Delivery - thin crust grandma pie with spinach and mushrooms and antipasto salad. Pizza was excellent with plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil. Nice antipasto salad with a basic oil and vinegar dressing which was delicious. Fast delivery - pizza could have been warmer but came out perfect with just a couple of minutes in the toaster oven
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ross Chesaniuk
After a long commute, I was looking for a good slice. This was not it. Pizza was burned and old, some of the lowest quality I’ve had in years.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Josephine Collura
Was charging more than menu when I questioned he hung up on me. Called back n he was nasty told me if I wanted the cheaper price order online. How do they hold onto customers?????
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
Amy B.
I paid $14 for an antipasto salad. I got basically a head of lettuce for $14!!! Not 1 tomato, no onion slices, no olives, not even a cucumber, no carrots or even a radish. For $14 I expect more than salad and a few pieces of meat. I picked up and there wasn't a soul in the place but the workers. That was a red flag right there, but I already placed my order and wasn't going to leave it. This was my first and last time going to this particular place. Unless they step up their game, not sure how they survive. I should have read the reviews but was in a hurry.
Zach F
The best wings I have ever had...I am being 100% honest when I say I have not had a better wing at any other restaurant, pizzeria, and even Buffalo wild wings. They are breaded to perfection and cooked perfectly. The only spot I'm going to get wings from now on!
Food: 5
Matt M.
After trying dozens of pizza places looking for a simple go-to, the "Old Fashion" here at Brooklyn Pizza has taken lead. Their red sauce is sweet and I can't get enough of it. We have been ordering here every other week or so for a while now and can't go wrong with the old fashion, a calzone, or the eggplant roletini, or anything else with their marinara.
Elegantease
Very picky about our pizza. Not too many good local pizza places in Long Hill Township. We have ordered take out pizza twice from here and very pleased. It’s thin crust and tasty saucy. Pepperoni pizza and Grandma’s pie our favorite. Grandma’s pie a bit pricey but standard cheese and one topping pies in line with other spots. Rice balls are tasty too. There spit in Short Hills is consistent and good too.
Matthew Miller
Moved here from Jersey City about a year ago and this is the best delivery pizza we’ve tried in the area. Crispy thin crust and the red sauce is amazing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alayna Gravy
Amazing food! Great place to go, vary nice and friendly staff. Highly recommend stopping by.??
I got a large cheese pizza tonight and it was excellent. I must say truly lives up to the Brooklyn name. They are in an odd location. It’s not the best but it’s worth going here my father, who is very picky had some of this pizza and had an extra slice because he said it was good and let me tell you something he never says it’s good and he’s hundred percent Italian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian A.
used a food service app to order a pie. when the car pulled up I grabbed it right away. got it inside, and it was stone cold (and looked it, too). It was legitimately pretty far from me, so I chalked it up to that, not blaming anyone. re-heated in the toaster oven. But it was very bland. With three meats on it, that is hard to believe.Something Wrong.
Alex Reed
Excellent neighborhood pizzeria! I’ve tried traditional and Sicilian pies, wings, and garlic knots and have only positive things to say.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
CTP Home Services LLC
Foods not bad, never ready when they say it's going to be staff seems very confused all the time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Bernard Langs
The food from Brooklyn Pizza is among the best take-out in this area of NJ. We've lived in New Providence and Gillette for 26 years and Brooklyn Pizza's delicious Grandma's Pizza, hot heroes, pastas, and appetizers are great each time - and the kitchen & register/phone staff work hard and are super nice. We've lived in the 1980s and '90s in Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens and we've never "experienced" a Grandma's Pizza until we found THIS Brooklyn. I tell my friends living in NY that Jersey pizza is as good if not better than anything you get in Manhattan, Queens and - aye, fuggedabout it- get on the Turnpike and check out Brooklyn Pizza in Sterling and you may be moving to the Garden State soon enough! Which exit??
Delivery - thin crust grandma pie with spinach and mushrooms and antipasto salad. Pizza was excellent with plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil. Nice antipasto salad with a basic oil and vinegar dressing which was delicious. Fast delivery - pizza could have been warmer but came out perfect with just a couple of minutes in the toaster oven
Food: 4
Service: 5
After a long commute, I was looking for a good slice. This was not it. Pizza was burned and old, some of the lowest quality I’ve had in years.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Was charging more than menu when I questioned he hung up on me. Called back n he was nasty told me if I wanted the cheaper price order online. How do they hold onto customers?????
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wings
I paid $14 for an antipasto salad. I got basically a head of lettuce for $14!!! Not 1 tomato, no onion slices, no olives, not even a cucumber, no carrots or even a radish. For $14 I expect more than salad and a few pieces of meat. I picked up and there wasn't a soul in the place but the workers. That was a red flag right there, but I already placed my order and wasn't going to leave it. This was my first and last time going to this particular place. Unless they step up their game, not sure how they survive. I should have read the reviews but was in a hurry.
The best wings I have ever had...I am being 100% honest when I say I have not had a better wing at any other restaurant, pizzeria, and even Buffalo wild wings. They are breaded to perfection and cooked perfectly. The only spot I'm going to get wings from now on!
Food: 5
After trying dozens of pizza places looking for a simple go-to, the "Old Fashion" here at Brooklyn Pizza has taken lead. Their red sauce is sweet and I can't get enough of it. We have been ordering here every other week or so for a while now and can't go wrong with the old fashion, a calzone, or the eggplant roletini, or anything else with their marinara.
Very picky about our pizza. Not too many good local pizza places in Long Hill Township. We have ordered take out pizza twice from here and very pleased. It’s thin crust and tasty saucy. Pepperoni pizza and Grandma’s pie our favorite. Grandma’s pie a bit pricey but standard cheese and one topping pies in line with other spots. Rice balls are tasty too. There spit in Short Hills is consistent and good too.
Moved here from Jersey City about a year ago and this is the best delivery pizza we’ve tried in the area. Crispy thin crust and the red sauce is amazing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food! Great place to go, vary nice and friendly staff. Highly recommend stopping by.??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza and very friendly atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I got a large cheese pizza tonight and it was excellent. I must say truly lives up to the Brooklyn name. They are in an odd location. It’s not the best but it’s worth going here my father, who is very picky had some of this pizza and had an extra slice because he said it was good and let me tell you something he never says it’s good and he’s hundred percent Italian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
used a food service app to order a pie. when the car pulled up I grabbed it right away. got it inside, and it was stone cold (and looked it, too). It was legitimately pretty far from me, so I chalked it up to that, not blaming anyone. re-heated in the toaster oven. But it was very bland. With three meats on it, that is hard to believe.Something Wrong.
Excellent neighborhood pizzeria! I’ve tried traditional and Sicilian pies, wings, and garlic knots and have only positive things to say.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Foods not bad, never ready when they say it's going to be staff seems very confused all the time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
The food from Brooklyn Pizza is among the best take-out in this area of NJ. We've lived in New Providence and Gillette for 26 years and Brooklyn Pizza's delicious Grandma's Pizza, hot heroes, pastas, and appetizers are great each time - and the kitchen & register/phone staff work hard and are super nice. We've lived in the 1980s and '90s in Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens and we've never "experienced" a Grandma's Pizza until we found THIS Brooklyn. I tell my friends living in NY that Jersey pizza is as good if not better than anything you get in Manhattan, Queens and - aye, fuggedabout it- get on the Turnpike and check out Brooklyn Pizza in Sterling and you may be moving to the Garden State soon enough! Which exit??
Food: 5
Service: 5