The ice cream here is great! Many good selections of flavors and toppings. The staff is very kind and were very understanding towards my brother who has a disability. Definitely would recommend!
Nick Rumaczyk
Amazing flavors and service. Got a cup for hot fudge, but next time definitely have to try their homemade waffle cone
Sunday Night Streaming
Great ice cream, smooth and packed with flavor. Will be back for sure. Peep @sundaynightstreaming on instagram for a full review
Zack Bond
Stirling Fountain is the best ice cream spot around. I’m a huge fan and go there all the time in the summer. Would definitely recommend!
Rory Hand
Best cones in NJ!
gregory lauricella
Stirling Fountain is hands down one of the best ice cream spots I’ve ever been to. It’s got that classic, old-school vibe that makes you feel like a kid again the second you walk up.
The ice cream is so good. super creamy, great flavor options, and they give you big scoops. Everything just tastes fresh and homemade. I had a sundae and a milkshake (because why not), and both were amazing.
The people there are super friendly, and you can tell they actually care about what they’re serving. It’s just one of those places that feels special, like a little hidden gem.
If you’re anywhere near Stirling, do yourself a favor and stop by. You won’t regret it.
Rob Macey
Fantastic ice cream and the decor was equally as amazing!! Definitely coming back!
Polly Wardell
Pro: ice cream was fine Con: the service couldn’t have been worse. We ordered four ice creams individually. Each one was handed to us wrong. The manager told us we were ordering by the wrong words (jr instead of kid). When handing the second order to us, I touched the rim and realized it was missing sprinkles. They scolded us that we ordered wrong and that shouldn’t adjust their mistake because we touched it. We were so stunned that we didn’t correct them for the wrong size of the third cup. And the fourth was also missing sprinkles. They glared at us while we were eating. And groaned when we opened the door to leave. Honestly. We said please, thank you, I’m sorry for the confusion. But they were beyond annoyed by our business. Never returning
JL Master LF
Came here excited to try something new with gf. The staff was a little rude and almost arrogant. I understand it could be busy but it is no reason to be so hostile. The service was low quality and the flavor on the ice cream was very bland… especially for over $20 for 2 people. The strawberry flavor was mediocre at best, not to mention the cone was stale. The vanilla ice cream had zero flavor. Does not compare to Magnifico’s ice cream or the ice cream shops in Princeton. Maybe we got the wrong flavors but overall was not the best experience and won’t be returning.
Rick Lechtman
Visited the last two Friday nights, exceptional homemade ice cream flavors and waffle cones…great vibe and terrific service…worth the drive!!!
Best ice cream shop in the area! Amazing staff and owner. Will be there again soon!
Frank Toresco
Great ice cream! Great customer experience.
Kenneth Maser
We have always had a great experience when we were there.
Frieda Menos
Delicious and fresh flavors!
elizabeth
The Stirling Fountain is a MUST-VISIT destination for anyone who loves ice cream (and let's be real, who doesn't?!). This charming shop is a gem in our community, and I'm so grateful to have it nearby.
The staff at the Stirling Fountain are truly exceptional. They're friendly, patient, and always willing to go the extra mile to make sure every customer leaves happy. My kids adore them, and I do too!
But the real star of the show is the ice cream itself. Oh. My. Goodness. The flavors are unique, delicious, and expertly crafted. From classic favorites to creative twists, there's something for every taste bud.
What I love most about the Stirling Fountain, though, is the way it brings our community together. It's a gathering place where friends and family can come together, enjoy a sweet treat, and make memories that will last a lifetime.
If you haven't been to the Stirling Fountain yet, what are you waiting for? Get yourself down there and taste the magic for yourself. Your taste buds (and your kids) will thank you!
The ice cream here is great! Many good selections of flavors and toppings. The staff is very kind and were very understanding towards my brother who has a disability. Definitely would recommend!
Amazing flavors and service. Got a cup for hot fudge, but next time definitely have to try their homemade waffle cone
Great ice cream, smooth and packed with flavor. Will be back for sure. Peep @sundaynightstreaming on instagram for a full review
Stirling Fountain is the best ice cream spot around. I’m a huge fan and go there all the time in the summer. Would definitely recommend!
Best cones in NJ!
Stirling Fountain is hands down one of the best ice cream spots I’ve ever been to. It’s got that classic, old-school vibe that makes you feel like a kid again the second you walk up.
The ice cream is so good. super creamy, great flavor options, and they give you big scoops. Everything just tastes fresh and homemade. I had a sundae and a milkshake (because why not), and both were amazing.
The people there are super friendly, and you can tell they actually care about what they’re serving. It’s just one of those places that feels special, like a little hidden gem.
If you’re anywhere near Stirling, do yourself a favor and stop by. You won’t regret it.
Fantastic ice cream and the decor was equally as amazing!! Definitely coming back!
Pro: ice cream was fine
Con: the service couldn’t have been worse. We ordered four ice creams individually. Each one was handed to us wrong. The manager told us we were ordering by the wrong words (jr instead of kid). When handing the second order to us, I touched the rim and realized it was missing sprinkles. They scolded us that we ordered wrong and that shouldn’t adjust their mistake because we touched it. We were so stunned that we didn’t correct them for the wrong size of the third cup. And the fourth was also missing sprinkles. They glared at us while we were eating. And groaned when we opened the door to leave. Honestly. We said please, thank you, I’m sorry for the confusion. But they were beyond annoyed by our business. Never returning
Came here excited to try something new with gf. The staff was a little rude and almost arrogant. I understand it could be busy but it is no reason to be so hostile. The service was low quality and the flavor on the ice cream was very bland… especially for over $20 for 2 people. The strawberry flavor was mediocre at best, not to mention the cone was stale. The vanilla ice cream had zero flavor. Does not compare to Magnifico’s ice cream or the ice cream shops in Princeton. Maybe we got the wrong flavors but overall was not the best experience and won’t be returning.
Visited the last two Friday nights, exceptional homemade ice cream flavors and waffle cones…great vibe and terrific service…worth the drive!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream shop in the area! Amazing staff and owner. Will be there again soon!
Great ice cream! Great customer experience.
We have always had a great experience when we were there.
Delicious and fresh flavors!
The Stirling Fountain is a MUST-VISIT destination for anyone who loves ice cream (and let's be real, who doesn't?!). This charming shop is a gem in our community, and I'm so grateful to have it nearby.
The staff at the Stirling Fountain are truly exceptional. They're friendly, patient, and always willing to go the extra mile to make sure every customer leaves happy. My kids adore them, and I do too!
But the real star of the show is the ice cream itself. Oh. My. Goodness. The flavors are unique, delicious, and expertly crafted. From classic favorites to creative twists, there's something for every taste bud.
What I love most about the Stirling Fountain, though, is the way it brings our community together. It's a gathering place where friends and family can come together, enjoy a sweet treat, and make memories that will last a lifetime.
If you haven't been to the Stirling Fountain yet, what are you waiting for? Get yourself down there and taste the magic for yourself. Your taste buds (and your kids) will thank you!
Loading...