All Star Bagel Toms River
181 NJ-37, Toms River
(732) 831-4807
Customers' Favorites
Dozen Bagels \u0026 1 Large Plain Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel with Pork Roll Egg and Cheese
Pork Roll Egg &Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel
Dozen Bagels & 1 Large Plain Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Salmon Cream Cheese
Baked Fresh Daily
Egg & Cheese
Tuna Salad
Homerun
Menu
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The owner and his son were so friendly and showed excellent hospitality. Need more businesses like them who remember that the customer is at the center of what they do. The bagels were excellent too. This is definitely our new go-to breakfast takeout spot.
This place has absolutely amazing bagels. Bagels are soft and warm, and oh-so-perfect, no matter if they're plain or loaded with yummy extras. Place was busy, if that says anything. I think they kind of skimp on the need for napkins, however. I got a to-go order of 3 bagel sammiches, for 3 different people, with a whopping 1 (one) napkin in my bag. Guess the 3 of us were supposed to share. There were also no napkins out, only behind the counter. So, be warned to supply...
Stopped by this morning and got a bacon and egg on a sesame bagel- delicious. Bagel was fresh and the bacon was thicker than any other bagel shop I’ve been to. Will be back for sure :)
You May Also Like
Slice House - 177 NJ-37
![]()
Pizza, Salad
Sub Doctors - 167 NJ-37 A
![]()
Sandwich Shop
Miracle Pub - 201 NJ-37
![]()
Bar, Pubs, Sports Bar