New York Water Bagel Co
542 Fischer Blvd, Toms River
(732) 279-6846
Customers' Favorites
Ham Egg and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Turkey Club with Potato Salad
Ham Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Pork Roll Egg and Cheese
Flagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Flavored Cream Cheese
Cheese Steak and Eggs
Bagel with Butter
Great Bambino
Featured items
Egg, Meat, & Cheese Sandwich
2 farm-fresh eggs prepared your way with your choice of meat and cheese on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Brooklyn Bomber
Our most popular breakfast sandwich. Are 2 farm fresh eggs prepared your way with a hash brown patty, your choice of cheese, and breakfast meat on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Side of Homefries
The store-made seasoned and diced potatoes.
Breakfast Meat & Cheese No Egg
Your choice of breakfast meat and cheese on a bagel, bread, wrap, or roll.
Frappuccino (95 oz)
Great Bambino
A meat lover favorite. 2 farm fresh eggs prepared your way, with a hash brown patty, your choice of cheese, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, boar's head premium sausage patty, and Taylor brand pork roll.
French Fries
Flavored Cream Cheese
8-ounce container of your choice of our delicious store-made specialty flavored cream cheese.
Sloppy Joe
Boar's head corned beef and oven gold Turkey, cole slaw, and Russian dressing piled high between 3 slices of rye bread.
Bagel with Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
Choice of bagel with sliced nova lox, cream cheese, sliced tomatoes, red onions, and capers.
French Toast
3 slices of the best French toast you ever had made with brioche bread.
Turkey Sandwich
Start with a boar's head ovengold Turkey and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Tuna Sub (7")
Store-made albacore tuna salad mixed with a pinch of carrots and celery and Hellman's mayonnaise. Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, Swiss, and Provolone.
Ham Sandwich
Start with Boar's head deluxe ham and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Bagel with Homemade Spreads & Salads
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Soft mild cheese.
Bagel with Butter
Bagel with Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
Choice of bagel with sliced nova lox, cream cheese, sliced tomatoes, red onions, and capers.
Egg Salad
The store is made with farm fresh eggs that have been grated and mixed with seasoning and Hellman's mayonnaise.
Chicken Salad
Store-made with fresh rotisserie chicken, a pinch of celery, carrots, and Hellman's mayonnaise.
Flagel with Butter
Twist with Butter
Tuna Salad
Store-made with albacore tuna mixed with a pinch of carrots and celery and Hellman's mayonnaise.
Bialy with Butter
Bagel with PB & J
Skippy peanut butter with your choice of Smucker's strawberry jam or Welch's grape jelly.
Bagel with Nutella
Bialy with Cream Cheese
Soft mild cheese.
Flagel with Cream Cheese
Soft mild cheese.
White Fish Salad
Twist with Cream Cheese
Soft mild cheese.
Bagels
Bagel
Mini Bagel
Flagel
Twist
Butter & Homemade Spreads
Flavored Cream Cheese
8-ounce container of your choice of our delicious store-made specialty flavored cream cheese.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese (8 oz)
Block.
Breakstone Butter (8 oz)
Whitefish Salad (8 oz)
Container.
Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg, Meat, & Cheese Sandwich
2 farm-fresh eggs prepared your way with your choice of meat and cheese on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Brooklyn Bomber
Our most popular breakfast sandwich. Are 2 farm fresh eggs prepared your way with a hash brown patty, your choice of cheese, and breakfast meat on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Breakfast Meat & Cheese No Egg
Your choice of breakfast meat and cheese on a bagel, bread, wrap, or roll.
Great Bambino
A meat lover favorite. 2 farm fresh eggs prepared your way, with a hash brown patty, your choice of cheese, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, boar's head premium sausage patty, and Taylor brand pork roll.
Southwest Breakfast Wrap
2 farm fresh scrambled eggs, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, avocado, salsa, cheddar cheese, and chipotle sauce on a plain or whole wheat wrap.
Potato, Pepper, & Egg Sandwich
2 farm-fresh scrambled eggs with potatoes and bell peppers on your choice of bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Taylor Pork Roll & Cheese No Egg
Taylor brand pork roll with your choice of cheese on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Guido Breakfast Wrap
2 farm fresh scrambled eggs, boar's head premium sausage patty, roasted red peppers, potatoes, and fresh mozzarella on a plain or whole wheat wrap.
