Papa's Tomato Pies
19 Main St, Robbinsville
(609) 208-0006
Customers' Favorites
Mustard Pie with Sausage and Garlic
Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Half Pepperoni Half Sausage
Italian Stallion Pie
Stuffed Artichoke
Bang Bang Shrimp
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Margherita Pie
Caesar Salad
Menu
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
8/23/25 - Pre-gaming took place at a restaurant called Papa's Tomato Pies in Robbinsville, NJ. They market the place as the oldest tomato pie restaurant in the country as it was opened in 1912. Just to remind you, a tomato pie is basically a pizza with cheese on the bottom and sauce on top.\n\nThis pie is nothing short of amazing. It is in the conversation of the best pizza I have ever eaten. Ever.\n\nThere's no bad things to report here so on to the good: \nThe sauce...
I thought pizza was just pizza until I tried this place and I couldn’t believe it was so good ! so I took two of my friends one from Philadelphia and the other from Virginia and both of them were amazed at how good it was !
A New Jersey institution! Classic pizza restaurant serving delicious tomato pie! We ordered a plain and a sausage and garlic. Both were excellent as evidenced with the fact I ate four slices! With a crisp thin crust, is unique creation topped with a tangy sauce. Our hostess was friendly was very attentive providing us with great service! Papa's is a great alternative to Delorenzos also located in Robbinsville, walking distance nearby. I recommend Papa's, it's affordable...
You May Also Like
Taco Bell - 28 Main St
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican
PORTO by Chef Jason - 1111 US-130
![]()
American, Italian, New American