Had to throw out a BEC because they completely disregarded my instructions and the whole thing was a runny disgusting mess. What a waste of $7. Asked for eggs over medium they were completely runny. Cheese barely melted. Bagel mushy. Bacon undercooked when I asked for it well. I couldn’t be bothered to take it back. Would not go back. 0/10 stars. Do not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Ava Dipasquale
I am a regular customer here and I just cant get enough of their food. I at least come here 3 times a week and the service is always amazing! Breakfast or lunch I definitely recommend this bagel store!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fran Ross
We stopped here 3/3/24 for the first time. We are local in Holiday Heights Toms River. This is near the Miracle Bar. We ordered a bagel and lox which was made perfectly. Cream cheese of both sides which was better then just one side. Healthy amount of Lox, which were taken our of their refrigerator fresh. We also bought 2 blueberry and 1 orange/cranberry for home. We just toasted the bagel. It was so fresh and delicious, light, not too doughy and lots of blueberries. This is our new Bagel Stop! This store started in Jackson where we used to live. Friendly staff. Plenty of employees working the toaster, grill with eggs. Busy and quickly got our order together, FRESH!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Destefano
Not the same with new ownership. Missing something from pickups 3/5 times
Laura Hamilton
I hate to do this but if I can save someone else some money its worth it. Without exaggeration these are the worst bagels, and possibly worst food, I've ever had :( They are inedible. They taste like store bought bagels except overbaked and stale so they are physically cracked. The only thing I can think of is that they are left out overnight or something. I got a salt bagel and there was so much salt that you couldn't even see the bagel and the bagel itself was so burnt that I couldn't scrape it off. You can tell the whole exterior layer of the bagel is burnt and stale. The only explanation is that they just don't care, because anyone who cuts this and serves it to someone can see it. Just go to shoprite and save your money. I had to throw it away. I hope they do better because this has been more than once for me.
Food: 1
jailranger18121
I'm very disappointed the play areas were very dirty. I'm not talking one day dirty but not clean in months dirty food and unhealthy uncleanness areas. The slide area had mats in between the mats were food and trash that could make you sick. So you know that it won't cleaned or wiped down in months.Wish I had my phone but I didn't sorry. Next time if I happen to go by I will show why health depth should fine them for starters
Atmosphere: 1
Shawn Mcgee
Great food ?
Jerry Cotugno
If you’re in Toms River and are lookin for a bagel you’re crazy to go anywhere else. The family that works the shop makes me feel like family every time I walk in. There’s no better way to start my day each morning then chatting with guys like Joe, Drew, or Max while having, by far one of the best, breakfast sandwiches I’ve ever had. I’ve lived in NJ my entire life, so I know a good egg sandwich when I see one, and All Star bagels does not play around. BEST BAGELS, BEST OWNERSHIP, BEST STATE!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels & 1 Large Plain Cream Cheese, Salmon Cream Cheese, Pork Roll Egg &Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel, Everything Bagel with Pork Roll Egg and Cheese, Homerun
Chris Coll
I’m from New York and I love the bagels, actually stopped into Manhattan bagels as well and noticed a remarkable difference. The bagels are great and so is the service… definitely going back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
B
This All Star bagel location is horrible. Cold food, a menu on the wall that can barely be seen, even with glasses. Manhattan bagel has it on you!