Egg & Meat Sandwich No Cheese
2 farm-fresh eggs prepared your way with your choice of meat on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Egg & Cheese Sandwich No Meat
2 farm-fresh eggs prepared your way with cheese on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Taylor Pork Roll Sandwich
Taylor brand pork roll on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Grand Slam
The ultimate double-decker breakfast sandwich stuffed with 4 eggs, 2 hash brown patties, cheese, and your choice of 2 breakfast types of meat.
Egg Sandwich
2 farm-fresh eggs prepared your way on a bagel, bread, roll, or wrap.
Breakfast Meat Sandwich
Your choice of just breakfast meat on a bagel, bread, wrap, or roll.
Breakfast Platters
French Toast
3 slices of the best French toast you ever had made with brioche bread.
Pancakes
Enjoy a stack of 3 pancakes made with our special recipe.
Veggie Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, peppers, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and mushrooms.
Cheese Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs and your choice of cheese.
Meat & Cheese Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs and your choice of breakfast meat and cheese.
Suzy's Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, potatoes, peppers, onions, and cheddar cheese.
Western Omelet with Cheese
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, boar's head deluxe ham, peppers, onions, and your choice of cheese.
Ashley's Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, baby spinach, and feta cheese.
Western Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, boar's head deluxe ham, peppers, and onions.
Cheese Steak Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, sauteed sliced steak, pepper, onions, and American cheese.
Guidette Omelet
Made with 3 farm fresh eggs, roasted red peppers, boar's head salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.
Breakfast Sides
Side of Hash Browns
2 hash brown patties.
Side of Homefries
The store-made seasoned and diced potatoes.
Side of Breakfast Meat
Your choice of boar's head applewood smoked bacon, boar's head premium sausage patty, boar's head deluxe ham, boar's head Turkey sausage patty, boar's head Turkey bacon, or Taylor brand pork roll.
Yogurt Parfait
Vanilla yogurt with fresh strawberries and blueberries topped with vanilla almond granola.
Side of Toast
Hot browned sliced bread.
Signature Sandwiches
Peter Luger
Boar's head roast beef sautéed in peter luger sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella, raw onions, and tomatoes on a 7-inch roll.
Little Italy
Boar's head prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze on a 7-inch roll.
Turkey Club
Double-decker on white toast with boar's head ovengold Turkey and a classic blt.
California Club
Breaded and fried chicken cutlet, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo on a 7-inch roll.
Canarsie
Grilled chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, fire-roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze on a 7-inch roll.
Buffalo Chicken Blt
Breaded and fried chicken breast tossed in hot sauce, with boar's head applewood smoked bacon, and pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, and tomato on a 7-inch roll.
Philly Cheesesteak
Sliced and sauteed chicken or beef with American cheese, peppers, onions, and mushrooms on a 7-inch roll.
Tavern on the Green
Boar's head deluxe ham, applewood smoked bacon, and Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, and pepper house gourmandize on a 7-inch roll.
The Verrazano
Boar's head roast beef, asiago cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and horseradish sauce on a 7-inch roll.
Classic Chicken
Breaded or grilled chicken cutlet, lettuce, and tomato on a 7-inch roll.
Empire State
Boar's head deluxe ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, sharp picante provolone, banana peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, and balsamic dressing on a 7-inch roll.
La Griglia
Grilled chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, and broccoli rabe sauteed with garlic on a 7-inch roll.
Spanish Harlem
Breaded and fried chicken cutlet, boar's head 3 pepper Colby Jack cheese, hot banana peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, and savory remoulade on a 7-inch roll.
Dyker Heights
Grilled chicken cutlet, asiago cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and Caesar dressing in a plain or whole wheat wrap.
Hell's Kitchen
Grilled chicken cutlet, boar's head pepper Jack cheese, banana peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, and creamy ranch or blue cheese dressing on a 7-inch roll.
18th avenue
Breaded and fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, spring mix, and balsamic dressing in a plain or whole wheat wrap.
The Avenue
Breaded and fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, fire-roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze on a 7-inch roll.
