New York Water Bagel Co

542 Fischer Blvd, Toms River
(732) 279-6846

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The bagels are absolutely delicious. I haven't had a good bagel for many years because I now live out of state. Luis kindly took my order by phone and I picked it up. Easy, fast, great customer service, with super delicious bagels. All of them were delicious including everything, sesame, onion, and cinnamon raisin
My husband and I found this shop for the first time yesterday. Our bagel, ham, egg, and cheese sandwiches were delicious and very well crafted. The bagels were scooped and the crusts: sesame and wheat, were perfectly crunchy. The eggs, ham, and cheese were EVENLY placed on the sandwich, so each bite was great. We were so impressed, we returned today for another try, this time on a bialy - also great! They have a huge selection of fun bagels, including chocolate chip ;). The coffee...
Best prices and fast service! Portions are big! Disregard the bad reviews this place is the best near the shore! Other places are charging 10$+ I highly recommend and they have the good ice! ?

More Reviews