The customer service was amazing they were very helpful the donut was very fresh and delicious the cookies were just ok.. but I would definitely recommend and return
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Claudia
Look carefully in the kitchen work area in Toms River bagel shop. It is hard to see, but keep looking beyond counter. Hasn't been cleaned since they opened. Yuck.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Miha Mal
1 questions why is ur bacon ? ever cook the right way wen I ask bacon egg and Chs why is the bacon under cook never crispy ever is horrible to actually eat a bacon sandwich wen the bacon is not crispy at all cook the bacon the right way or the cook should get another job
Ahren Frey
Easily one of the best bagels I have ever had, and the staff was absolutely delightful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lew Gio
Nice sandwich, have been here a few times and they haven't disappointed yetI recommend stopping in and judging for
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pork Roll Egg &Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel
Had to throw out a BEC because they completely disregarded my instructions and the whole thing was a runny disgusting mess. What a waste of $7. Asked for eggs over medium they were completely runny. Cheese barely melted. Bagel mushy. Bacon undercooked when I asked for it well. I couldn’t be bothered to take it back. Would not go back. 0/10 stars. Do not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
I am a regular customer here and I just cant get enough of their food. I at least come here 3 times a week and the service is always amazing! Breakfast or lunch I definitely recommend this bagel store!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped here 3/3/24 for the first time. We are local in Holiday Heights Toms River. This is near the Miracle Bar. We ordered a bagel and lox which was made perfectly. Cream cheese of both sides which was better then just one side. Healthy amount of Lox, which were taken our of their refrigerator fresh. We also bought 2 blueberry and 1 orange/cranberry for home. We just toasted the bagel. It was so fresh and delicious, light, not too doughy and lots of blueberries. This is our new Bagel Stop! This store started in Jackson where we used to live. Friendly staff. Plenty of employees working the toaster, grill with eggs. Busy and quickly got our order together, FRESH!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not the same with new ownership. Missing something from pickups 3/5 times
I hate to do this but if I can save someone else some money its worth it. Without exaggeration these are the worst bagels, and possibly worst food, I've ever had :( They are inedible. They taste like store bought bagels except overbaked and stale so they are physically cracked. The only thing I can think of is that they are left out overnight or something. I got a salt bagel and there was so much salt that you couldn't even see the bagel and the bagel itself was so burnt that I couldn't scrape it off. You can tell the whole exterior layer of the bagel is burnt and stale. The only explanation is that they just don't care, because anyone who cuts this and serves it to someone can see it. Just go to shoprite and save your money. I had to throw it away. I hope they do better because this has been more than once for me.
Food: 1
I'm very disappointed the play areas were very dirty. I'm not talking one day dirty but not clean in months dirty food and unhealthy uncleanness areas. The slide area had mats in between the mats were food and trash that could make you sick. So you know that it won't cleaned or wiped down in months.Wish I had my phone but I didn't sorry. Next time if I happen to go by I will show why health depth should fine them for starters
Atmosphere: 1
Great food ?
If you’re in Toms River and are lookin for a bagel you’re crazy to go anywhere else. The family that works the shop makes me feel like family every time I walk in. There’s no better way to start my day each morning then chatting with guys like Joe, Drew, or Max while having, by far one of the best, breakfast sandwiches I’ve ever had. I’ve lived in NJ my entire life, so I know a good egg sandwich when I see one, and All Star bagels does not play around. BEST BAGELS, BEST OWNERSHIP, BEST STATE!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels & 1 Large Plain Cream Cheese, Salmon Cream Cheese, Pork Roll Egg &Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel, Everything Bagel with Pork Roll Egg and Cheese, Homerun
I’m from New York and I love the bagels, actually stopped into Manhattan bagels as well and noticed a remarkable difference. The bagels are great and so is the service… definitely going back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This All Star bagel location is horrible. Cold food, a menu on the wall that can barely be seen, even with glasses. Manhattan bagel has it on you!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The customer service was amazing they were very helpful the donut was very fresh and delicious the cookies were just ok.. but I would definitely recommend and return
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Look carefully in the kitchen work area in Toms River bagel shop. It is hard to see, but keep looking beyond counter. Hasn't been cleaned since they opened. Yuck.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
1 questions why is ur bacon ? ever cook the right way wen I ask bacon egg and Chs why is the bacon under cook never crispy ever is horrible to actually eat a bacon sandwich wen the bacon is not crispy at all cook the bacon the right way or the cook should get another job
Easily one of the best bagels I have ever had, and the staff was absolutely delightful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice sandwich, have been here a few times and they haven't disappointed yetI recommend stopping in and judging for
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pork Roll Egg &Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel