I usually go to tomato pies every 2 months. The store is all the way from 1912! More than a century ago! Which makes me feel like i'm in a vintage store. Outside, there is a 2 doors in the front. There is a door for dine-in and another door for order to go or pick up. I personally haven't done dine-in but I always go for to go or pick up. Whenever I go, the staff is always so sweet and are always accurate for the time left. The only thing I dislikd is the time if takes to make the pizza. The pizza was delicious and stayed pretty warm when handed to me.
Linda B.
Oh my what can I say about papas. Most delicious pizzas. Any type. They will create for your asking. Also their chopped antipasto is so delicious with their homemade dressing be sure to order it w ur pizza.
Sean C. B.
One of the best pepperoni pizza's I've ever eaten and I ate a whole pie by myself ! 5 stars for sure! I want to try the mustard pie next time. Papa's is the real deal!
Linda R.
I have heard so much about the mustard pie. My family was like yuck yet I dragged them out there today. Have to say I wasn't a big fan. I really expected to be. I prefer a crispier crust. The sausage on half the pie was big chunks that were yummy but oddly only on 3 slices. The mustard was not to my taste. The fried ravioli and chicken tenders with fries appetizers were quite good. Everything was served hot! Service was fine. We got our pizza before the appetizers which was odd and our waitress didn't even notice. The ambiance is pretty typical for an old pizza place. A little work at the edges. Surprised to see no free refills on the drinks. I haven't seen that in decades. Overall, it was ok. Not sure we will be back.
Cindy G
I went on a road trip and picked up a mustard ? pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mustard Pie
Brian Huber
Was here with my family for my birthday. Had our grandson with us who has a disability. The customer base here is very snooty. One of the customers made a comment that we need to take our grandson out. Needless to say we all left. The person at the counter was nice and apologized. But because of the snobby customer base I would not recommend this restaurant to families with little ones, especially ones that may have a disability.This restaurant is not the right spot for individuals ( children) who have a disability especially if it's not apparent.I'm sure that they will not care , reach out to us at all because , we are not part of their usual customer base
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Jeffrey Newinski
Great food and service.Parking: Plenty of parkingWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage
patricia Fort
Love their pies and white clam sauce w/ linguine. They have the best pies around the whole city of trenton and hamilton. Can't get a pie like Their anywhere.Parking: Plenty of parking. No problems.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Artichoke, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie, Sausage
Susan G.
The BEST tomato pie around!! Crispy crust and never burned, just enough cheese! Date night was every Saturday night on Chambers St. for at least 10 years!!
Richard R.
Perfect pizza every time. thin crust, great sauce, no flop. The mustard pie is a thing of wonder. Every topping is top flight, the salads are awesome. Papa's is old school. Simple, consistent, and always perfect.
I had heard so many great things about this place, so was really disappointed it didn't live up to the hype. Overall the pizza was just not enjoyable to me - sauce had no flavor, cheese was not the best quality. It looked amazing but just did not live up to the reviews in terms of taste and quality. Especially after a 45 minute wait!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Anish Patel
We are vegetarian and tried the veg options - loved the Mustard & Margherita Pies. Zucchini Sticks & Bruschetta were also awesome for Appetizers. Ambiance as resemblance of older days as it is there since 1912 :) .. loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta, Mustard Pie, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Bharat Mehta
Best as always. They never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mustard Pie, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Vr regan
Great place to get your fix of Tomato pie.This restaurant has been around since 1914 I believe. Great history, and differentiates with "mustard pie" which I assume is great, made with a layer of mustard baked in but my 5 friends were afraid to try. Maybe next time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikki C.
Old school family style restaurant with amazing prices, delicious pizza and attentive staff
I usually go to tomato pies every 2 months. The store is all the way from 1912! More than a century ago! Which makes me feel like i'm in a vintage store. Outside, there is a 2 doors in the front. There is a door for dine-in and another door for order to go or pick up. I personally haven't done dine-in but I always go for to go or pick up. Whenever I go, the staff is always so sweet and are always accurate for the time left. The only thing I dislikd is the time if takes to make the pizza. The pizza was delicious and stayed pretty warm when handed to me.
Oh my what can I say about papas. Most delicious pizzas. Any type. They will create for your asking. Also their chopped antipasto is so delicious with their homemade dressing be sure to order it w ur pizza.
One of the best pepperoni pizza's I've ever eaten and I ate a whole pie by myself ! 5 stars for sure! I want to try the mustard pie next time. Papa's is the real deal!
I have heard so much about the mustard pie. My family was like yuck yet I dragged them out there today. Have to say I wasn't a big fan. I really expected to be. I prefer a crispier crust. The sausage on half the pie was big chunks that were yummy but oddly only on 3 slices. The mustard was not to my taste. The fried ravioli and chicken tenders with fries appetizers were quite good. Everything was served hot! Service was fine. We got our pizza before the appetizers which was odd and our waitress didn't even notice. The ambiance is pretty typical for an old pizza place. A little work at the edges. Surprised to see no free refills on the drinks. I haven't seen that in decades. Overall, it was ok. Not sure we will be back.
I went on a road trip and picked up a mustard ? pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mustard Pie
Was here with my family for my birthday. Had our grandson with us who has a disability. The customer base here is very snooty. One of the customers made a comment that we need to take our grandson out. Needless to say we all left. The person at the counter was nice and apologized. But because of the snobby customer base I would not recommend this restaurant to families with little ones, especially ones that may have a disability.This restaurant is not the right spot for individuals ( children) who have a disability especially if it's not apparent.I'm sure that they will not care , reach out to us at all because , we are not part of their usual customer base
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Great food and service.Parking: Plenty of parkingWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage
Love their pies and white clam sauce w/ linguine. They have the best pies around the whole city of trenton and hamilton. Can't get a pie like Their anywhere.Parking: Plenty of parking. No problems.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Artichoke, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie, Sausage
The BEST tomato pie around!! Crispy crust and never burned, just enough cheese! Date night was every Saturday night on Chambers St. for at least 10 years!!
Perfect pizza every time. thin crust, great sauce, no flop. The mustard pie is a thing of wonder. Every topping is top flight, the salads are awesome. Papa's is old school. Simple, consistent, and always perfect.
Restaurantji Recommends
I had heard so many great things about this place, so was really disappointed it didn't live up to the hype. Overall the pizza was just not enjoyable to me - sauce had no flavor, cheese was not the best quality. It looked amazing but just did not live up to the reviews in terms of taste and quality. Especially after a 45 minute wait!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
We are vegetarian and tried the veg options - loved the Mustard & Margherita Pies. Zucchini Sticks & Bruschetta were also awesome for Appetizers. Ambiance as resemblance of older days as it is there since 1912 :) .. loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta, Mustard Pie, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Best as always. They never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mustard Pie, Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Great place to get your fix of Tomato pie.This restaurant has been around since 1914 I believe. Great history, and differentiates with "mustard pie" which I assume is great, made with a layer of mustard baked in but my 5 friends were afraid to try. Maybe next time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old school family style restaurant with amazing prices, delicious pizza and attentive staff