I ordered a meat slice, a plain slice, and calamari. Only the plain slice was decent. Definitely not Brooklyn pizza, maybe cafeteria pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Vincent J. Amato
Tastee plain pie.Nice staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pizza
Michael W.
First time getting pizza from here. Saw the picture of the Brooklyn Grandma, thought it looked good, so gave it a try. Looked exactly like the picture and could quite possibly be some of the best pizza I've ever had. I usually ask for my pizza well-done, but no need here. It was cooked perfectly. The sauce had some sweetness to it which was a nice surprise and change of pace. I'd recommend they use the sauce on all their pizza because I tried a plain slice and it just couldn't compare. Can't wait till I'm back in town to get another Brooklyn Grandma.
Zachary Davis
Wonderful to watch how the employees all work together to make an amazing pizza and food experience.Came in on Super Bowl Sunday and though they were slammed with orders, the staff all worked with smiles to deliver the orders as fast as they could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Rollatini Pizza
Igor Kalmykov
My favorite pizza in the area
Kevin “Slater” Ryan
Pizza is good, wings were underdone. For all the handwringing and complaining about "third party delivery apps" on their website, my order was actually cheaper through Door Dash. Identical orders. The compulsory tipping through their site to "help the team out" with stock team photos should be reigned in as well. Tipping shouldn't be forced, it's for outstanding service.
Food: 4
Karyssa Chavez
Ordered the little Italy panini. The fries were better than the panini and the fries could’ve been better. Little to no flavoring which was surprising being that the majority of the cooks in the back were Hispanic. Definitely not worth $15. The young girl in the front was also kinda rude but nothing I haven’t dealt with before. And yes I’m reviewing the right place, you can keep your sarcastic responses to yourself thanks!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nancy Ceus
Love Grandma pie, garlic knots, salad, and bbq wings. Delicious. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter A.
If you're going for a cheese pizza, don't. It's mediocre at best. However, the grandma pie was absolutely fantastic and I'll be back for more.
Steve B.
First off, don't love giving this review because the people working there are nice. But if you have had $1 slices in NYC - undercooked, low amounts of cheap ingredients, you can relate to their pizza. Had a plain and sausage slice and both were pretty weak. Lots of speciality slices but really dressed up $1 slices. With all the quality places in the area, the only reason to eat here is the convenience of the train station or an errand at the post office.
List wait time wrong. Waited for order in restaurant for 20 minutes. Please post correct wait time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Luigi Monaco
I hear your pizza is the Best? What do you recommend pepperoni? Please ? advise
R B.
Your pizza is as thin as a tortilla chip. I expect better value for $17 large pie
Noelle Y.
Nice service, delicious pizza, cozy environment. The pizza was perfectly crunchy, crispy, and very addictive. Would recommend to come here.
Kevin Quan
Cute restaurant right outside the train station, great spot to pick up a slice of pizza on your way into the city or back. I picked up a delicious chicken bacon ranch and enjoyed it my with friends. Food was prepared quickly and efficiently and I had a good experience speaking with employees there, they were friendly an attentive. I will be going back !
I ordered a meat slice, a plain slice, and calamari. Only the plain slice was decent. Definitely not Brooklyn pizza, maybe cafeteria pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Tastee plain pie.Nice staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pizza
First time getting pizza from here. Saw the picture of the Brooklyn Grandma, thought it looked good, so gave it a try. Looked exactly like the picture and could quite possibly be some of the best pizza I've ever had. I usually ask for my pizza well-done, but no need here. It was cooked perfectly. The sauce had some sweetness to it which was a nice surprise and change of pace. I'd recommend they use the sauce on all their pizza because I tried a plain slice and it just couldn't compare. Can't wait till I'm back in town to get another Brooklyn Grandma.
Wonderful to watch how the employees all work together to make an amazing pizza and food experience.Came in on Super Bowl Sunday and though they were slammed with orders, the staff all worked with smiles to deliver the orders as fast as they could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Rollatini Pizza
My favorite pizza in the area
Pizza is good, wings were underdone. For all the handwringing and complaining about "third party delivery apps" on their website, my order was actually cheaper through Door Dash. Identical orders. The compulsory tipping through their site to "help the team out" with stock team photos should be reigned in as well. Tipping shouldn't be forced, it's for outstanding service.
Food: 4
Ordered the little Italy panini. The fries were better than the panini and the fries could’ve been better. Little to no flavoring which was surprising being that the majority of the cooks in the back were Hispanic. Definitely not worth $15. The young girl in the front was also kinda rude but nothing I haven’t dealt with before. And yes I’m reviewing the right place, you can keep your sarcastic responses to yourself thanks!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Love Grandma pie, garlic knots, salad, and bbq wings. Delicious. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're going for a cheese pizza, don't. It's mediocre at best. However, the grandma pie was absolutely fantastic and I'll be back for more.
First off, don't love giving this review because the people working there are nice. But if you have had $1 slices in NYC - undercooked, low amounts of cheap ingredients, you can relate to their pizza. Had a plain and sausage slice and both were pretty weak. Lots of speciality slices but really dressed up $1 slices. With all the quality places in the area, the only reason to eat here is the convenience of the train station or an errand at the post office.
Restaurantji Recommends
List wait time wrong. Waited for order in restaurant for 20 minutes. Please post correct wait time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I hear your pizza is the Best? What do you recommend pepperoni? Please ? advise
Your pizza is as thin as a tortilla chip. I expect better value for $17 large pie
Nice service, delicious pizza, cozy environment. The pizza was perfectly crunchy, crispy, and very addictive. Would recommend to come here.
Cute restaurant right outside the train station, great spot to pick up a slice of pizza on your way into the city or back. I picked up a delicious chicken bacon ranch and enjoyed it my with friends. Food was prepared quickly and efficiently and I had a good experience speaking with employees there, they were friendly an attentive. I will be going back !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5