Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop

Very good. Def try the waffles

Highly artificial ice cream, no flavor, tasteless and strong non-natural colors .. unfortunately, I couldn't finish my $8 ice cream after only one spoon. However the staff was very friendly.

$18.75 for two small cones. One tasted like they mixed the candy cherry juice into it and both had paper stuck to the cones from the sheet.

Toilet paper was facing the wrong way

Great flavors. Great ambience and best welcome...please do try ...different flavors different combination...must try

Very tasty ice cream. They give out hefty-sized scoops and their cones are good too. Normal flavors mixed with specialty flavors makes the menu diverse. They also have giant cookies and brownies if you're looking for that extra sugar high. They're decent.

Staff is friendly: pretty relaxed, quiet place. Younger people in school and the owner (I think) are usually behind the counter and they do a fine job in my experience there.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Regular Ice cream was okay. Vegan pistachio was so awful; I believe they said they use soy & coconut milk, maybe should consider oat or omitting the soy because I’ve had many delicious vegan icecreams but this was not one. Sampled both the pumpkin cheesecake & pumpkin latte; they both were just not enjoyable enough to have a whole scoop and with it being fall season there are so many more tastier competitor icecreams (even by the pint in stores for less.) Waffles weren’t made fresh or anything special for their high price

Parking: During summer months this block is blocked off to cars and pedestrian only

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Coney Waffle

delicious! my daughter recommended it and it was bangin!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cute place!! People serving ice cream could be little friendly. The person who was helping us look miserable doing her job. People are here to enjoy some sugar and be happy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Absolutely amazing! I came here with my family literally today. this is my first time coming to this location, but asides from that I've been to other Coney Waffle locations before. The ice cream was good, but sometimes I think my taste buds are broken because I can never taste anything, so this is not too accurate, but the ice was actually good. I got the "Happy birthday to me" flavor, which sounds depressing, but it was good! The workers so kind! They asked me what flavor I wanted very kindly, and told me to take my time. The atmosphere is nice. Pretty good overall.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone, Birthday Cake, Cotton Candy

Absolutely amazing! I came here with my family literally today. this is my first time coming to this location, but asides from that I've been to other Coney Waffle locations before. The ice cream was good, but sometimes I think my taste buds are broken because I can never taste anything, so this is not too accurate, but the ice was actually good. I got the "Happy birthday to me" flavor, which sounds depressing, but it was good! The workers so kind! They asked me what flavor I wanted very kindly, and told me to take my time. The atmosphere is nice. Pretty good overall.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Decorated Rainbow Cone or Bowl, Birthday Cake, Cotton Candy, Cookies & Cream

RED BANK LOCATION - Tonight, there was ONLY one girl working I believe her name was Shannon. While the manager was nowhere in sight- in the back- this girl had to deal with over 30 people taking their orders, fulfilling their orders and ringing them up. One gentleman in line wanted to get back there and help her fulfill the orders or the register because it was a ridiculous amount of people the line. The line was out the door with only one person working.

I hope this is a lesson to the manager, especially on a holiday in the summer of how bad and his poor pre-planning to have only one person working and also to not be anywhere in sight to help. I would hire this girl in a minute. Customers came back in after eating their ice cream to tell her AND the manager once he appeared of what a wonderful job she did and nobody could believe that She was the only person working.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went with a line almost out the door and Shannon was the only one behind the counter. She handled herself like a boss with a massive crowd, and every order was correct. Give her a raise!! Love it here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great ice cream
Staff rude
It’s ice cream. Should be a good time but it wasn’t.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Coney Waffle seems to have very limited hours. Almost never open during my lunch break in town. Today was an exception. The woman was not very kind behind the counter. The signs for flavors are awkwardly placed on top of the cases and not on the glass in plain sight. I asked to sample one flavor and was told they don’t do samples. Pretty horrible business if you don’t let customers sample your ice cream. I’ve actually never heard of such nonsense before. Unfortunately for them I just walked out. Fortunately for me I saved $$ and went elsewhere. Shocked they’re still in business, but probably not for much longer.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1