Speciality slices and cheese steaks are out of this world. Service is super friendly and pizzeria is clean. This is one place you don't want to skip out on this summer.Slice in photo is buffalo chicken.Vegetarian options: Salads, etc.Parking: Spots are shared with neighbor businesses in plaza lot.Wheelchair accessibility: Front entrance has wheelchair accessible ramp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Special, Cheese Steak
Pat P.
pizza was oily and greasy! called owner and he was nasty. Don't order from here! Place doesn't deserve any stars!
Johnny Devine
Very good and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynne A
Ordered some food for New Year’s Day because a lot of other local spots were closed. This was a delight! The pizza was delicious: the cheese, sauce, and crust were all very tasty. I also ordered a chicken francaise and it was very good as well! I think they just got a new customer!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Vega
Got a specialty pizza which was really good but I can't give it 5 stars because of the "garlic knot crust". It was so disappointing because all it is was the same regular crust but just shaped like a garlic knot with just a sprinkle of garlic powder. I was hoping they'd at the very least be topped with some real garlic and some kind of oil or butter. It ended up just being thrown in the trash because it was just dry dough. Definitely would have just preferred regular crust at that point.
Food: 4
Elizabeth B.
I ate here with a friend after reading some good reviews of the place, and we were both really pleased with the food. The plain cheese pie was delicious, and the slices we ordered were quite large. We also got sandwiches. I think it's difficult to find a really tasty eggplant parm, but Italy's Best III makes a very good one. My friend ordered the chicken Francaise sandwich and loved it! The food is fresh tasting and delicious. The staff here is really friendly and helpful. We're looking forward to working our way through the menu.
Dante F.
We stopped here on the way home from Seaside Heights. The foods was decent at good prices. Really liked the staff! They are on top of their game! We ordered our food and it was our within 15 mins. That's with them starting to get busy at that point. I highly recommend the Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza! The plain was ok and the cheese steak was ok. Really not the way I like it but it was ok. I would recommend stopping while in town!
Irfan Neimarlija
Moved down from Brooklyn recently, my wife and I were testing out what pizza/Italian joint is going to be our go to! Everything is made in house and the vodka sauce and pizza show. We found our spot! Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas DePaolo
Got a grandmas pie, a salad and jalapeño poppers, and I'll start by saying the Jalapeño poppers were awesome just not sure if homemade or not. After that the experience got bad. The pizza was extremely soggy and flopped right over and the cheese and sauce just slopped off onto the plate. The salad was missing ingredients including olives and artichokes which was why we ordered that salad. Super disappointed as the first time we ordered it was alot better, but probably will not be ordering again.
First of all all three of us ordered something different, all three of us were very pleased, very good tasting food. Customer service very nice and helpful. Will go back there when ever I’m in town ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dolan D.
Amazing food, great owners-we're weekly repeats. Always personable, reasonable prices and the pizza is incredible.
Michael Pannucci
I’m from north Jersey, and whenever I visit Toms River, this is the only pizza that I’ll get. Great quality and they make the crust just right. Also such friendly people who work there. They are always so pleasant when I come in to pick up my order. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Juan M.
We just ordered a chicken, Bacon Ranch pizza and wow is sooooo good and packed with real chicken and Bacon and the right amount of Ranch....I never leave any comments anywhere but Italys best 3 is the best also try out their delicious Jalapeño poppers sooo delicious! Thank you guys from Juan M.
Jim D.
It's been two years since being in NJ and I alway stop here for pizza. Come to find out that they sold out. The first thing that came to mind is will the pizza be just as good, yes it was and much better. By the menu size it's more then a pizza parlor. Now the only thing I can really speak about is the pizza and it was really good! When I first walked in I was greeted and was shown a menu (lol come to find out it was the owners son) I told him what I was looking for and he said to look at the Combo Pizza so I ended up getting that. If you never have been here take it from me, TRY THEM! I can't until I come back home to have more of the good stuff!
i thought this was a taco bell
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Speciality slices and cheese steaks are out of this world. Service is super friendly and pizzeria is clean. This is one place you don't want to skip out on this summer.Slice in photo is buffalo chicken.Vegetarian options: Salads, etc.Parking: Spots are shared with neighbor businesses in plaza lot.Wheelchair accessibility: Front entrance has wheelchair accessible ramp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Special, Cheese Steak
pizza was oily and greasy! called owner and he was nasty. Don't order from here! Place doesn't deserve any stars!
Very good and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered some food for New Year’s Day because a lot of other local spots were closed. This was a delight! The pizza was delicious: the cheese, sauce, and crust were all very tasty. I also ordered a chicken francaise and it was very good as well! I think they just got a new customer!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a specialty pizza which was really good but I can't give it 5 stars because of the "garlic knot crust". It was so disappointing because all it is was the same regular crust but just shaped like a garlic knot with just a sprinkle of garlic powder. I was hoping they'd at the very least be topped with some real garlic and some kind of oil or butter. It ended up just being thrown in the trash because it was just dry dough. Definitely would have just preferred regular crust at that point.
Food: 4
I ate here with a friend after reading some good reviews of the place, and we were both really pleased with the food. The plain cheese pie was delicious, and the slices we ordered were quite large. We also got sandwiches. I think it's difficult to find a really tasty eggplant parm, but Italy's Best III makes a very good one. My friend ordered the chicken Francaise sandwich and loved it! The food is fresh tasting and delicious. The staff here is really friendly and helpful. We're looking forward to working our way through the menu.
We stopped here on the way home from Seaside Heights. The foods was decent at good prices. Really liked the staff! They are on top of their game! We ordered our food and it was our within 15 mins. That's with them starting to get busy at that point. I highly recommend the Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza! The plain was ok and the cheese steak was ok. Really not the way I like it but it was ok. I would recommend stopping while in town!
Moved down from Brooklyn recently, my wife and I were testing out what pizza/Italian joint is going to be our go to! Everything is made in house and the vodka sauce and pizza show. We found our spot! Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a grandmas pie, a salad and jalapeño poppers, and I'll start by saying the Jalapeño poppers were awesome just not sure if homemade or not. After that the experience got bad. The pizza was extremely soggy and flopped right over and the cheese and sauce just slopped off onto the plate. The salad was missing ingredients including olives and artichokes which was why we ordered that salad. Super disappointed as the first time we ordered it was alot better, but probably will not be ordering again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
First of all all three of us ordered something different, all three of us were very pleased, very good tasting food. Customer service very nice and helpful. Will go back there when ever I’m in town ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food, great owners-we're weekly repeats. Always personable, reasonable prices and the pizza is incredible.
I’m from north Jersey, and whenever I visit Toms River, this is the only pizza that I’ll get. Great quality and they make the crust just right. Also such friendly people who work there. They are always so pleasant when I come in to pick up my order. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just ordered a chicken, Bacon Ranch pizza and wow is sooooo good and packed with real chicken and Bacon and the right amount of Ranch....I never leave any comments anywhere but Italys best 3 is the best also try out their delicious Jalapeño poppers sooo delicious! Thank you guys from Juan M.
It's been two years since being in NJ and I alway stop here for pizza. Come to find out that they sold out. The first thing that came to mind is will the pizza be just as good, yes it was and much better. By the menu size it's more then a pizza parlor. Now the only thing I can really speak about is the pizza and it was really good! When I first walked in I was greeted and was shown a menu (lol come to find out it was the owners son) I told him what I was looking for and he said to look at the Combo Pizza so I ended up getting that. If you never have been here take it from me, TRY THEM! I can't until I come back home to have more of the good stuff!