Attilio's of Tom's River

941 NJ-166, Toms River
(732) 240-1331

Recent Reviews

Sue Frey

Ordered from Uber eats, for the second time our food came very over cooked and almost uneatable. Tonight we ordered a meatball sub w/ extra cheese and a sausage Parm sub. Never had a sausage Parm with grease dripping out of it .Both subs where overcooked, couldn't eat one side of the bread, no extra cheese. Last time we ordered we got a burnt pizza. We have been ordering from them for 3 years and always loved the food. Maybe they have a new chef. We order at least 3 times a month and will give them one more chance ... Three strikes and they are out

Food: 1

Service: 3

Michael Smith

They have been around for so many years and the food is wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sally L.

Way overpriced for pizza. Toppings which were few and far between increased the cost of 3, 12 inch pies plus delivery to $75.00+. My toppings were onions, green peppers and mushroom. There was one slice of mushroom on each slice and onions and peppers were scant also. Won't be ordering there again.

Gidget

The gf vegan pizza was delicious!

David N.

For some reason they're unable to deliver good food. My opinion they simply have leftover food , return food and that's what they give when they deliver. You sit down and eat in the restaurant the food's good if you have it delivered throw it out.

Aaron Dirodrico

I haven't been a big fan of attilio's pizza for a while the pizza has been known to be pretty greasy. I've ordered from them on GrubHub and I have been disappointed. I ordered from GrubHub again today add to my surprises Pizza is different than it's been. No grease no oil it looks like it's higher quality ingredients. Unfortunately the delivery driver for GrubHub left my pizza on the ground but as far as the food was concerned it was very good

Food: 5

Service: 3

Cruz Mojica

Food dry as heck and cold, almost choked. Management was no help nor did she care. Waited 10min+ to order just to hate the food and experience bottom tier service. At least be kind to the customers lady.

henry matos

I have never seen nor met such a nasty and terrible manager/owner. This place left much to be desired. Unfortunately i will not return after seeing a woman and her child be addressed with hatred. I didnt take the owner as a racist but you never know now a days.

Service: 1

Tiffany Urena

Unfortunately i cannot continue to come here with my family. Wait times arent an issue necessarily if the staff is friendly and food is good. However, here at this establishment i wasnt addressed at all after waiting almost 10 minutes for my order to be taken. When I asked for assistance i was met with the worst attitude from the owner. 0/10 DO NOT RECOMMEND

Service: 1

Nikki

Abhorrent racist behavior by the owner, horrible experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ronald Scott

great vegan options

Minnie

Horrible owner & horrible attitude. Unbelievable!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Derek Boman

If you leave a customer waiting for 10 minutes to take an order and they ask for service maybe you shouldn’t respond by saying “ can’t you see I’m busy here” and then proceed to kick them out the store because you didn’t like the fact they asked to be helped. Thanks for what you did to my 15 year old . She needs to learn that people like you exist in this world. Sorry about whatever happened to you in life but people don’t deserve to get treated like this for asking to be helped.

Madison Lloyd

Horrible, rude customer service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dominick Dakarla

First time here definitely lives up to the reputation. Detroit pizza/ vegan pizza / garlic knots/ escarole beans etc etc all great and super nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More