Restaurants near Stillwater

“On my first visit, I thought the food was delicious. It has a small town and cozy atmosphere with several tables. You must order your menu choices and make your reservation a day or more in advance. I can't wait to go back. It's a little hidden treasure. and you won't be disappointed.”

“So I took an extra trip from NYC to try the this Ice Cream, trust me it was worth it. My suggestion is that if you do come this way plan to stay in the area at least one day to see the Butterfly Falls and stop here to enjoy the best ice cream that you will ever try. They have many different flavors available. Next to the Ice Cream shop, there is also Pizzeria, and a great store located on the same yard. Pizza I did not try, it was closed when I arrived. But I did mange to get few things from their store. Large selection of products, from Bread, different spices, sauces, fruits, vegetables. The best time to come here is when the Apple picking season starts. Keep up the good work!”

“Always delicious and very consistent”

“Lovely setting, perfect service, and food that is authentic and perfectly prepared. There's no need to travel outside Sussex County for great Indian food.”

“excellent ... very impressive, food and service was great !!!”

“Just used cafe Pierrot to cater a sprinkle I was hosting. Everything was amazing! Placing the order was extremely easy- I sent an email and someone called me right away and quickly responded to any email questions I had. Everyone enjoyed the food and LOVED the cupcakes. Was able to pay in advance online so all I had to do was send someone for pick up the day of the party and everything was ready right away I think food is one of the hardest parts of planning a party. Never know what to get or how much. Being able to simply give them a number of guests and all I had to do was decide which type of salad I wanted, made this part of the party so simple and stress free! Love the one stop shopping aspect where I could get my food, sides, and even cupcakes all from one place. The spread they provide is the perfect mix and they provide the perfect amount, for an awesome price! Definitely recommend using them!!!”

“Outstanding bagels New Jersey’s best Steve keeps everything stock to the roof Ari runs the front end multitask takes orders processes everything quickly and efficiently. Ari‘s mom does all the homemade baking cakes cookies tiramisu tray Leche cake outstanding good food don’t miss firehouse bagels you get what you pay for!!”

“very good food and prices and a good atmosphere”

“I was hiking a section of the Appalachian Trail, and some other hikers told me of this place. I was so hungry and when I got there the food smells were so good, I had to stop. I had my dog with me but the owner had no problems with me tying the dog out back where there are picnic tables while I ordered. The owner loves dogs and is very friendly to both the dog and I. The food was delicious and the portions so large that I was full before I even finished my lunch. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants good service, good food and a caring restaurant owner. Thanks Mo and crew!”

“Amazing Food! Anytime I order everything is so good! The desserts are out of this world!”

“please do no review anywhere else besides google, all others business profile are not been set up by the restaurant owners, anyone can write anything with out getting any response or trying to fix any issue, in google we will try to contact you by replying your review and get you a solution if you have a problem with orders or anything related with the restaurant, and we sorry about adding surcharge fees on credit/debit or other forms of payment , if anyone dont wanna pay the surcharges fees have the option to pay cash, is optional, about food prices keep in mind everything is increasing we try to keep as low as possible. thank you”

“Great place and the owner is amazing”

“Owner Steve makes an outstanding pie. He’s been in the business along time and knows all the secrets to making a delicious pizza. He was very personable and I look forward to going back soon. OOne of my new favorite pizza restaurants around.”

“We have found our new favorite place!!!! We went for dinner on New Year's Eve and WOW. Everything we ordered was outstanding! great vibes, great service. can't wait to go back!”

“Quaint breakfast and lunch spot. Good food and nice staff.”

“Such a great little place with legitimately good quality beer! I've been to plenty of small town breweries all over the country and more often than I'd like to admit, the beer can be very home-brewy. This place is putting out high quality craft beer, and it's pretty clear they have some talent running the brew house!

I really dug their doppelbock, their Belgian ale, the high gravity porter....it really was all fantastic! The place itself is also a ton of fun. Such great staff behind the counter, and even the locals at the bar were super fun to hang out with!

Pro Tip: Don't forget, they have cans of beer to-go so you should definitely take some home with you!”

“Pick up a Italian Sub sandwich today> EXCELLENT111”

“Everything was on point - the waitress was so pleasant i forgot her name very personable! The food was amazing large portions the taste was amazing! Sat in a little cozy room for 2 just a perfect experience! HIGHLY RECOMMEND”

“Took a side trip from my AT hike and ended up spending several hours relaxing, eating, and consuming a bucket of suds. A must stop for hikers!”

“Comfy, friendly staff, really good food.”

“Best soups and sandwiches in a 20 mile radius. They happily provide samples of soups so you can pick your favorite. I keep a running spreadsheet of the top soups from here so I can rank them. African Peanut and Clam Chowder are phenomenal.”

“Hidden gem that we’ve driven past numerous times without even realizing. Today we tried it and WOW. I had the chipotle ranch smash burger and it was out of this world. We also had a French dip which was excellent, as was the chicken rice bowl. We will definitely be back!”

“Excellent food, cocktails and atmosphere.”

“Love Village Sundaes! Best ice cream around and excellent service. Lisa and Scott really did a great job with this little spot, great comfortable places to sit and relax with a cup or cone outside. And the ability to get a custom ice cream cake put together with your favorite flavors for special occasions is AWESOME! Definitely recommend stopping by and grabbing some ice cream from here.”

“I had a lovely lunch with my friend. The food was delicious and the staff were so sweet and friendly. It felt like grand dining room at a gorgeous country side. I was very happy dining here today. I’ll definitely be back!”

“Farmer's Daughter Restaurant is a five-star restaurant all the way around.”

“Great lunch, great staff, clean and friendly atmosphere”

“My favorite deli. I love their sandwiches and how customizable they are”

“Fresh bagels and fast friendly staff. Five stars”

“Wonderful gem!”