Sloppy Joe
Boar's head corned beef and oven gold Turkey, cole slaw, and Russian dressing piled high between 3 slices of rye bread.
Reuben
Boar's head grilled corned beef and imported Swiss, kraut, and Russian dressing on rye.
The Upstate
Boar's head roast beef and Vermont cheddar sauteed with onions and topped with horseradish sauce on a 7-inch roll.
The Bensonhurst
Boar's head hot cappy ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, picante provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, and tomatoes on a 7-inch roll.
Tottenville
Breaded and fried chicken cutlet with grilled boar's head deluxe ham and melted imported Swiss, fried onions, lettuce, and tomatoes on a 7-inch roll.
Howard Beach
Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, basil, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze on a 7-inch roll.
Cheesesteak
Sliced and sauteed chicken or beef with American cheese on a 7-inch roll.
The Bowery
Boar's head pastrami and imported Swiss grilled with sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye.
Sheepshead Bay
Grilled chicken cutlet, BBQ sauce, and boar's head applewood smoked bacon and pepper Jack cheese with fried onions on a 7-inch roll.
Central Park
Boar's head applewood smoked bacon, fresh avocado, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo on toast.
Belt Parkway
Grilled chicken cutlet, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, and Vermont cheddar with ranch dressing on a 7-inch roll.
The East Village
Boar's head ovengold Turkey and picante provolone, Asian coleslaw, lettuce, tomatoes, and red onions. Honey mustard and mayo in a whole wheat wrap.
Queens Delight
Boar's head roast beef and asiago cheese, sautéed broccoli rabe, and fried onions on a 7-inch roll.
New York Cheesesteak
Sliced and sauteed chicken or beef with boar's head picante provolone and roasted red peppers on a 7-inch roll.
Gourmet Cheesesteak
Sliced and sauteed chicken or beef with asiago cheese and sautéed broccoli rabe on a 7-inch roll.
Hot From the Grill & Fryer
French Fries
Blt
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, sliced tomatoes, and mayo. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
NYWBC Burger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger topped with American and cheddar cheeses. Boar's head applewood smoked bacon, fried onions, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and special sauce on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries ). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Angus Cheeseburger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger with your choice of cheese on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Chicken Fingers
Battered and fried chicken tenders. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Jersey Burger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger and Taylor brand pork roll topped with fried onions and American cheese on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Grilled Cheese, Bacon, & Tomato
Classic grilled cheese sandwich with boar's head applewood smoked bacon and sliced tomato. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Grilled Cheese
Classic grilled cheese sandwich. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Bronx Burger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger topped with onion rings, pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, and BBQ sauce on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Black Angus Burger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Guido Burger (8 oz)
Black Angus burger topped with mozzarella and asiago cheeses, peppers, onions, and marinara sauce on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
South of the Border Burger
Black Angus burger. Boar's head pepper Jack cheese, avocado, lettuce, and tomatoes on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Turkey Burger (6 oz)
Turkey burger on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Turkey Cheeseburger (6 oz)
Turkey burger with your choice of cheese on a brioche bun. Make it a deluxe (includes regular fries and your choice of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions). Includes lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Create Your Own Deli Sandwiches
Turkey Sandwich
Start with a boar's head ovengold Turkey and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Ham Sandwich
Start with Boar's head deluxe ham and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Start with boars head roast beef and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Bologna Sandwich
Start with the boar head bologna and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Liverwurst Sandwich
Start with Boars head liverwurst and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Cheese Sandwich
Start with any boars head cheese and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Start with hot boar's head pastrami and build from there.
Pastrami Sandwich
Start with boar's head pastrami and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Genoa Salami Sandwich
Start with boar's head genoa salami and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
Start with hot boars head corned beef and build from there.
Corned Beef Sandwich
Start with boars head corned beef and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Prosciutto Sandwich
Start with the boar's head prosciutto and build from there. While there is no charge for lettuce, tomato, or onions, you must specify what you want to be added to the sandwich add-on modifier.
Cold Subs
Turkey & Cheese Sub (7")
Boar's head ovengold Turkey and your choice of cheese. Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, Swiss, or Provolone.
Italian Sub (7")
Boar's head deluxe ham, ham cappy, genoa salami, and picante provolone. Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, swiss, or Provolone.
