If I could give 0 stars I would. They took our order and never started cooking the food. People came in 20 minutes after us were being served. We walked out, making it worse, they lied about our food preparation. Saying it was being made, pointing to an empty station. Mr. Pizza slice is a perfect name, if you order anything else you're not eating.
David Vignolini
Best pizza around. Cheesesteaks, fries… who am I kidding all the food there is great. The staff is excellent.
I like the variety of slices and am so glad they kept the original slice. I worked there for a few years during high school/college for Steve and the pizza and sandwiches were just like I remember making/eating last time I visited.
Keep up the great work and have a slice for me to toast one up to Steve “the man, the myth, and the legend”. I sure miss him, he was probably the best boss I ever had or ever will have.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Matthies
Total rip off taking advantage of kids who want cheeseburgers. Have you ever been to a place that charges $5 for a slice of cheese?! Or $15 + tax + tip for a cheeseburger with no fries, pickle, nothing but a cheeseburger?! Twice the price for half the food!! This is the first time I’ve seen that in my life. Never going here again!!
Robert Sax
The best pizza I have found in Red Bank NJ . They had a nice ice slating event outside their business on Sunday so I decided to stop in . the staff was very friendly and helpful the chicken barbecue pizza I ordered was amazing , I will certainly be going back the next time I am in Red
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie !
My mozzarella sticks were empty ? so sad
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Tyler Strand
Best Pizza Place at Red Bank NJ
L T
Usually love their cheesesteaks, but they changed the bread ?
Food: 2
Todd Diamond
Food was great! But it is sad that someone renovated this historic landmark. I skipped school to come here and saw Jon Bon Jovi here! I hope the old booths and video games are in a museum ❤️
I’m originally from Jersey, and this pizza was great. The perfect crust, good cheese, the right amount of greasiness, sauce with the right balance and a slice for the right price under$2!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Curley
I had lunch at Mr Pizza Slice at least once a week when I worked in Red Bank from the mid-70s until I moved to FL in 1995. Even through illness Steve cooked the most perfect burgers I have ever had enhanced by the sautéed onions and peppers topping that had a secret ingredient. Steve finally told me what it is but made me promise that I never tell. I still haven't told anyone.
S B
I have been a customer of Mr. Pizza slice since before anyone who works there was even born. Their cheesesteaks, which used to be delicious and fairly priced are no longer. $20 for a cheesesteak, are you kidding? They have half the meat they used to have, and are twice the price. Yes, I understand food prices have gotten very expensive. But you all need a reality check, to include a $23 plain pizza? I’ve seen lots of other restaurants in town over the last three decades come and go with this strategy. It’s not a lasting business model.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
CJ W
If you ask the servers, they'll yell at you like Steve used to. It's awesome! One star!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Aaron Levine
The go to takeout pizza spot when in Red Bank. Great pizza and friendly staff.
If I could give 0 stars I would. They took our order and never started cooking the food. People came in 20 minutes after us were being served. We walked out, making it worse, they lied about our food preparation. Saying it was being made, pointing to an empty station. Mr. Pizza slice is a perfect name, if you order anything else you're not eating.
Best pizza around. Cheesesteaks, fries… who am I kidding all the food there is great. The staff is excellent.
I like the variety of slices and am so glad they kept the original slice. I worked there for a few years during high school/college for Steve and the pizza and sandwiches were just like I remember making/eating last time I visited.
Keep up the great work and have a slice for me to toast one up to Steve “the man, the myth, and the legend”. I sure miss him, he was probably the best boss I ever had or ever will have.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Total rip off taking advantage of kids who want cheeseburgers. Have you ever been to a place that charges $5 for a slice of cheese?! Or $15 + tax + tip for a cheeseburger with no fries, pickle, nothing but a cheeseburger?! Twice the price for half the food!! This is the first time I’ve seen that in my life. Never going here again!!
The best pizza I have found in Red Bank NJ . They had a nice ice slating event outside their business on Sunday so I decided to stop in . the staff was very friendly and helpful the chicken barbecue pizza I ordered was amazing , I will certainly be going back the next time I am in Red
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My mozzarella sticks were empty ? so sad
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Best Pizza Place at Red Bank NJ
Usually love their cheesesteaks, but they changed the bread ?
Food: 2
Food was great! But it is sad that someone renovated this historic landmark. I skipped school to come here and saw Jon Bon Jovi here! I hope the old booths and video games are in a museum ❤️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cheese slice SLAPS. Perfect everything. 0 flop. Nice slice $3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got 2 slices today. Inedible. Like chewing gum. The cheese was was awful. The crust terrible. Not the Mr. Pizza slice of yore.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I’m originally from Jersey, and this pizza was great. The perfect crust, good cheese, the right amount of greasiness, sauce with the right balance and a slice for the right price under$2!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had lunch at Mr Pizza Slice at least once a week when I worked in Red Bank from the mid-70s until I moved to FL in 1995. Even through illness Steve cooked the most perfect burgers I have ever had enhanced by the sautéed onions and peppers topping that had a secret ingredient. Steve finally told me what it is but made me promise that I never tell. I still haven't told anyone.
I have been a customer of Mr. Pizza slice since before anyone who works there was even born. Their cheesesteaks, which used to be delicious and fairly priced are no longer. $20 for a cheesesteak, are you kidding? They have half the meat they used to have, and are twice the price. Yes, I understand food prices have gotten very expensive. But you all need a reality check, to include a $23 plain pizza? I’ve seen lots of other restaurants in town over the last three decades come and go with this strategy. It’s not a lasting business model.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
If you ask the servers, they'll yell at you like Steve used to. It's awesome! One star!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
The go to takeout pizza spot when in Red Bank. Great pizza and friendly staff.
Food: 5
Loading...