omg the Tres Leches is the best !!“

4.9 Superb40 Reviews
Cake Fiction Bakery • $$
11 E Mill Rd, Long Valley - 7.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
Custom Cake

“Paula and Simon take time to listen to what the customer wants and the end results are incredible. The cake recipe is perfect - not too sweet and still moist. The designs are stunning with every detail cared for. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend.“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Harper's Bakery Bakery • $
265 Main St, Hackettstown - 6.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“Ordered a pull a part cake for a baby shower. Cake was delicious and it was done exactly how I asked“

4.4 Superb12 Reviews
Rico Pan Bakery Bakery • $
183 Main St, Hackettstown - 6.48 miles

“Really good! Much better than I expected. I live in Orange NJ and there are lots of colombian bakeries near me, none are as good as this place. The pastries are great, and the empanadas are soooo good. Not greasy, and very flavorful. I would definitely come back and try other things. I would also order from here for a party. Great place“

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Main Street Cafe Bakery • $
103 Main St, Hackettstown - 6.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kids Chicken Fingers and Fris
Country Platter Bandeja Paisa
Rancheros with Fried Egg
Country Breakfast
Guacamole
Empanadas
Paratha
Chips

“The coffee is the best I have ever had. The food is delicious. The staff is friendly. 100% recommend stopping in.“

4 Good51 Reviews
Just Made Bakery Bakery • $
1875 NJ-57, Hackettstown - 4.61 miles

“I would highly recommend TreeLicious Orchards. Had a fabulous dinner with our family here tonight. The food and hospitality was beyond EXCELLENT. Due to this whole Covid situation things can be weird, but we felt very safe and comfortable here. The farm is owned and run by the family who is extremely polite and friendly. They make you feel as if we were right at home, like you were part of their family (who happen to be separated by 6 ft -(thank you covid)) The food is made fresh right from the farm in their own home and then brought out for dinner. There is a wide range of food to choose from. They serve everything to you. I am a huge veggie lover and the purple cabbage was my favorite dish. Now the baked goods... OMG the apple pie and peach pie are SOOOO good. We couldn’t leave there without stopping In the barn for some fruits and veggies. Of course we got some apple, peach, & blueberry pie that we are dying to dig into when we get home. I would recommend this place to everyone. There is a huge difference In going to a chain place than going out to a mom and pop place. So happy our family introduced us to this farm- we will defiantly be back soon! Can not recommend them enough!“

4 Good3 Reviews
Cafe 57 Cafe • $
486 NJ-57, Washington - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Prinzregententorte
Roast Beef Sub
Cinnamon Roll
Club Sandwich

“Drove over 3 hours because I kept watching them post all these amazing things on Facebook. Decided one day to just go and check it out for myself. Did NOT disappoint. Took several things home and everything was amazing!“

4.5 Superb98 Reviews
Mackey's Orchard Bakery • $
284 County Road 519, Belvidere - 7.71 miles

“Apple dumplings, warm from the oven… a treat not to be missed.“

4.4 Superb78 Reviews
Philly Pretzel Factory Pretzel Store • $
150 Mountain Ave, Hackettstown - 6.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Batter
Honey Mustard
Melted Cheese
Rivet Shaker
Pretzel Dog

“Thank you for the amazing work making our daughters Decision Day extra fun and delicious. Such wonderful and kind people that are always friendly and helpful.“

3.7 Good23 Reviews