Roast Beef & Cheese Sub (7")
Boar's head roast beef and your choice of cheese. Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, Swiss, and Provolone.
Tuna Sub (7")
Store-made albacore tuna salad mixed with a pinch of carrots and celery and Hellman's mayonnaise. Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, Swiss, and Provolone.
Ham & Cheese Sub (7")
Boar's head. Include lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choice of American, Swiss, and Provolone.
Salads
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, black olives, and choice of dressing.
Harvest Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Romaine lettuce tossed with fuji apples, anjou pears, walnuts, dried cherries, and gorgonzola.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed in our Caesar dressing topped with seasoned croutons and asiago and parmesan cheeses.
Autumn Salad with Champagne Vinaigrette
Baby spinach tossed with almonds, craisins, seasoned croutons, shredded carrots, apples, and sliced strawberries.
Turkey BLT Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with cucumbers, grape tomatoes, seasoned croutons, and craisins, topped with boar's head ovengold Turkey breast and applewood smoked bacon.
Macaroni Salad (1/4 lb)
Potato Salad (1/4 lb)
Cobb Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Diced chicken cutlet, avocado, boar's head applewood smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, hard boiled eggs, and crumbled gorgonzola on a bed of romaine.
Trifecta Salad
A generous scoop of tuna, chicken, and egg salad served on a bed of spring mix with sliced onions, shredded carrots, grape tomatoes, and a choice of dressing.
Chicken Mozzarella Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Grilled chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, black olives, roasted red peppers, red onions, and grape tomatoes over a bed of mixed greens.
Chef Salad
Boar's head deluxe ham, oven gold Turkey, roast beef, and imported Swiss served on a bed of lettuce with hard-boiled eggs, tomatoes, onions, and a choice of dressing.
Mesclun Salad with Raspberry Vinaigrette
Spring mix tossed with black olives, asiago cheese, red peppers, cashews, and mandarin oranges.
Asian Cole Slaw (1/4 lb)
Boars Head Combo Deals
Combo 1
1/2 pound deluxe ham, 1/2 pound ovengold Turkey and 1/2 pound yellow American cheese. Freshly sliced boars head meat and cheese combo deals. Please note that no modifications can be accommodated.
Combo 3
1 pound. Deluxe ham, 1 pound. Ovengold Turkey, 1 pound. Yellow American cheese, 1/2 pound roast beef, 1/2 pound. Bologna and 1/2 pound. Imported gold Swiss. Freshly sliced boars head meat and cheese combo deals. Please note that no modifications can be accommodated.
Combo 2
1 pound deluxe ham, 1 pound oven gold Turkey, and 1 pound. Yellow American cheese. Freshly sliced boars head meat and cheese combo deals. Please note that no modifications can be accommodated.
Sweet Treats
Jumbo Cookies
Beverages
Simply (12 oz)
Yoo Hoo (12 oz)
Soda (20 oz)
Gatorade (20 oz)
Milk (1 pt)
Snapple (16 oz)
Vitamin Water (20 oz)
Frappuccino (95 oz)
Monster (16 oz)
Milk - Chocolate (1 qt)
Muscle Milk Chocolate (16 oz)
Poland Spring Water
Tropicana Apple Juice (12 oz)
Turkey Hill (18 oz)
Nesquik Strawberry Milk
Simply Orange Pulp Free (1/2 Gal)
Apple, cranberry, and lemonade.
Red Bull (8.4 oz)
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Delicious bagels. Soft and chewy! Staff was very nice and helpful. Bought 2 bakers dozen for an office party, and many people asked where I bought them. I will be returning to my new favorite bagel shop!
July 2025
Live on the West coast now and they have no clue how to make an authentic begal...this place does! Will come back every time I visit family in NJ. Packed and looked like a long wait on a Sunday morning but service was friendly and quick.
July 2025
You May Also Like
Brasas bbq - 542 Fischer Blvd
![]()
Barbecue, Portuguese, Barbeque
Rue 561 bistro - 561 Fischer Blvd
![]()
Salad, Seafood, Soup
They aren't just a 'bagel shop'. They are a deli as well. They have homemade spreads as well as your typical butter and cream cheese.
I was only there for bagels, but you can dine in. It's small, but they have a lot of offerings.
Definitely recommend.