Mystic Market LBI

2901 Long Beach Boulevard, Ship Bottom
(609) 342-1191

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Southern Heat Grilled Lobster 2
Connecticut Lobster Roll
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese
LBI Lobster Roll
Jersey Devil

Menu

Catering
Small Sub Tray
Feeds 10-12 People
Large Sub Tray
Feeds 16-20 People
Small Lobster Roll Tray
4 Lobster Rolls
Large Lobster Roll Tray
8 Lobster Rols
Upgrade Small Lobster Tray
Speciality Rolls
Upgrade Large Lobster Tray
Speciality Rolls
Shrimp Platters
Grilled Chicken For Sub Platter Per Sub
Proscuitto For Sub Platter. Per Sub

Drinks
Sprite
Dr. Pepper
Coke
Diet Coke
Stewart's Rootbeer
Stewarts Diet Rootbeer
Stewarts Orange Cream
Bai Coconut
Gold Peak Green Tea
Gold Peak Unsweetened
Gold Peak Green Tea
Snapple Fruit Punch 32oz
Snapple Lemon 32oz
Snapple Lemon Zero 32oz
Snapple Raspberry 32oz
Gatorade Cool Blue
Gatorade Fruit Punch
Gatorade Lemon-lime
Gatorade Orange
Monster Energey
Monster Energy Zero
Rock Star
Rock Star Sugar Free
Rock Star Fruit Punch
Rock Star Silver Ice

Regular Hot Dog
Dog Only
With Fries

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+40 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+39 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

1 of the best places on LBI to eat at! Whether it's a quick bite or a sit down dinner, Mystic has u covered! The staff was knowledgeable & attentive. Met the manager Jim who asked how everything was & even took care of my kids w/something extra. We will continue to patronize this LBI Staple!
Keep up great work Mystic & Staff
August 2026
Food is good, but be prepared to WAIT a VERY LONG time for your order to be ready! I waited 25-30 minutes after I ordered only 2 Lobster 🦞 Rolls! I understand they are busy, but they very much need another person working to help make the food and speed up the process!
August 2026
I just enjoyed the 10” Hawaiian Chicken sub with grilled chicken, pineapple, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and a delicious Mango Citrus Mayo. Fantastic! I split the generous sandwich with my husband. I ordered on the website and the sandwich was ready when I walked in the door. I strongly recommend Mystic Market for your next order!!
June 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Ferrara's Island Bakery - 2900 Long Beach Boulevard
Bakery, Vegetarian
Topsail Steamer - 2608 Long Beach Boulevard
Seafood, Seafood Markets
La Bamba - 3200 Long Beach Blvd
Mexican, Latin American, Seafood, Vegetarian

Mystic Market LBI

2901 Long Beach Boulevard, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
(609) 342-1191