FOOD - 5 STARS (Award winning breakfast spot on your way to the beach) SERVICE - 5 STARS (they made me a gluten free ham cheese sandwich, yup) AMBIANCE - 5 STARTS (You can sit inside or outside) I will be back every summer and very much addicted to their breakfast sandwiches.
Barbara Degnan
Lobster rolls were wonderful, had the Connecticut version. Many selections to choose from, cold with mayo to hot with butter, you name it, they had it. The roll came with cole slaw and a pickle. We shared fries, did not order drinks (although there was a large assortment). Bill was $50.
Carolyn Lazlo
This was our first time ordering from Mystic Market LBI and it won't be our last. It is very clean and bright inside, with a few tables if you want to sit and eat, and it's conveniently located on Long Beach Blvd in Ship Bottom. We ordered a large Italian sub and a "mighty" Maine lobster roll. Both were huge, fresh, and delicious!
Giana D.
Delicious lobster roll, clean market, very friendly staff. It's exactly what you want in a lobster roll, meaty with a nice sweet bun. Would definitely recommend
William L
Food was a bit pricey, frozen lobster tail was 15.99/lb when I could buy a live lobster at shoprite for 8.99/lb this late in summer. They also did not have some things like scallops but that’s because they only come in on certain days. I will say this, while the selection is not priced competitively and stock is hit or miss the quality of the seafood and steaks is very high. I probably would not stop by here again unless I was looking for something particular, but if you don’t mind the prices they do sell quality food.
user_523340
GREAT service and food, if you are looking for quality and quantity this is your place! The new owners are GREAT!
Christopher F.
We were on LBI for a week vacation and had Mystic Market recommended to us for sandwiches and lobster rolls. Decided to give it a try and it did not disappoint. Received a friendly greeting from the staff as I walked in the door. Decided to go with the lobster roll of which they had a multitude of varieties. I kept it simple and went with Connecticut style, just lobster and melted butter on a roll. They have seating so you can dine in or take out. Decided to have it there. These are made to order and it was ready in a matter of minutes. The lobster roll was excellent, filled with fresh lobster smothered in just the right amount of butter on a perfectly toasted roll! If that wasn't enough, it was served with a tasty pickle spear and coleslaw that was clearly homemade! So good I had to order a 2nd one to bring home for my wife. Would highly recommend this place! Enjoy!
Colleen Ponik
I’ve come to this establishment twice. The first time in 2022 I was so impressed with the quality and flavor of the lobster roll. This summer it was bland and quite possibly smaller.
Erin Balukas
We went today for an Italian sub. It was delicious! Loaded with meats in a yummy roll. Service was friendly and efficient and the place was clean. We will be back!
Suzanne Bell
Went for there to get some steaks for dinner. Great service and excellent NY strip steaks. Will definitely go back.
Best breakfast sandwiches and cheesesteaks... in NJ let alone the island. I really haven't had anything bad from here. The sangwiches rival the best in Brooklyn. Run, don't walk and get yourself a Jersey Devil.
Erin C.
Fantastic lobster rolls! They even have gluten free rolls, which made it worth the walk for the gluten free members of our family, who normally can't get lobster rolls in most places. LBI roll & Hawaiian rolls were fabulous. We went at lunchtime and had very little wait, sat inside at the table to eat. Very cute place, owner was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back to try more of their specialty rolls!
S H.
My Connecticut Lobster Roll was a disappointment. The roll wasn't toasted and warm, and the lobster wasn't warmed in melted butter. Last year it was much better.
Rile
Macaroni salad slapped! Very good. Friendly and accommodating staff.
Nhoj Elrebe
Great place to stop and load up on lobster rolls. The choices are amazing. My DW and I have been going to LBI for years and just 'discovered' Mystic Market. We will make this a regular stop from now on. It is worth stopping for.
FOOD - 5 STARS (Award winning breakfast spot on your way to the beach) SERVICE - 5 STARS (they made me a gluten free ham cheese sandwich, yup) AMBIANCE - 5 STARTS (You can sit inside or outside) I will be back every summer and very much addicted to their breakfast sandwiches.
Lobster rolls were wonderful, had the Connecticut version. Many selections to choose from, cold with mayo to hot with butter, you name it, they had it. The roll came with cole slaw and a pickle. We shared fries, did not order drinks (although there was a large assortment). Bill was $50.
This was our first time ordering from Mystic Market LBI and it won't be our last. It is very clean and bright inside, with a few tables if you want to sit and eat, and it's conveniently located on Long Beach Blvd in Ship Bottom. We ordered a large Italian sub and a "mighty" Maine lobster roll. Both were huge, fresh, and delicious!
Delicious lobster roll, clean market, very friendly staff. It's exactly what you want in a lobster roll, meaty with a nice sweet bun. Would definitely recommend
Food was a bit pricey, frozen lobster tail was 15.99/lb when I could buy a live lobster at shoprite for 8.99/lb this late in summer. They also did not have some things like scallops but that’s because they only come in on certain days. I will say this, while the selection is not priced competitively and stock is hit or miss the quality of the seafood and steaks is very high. I probably would not stop by here again unless I was looking for something particular, but if you don’t mind the prices they do sell quality food.
GREAT service and food, if you are looking for quality and quantity this is your place! The new owners are GREAT!
We were on LBI for a week vacation and had Mystic Market recommended to us for sandwiches and lobster rolls. Decided to give it a try and it did not disappoint. Received a friendly greeting from the staff as I walked in the door. Decided to go with the lobster roll of which they had a multitude of varieties. I kept it simple and went with Connecticut style, just lobster and melted butter on a roll. They have seating so you can dine in or take out. Decided to have it there. These are made to order and it was ready in a matter of minutes. The lobster roll was excellent, filled with fresh lobster smothered in just the right amount of butter on a perfectly toasted roll! If that wasn't enough, it was served with a tasty pickle spear and coleslaw that was clearly homemade! So good I had to order a 2nd one to bring home for my wife. Would highly recommend this place! Enjoy!
I’ve come to this establishment twice. The first time in 2022 I was so impressed with the quality and flavor of the lobster roll. This summer it was bland and quite possibly smaller.
We went today for an Italian sub. It was delicious! Loaded with meats in a yummy roll. Service was friendly and efficient and the place was clean. We will be back!
Went for there to get some steaks for dinner. Great service and excellent NY strip steaks. Will definitely go back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best breakfast sandwiches and cheesesteaks... in NJ let alone the island. I really haven't had anything bad from here. The sangwiches rival the best in Brooklyn. Run, don't walk and get yourself a Jersey Devil.
Fantastic lobster rolls! They even have gluten free rolls, which made it worth the walk for the gluten free members of our family, who normally can't get lobster rolls in most places. LBI roll & Hawaiian rolls were fabulous. We went at lunchtime and had very little wait, sat inside at the table to eat. Very cute place, owner was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back to try more of their specialty rolls!
My Connecticut Lobster Roll was a disappointment. The roll wasn't toasted and warm, and the lobster wasn't warmed in melted butter. Last year it was much better.
Macaroni salad slapped! Very good. Friendly and accommodating staff.
Great place to stop and load up on lobster rolls. The choices are amazing. My DW and I have been going to LBI for years and just 'discovered' Mystic Market. We will make this a regular stop from now on. It is worth stopping for.