Attilio's of Tom's River

941 NJ-166, Toms River
(732) 240-1331

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lauralei

This is a local pizza joint but they have a few vegan options. We ordered vegan garlic knots and a roasted veggie vegan pizza with added artichokes and both were fantastic. I was visiting family in the area and the vegans and non vegans were all very happy with our food. We drove a bit out of the way to go to Attilios and are glad that we did!

Ennis Williams

Living south of the mason Dixon line, it's hard to find good pizza. This pizza was pretty good. The garlic knots were very good 👍

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Virna Simpson

Worst sub ever!!!!! Will not he back here!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kelly Mortellite

Never again! Received a cold pizza that looks and tastes 3 days old for $30. We called to let them know and the kid had nothing to say but my boss left. We will not be ever ordering again and we have been steady customers over the years.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

C Galanos

I believe I was sold an all day old pizza tonight maybe a 2day old pizza was hard as a rock and extremely salty. (One bite 🤮)
No we did NOT order a well done pizza- it was close to closing time and we got leftover.
Bottom is from yours truly.
Top is from Mangia.
SMH. Yes had to order from another place. So disgusting.
Was worth losing the $, all 3 families here@my house now no better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Theresa A

I just ordered pizza from you the first time for delivery. It came very salty

Tammy Dwight

Loved this place - order constantly, everything from pizza/cheese steaks/antipasto/chix franchaise...but this time they dropped the ball big time!!! 2 hrs to receive cold food - usual typical order - and no reasonable explanation, very disappointed

Service: 1

Christian

Lack luster nothing special just easy place to stop since it's on my way home.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Dana Telaj

I complained and spoke to to owner who did not care about my concerns as a costumer what’s so ever he told me to basically deal with it .. I spent $60 dollars on 1 pie and 2 small chicken cheese steaks .. the pie was tiny and the thinnest pizza . there was no chicken on the sandwich was so dry not a real chicken cheesesteak .. the owner didn’t care to accommodate us what so ever just dismissed our concerns I will never order from here again !.. do not recommend!

Food: 1

Service: 1

Thomas Andre

50 dollars for a grand ma pie with sausage and fried onions and half the pizza didn’t even have sausage on it absolutely disgusting never order from them!!!!

Food: 1

Service: 1

ha ha Nope

Used to be really good quality but lately the food is mid.. look at my ozempic mozzarella stick

Anthony Alberto

Best pizza ever , I’m reallly good at jokes also

C L

As a regular customer for the pizza, I have never had any issues. But I’m reaching out because I never got a response on Facebook. I decided to treat myself and spend the 20+ dollars and grab a chicken Parm dinner… I typically will go over to ShopRite and grab one of the $11.99 two large chicken breast Parm… in the prepared meals, refrigerated section and bring it home.. I was hungry and sprung for the hot chicken Parm dinner. I just wanted to express my disappointment… The chicken Parm is made with frozen chicken patties. And not like the white meat Purdue breaded chicken breast, You would find refrigerated in the meat section… this was like the frozen banquet brand… spongy, spicy breading, we will call it light meat as it was a toss between dark and white… it was such a disappointment when spending over $20. Unfortunately, I chose not to eat it, toss and get my chicken Parm fix A few days later. I am disappointed I did not get the chicken française or marsala, as I would assume that would be real chicken.. they were all the same cost.
my family will continue to pick up pies on the weekend as the pizza is excellent, but I really think the chicken parm needs to be changed

Terry Matthews

I’m posting this 5 star review for all the great meals this establishment has served me over the years. If it’s possible, I’ll attempt to submit yet another 5 star review for all the 1 star responses this establishment has submitted…just as good as the pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Slice of Pizza

Shannon Mahedy

Attilio’s pizza makes your worries disappear for a brief moment, and that’s true magic. Gooey cheese, soft chewy crust, and sweet sauce await you at Attilio’s. I grew up in New Jersey, but I now live in the Midwest. Whenever I visit family in New Jersey, my first stop is Attilio’s. Their pizza feels like home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...