Stillwater Cafe

912 Main St, Stillwater
(908) 472-9407

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Home Fry Bowl

Photos

+15 photos

+14 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We had a wedding at the Stillwater Cafe, and it was wonderful! The setting was extremely unique and intimate, and Dave, the owner, was over-the-top accommodating with us from planning to executing. The food was delicious and plentiful. I couldn't ask for more, and I wouldn't change a thing! Our guests have been calling, telling us how great everything was that day, and that it was the best wedding food they've ever had! Now they want to check out his Saturday dinners!...

March 2026

We have been here a couple times now. If you are looking for something unique and fun check it out. It seems like it’s off the beaten path but not really. Dining in a General Store from the 1800’s is pretty cool but let’s talk about the food and host. Dave has done a great job creating dishes with care and our experience has been nothing but positive. Plan ahead as you need to order before you arrive and seating is limited but so worth the experience. Seems like he...

January 2026

What an amazing gem hidden in a small town!
We went to visit family in the area and there’s not much around, but there was this general store, turned cafe. We were arriving on a Saturday and my aunt asked if we wanted to try dinner at the cafe. You reserve your spot and place your order ahead of time. There's only one seating for dinner but you are served a one of a few choices for each course of the 4-course meal (appetizer, salad, entree with two sides, and...

November 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Stillwater, NJ

Stillwater Cafe

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Stillwater Cafe