Papa's Tomato Pies
19 Main St, Robbinsville
(609) 208-0006
Customers' Favorites
Mustard Pie with Sausage and Garlic
Mustard Pizza and Tomato Pie
Half Pepperoni Half Sausage
Italian Stallion Pie
Stuffed Artichoke
Bang Bang Shrimp
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Margherita Pie
Caesar Salad
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Very good pizza with crispy, thin crust. First time having a tomato pie and not a fan of the tomato sauce above the cheese, but that’s personal preference. Very casual interior made for a homey vibe. Would go back to try their mustard pie.
We have been there twice, the second time on a Monday because nearby Delorenzo’s was closed. We ordered fried raviolis and they were just ok, not great. Small. Pizzas have great crust with the highly desired “no flop.” When they were delivered to our table, however, we were a bit surprised to see how oily they were. Sauce taste was ok, not great. Overall, the pizzas were very good though. Our takeaway? Delorenzo’s pizza is better. Same great crust, but even better. Sauce...
Yes I get that. This is supposed to be an old establishment and one of the first tomato pies in the US. Mustard on pizza, Not great. The regular tomato pie was pretty good. Oh do not get that house salad. It was basically beets with lettuce and tomato. Just gross and disappointing.