Silver Bay Bagels
1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River
(732) 255-8131
Customers' Favorites
French Toast Bagel with Maple Butter & Powdered Surgar
Sausage Egg and Cheese Bagel with Cream Cheese
3 EGR Omelette 2 Eggs Your Way French Toast
Bagel with Bacon Egg Cheese
Pork Roll Egg \u0026 Cheese
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese
Short Stack Pancakes
French Toast Platter
Breakfast Burrito
Breakfast Sandwiches *
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese *
Pork Roll & Egg *
Pork Roll & Cheese *
Pork Roll Only *
Bacon Egg & Cheese *
Bacon & Egg *
Bacon & Cheese *
Bacon Only *
Sausage Egg & Cheese *
Sausage & Egg *
Sausage & Cheese *
Sausage Only *
Deli Ham Egg & Cheese *
Deli Ham & Egg *
Deli Ham & Cheese *
Deli Ham Only *
Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon & Egg *
Turkey Bacon & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon Only *
Steak Egg & Cheese *
Steak & Egg *
Steak & Cheese *
Steak Only *
Deli Turkey Egg & Cheese *
Deli Turkey & Egg *
Deli Turkey & Cheese *
Deli Turkey Only *
Egg Only *
Egg & Cheese *
Egg White Breakfast Sandwiches *
Egg White Only *
Egg White & Cheese *
Pork Roll Egg White & Cheese *
Pork Roll & Egg White *
Bacon Egg White & Cheese *
Bacon & Egg White *
Sausage Egg White & Cheese *
Sausage & Egg White *
Deli Ham Egg White & Cheese *
Deli Ham & Egg White *
Turkey Bacon Egg White & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon & Egg White *
Deli Turkey Egg White & Cheese *
Deli Turkey & Egg White *
Steak Egg White & Cheese *
Steak & Egg White *
Bagel w/Spread *
Bagel w/Butter *
Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Special Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Peanut Butter *
Bagel w/Peanut Butter & Jelly *
Bagel w/Nova Lox Spread *
French Toast Bagel w/Butter *
French Toast Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Mini Bagel w/Butter *
Mini Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Mini Bagel w/Special Cream Cheese *
Mini w/Nova Lox Spread *
Roll w/Butter *
Roll w/Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Cheese *
Bagel w/Jelly *
Breakfast Platters *
Omelette *
Egg White Omelette *
Egg Platter *
Western Omelette *
Egg White Western Omelette *
Order Pancakes *
Order French Toast *
Pancake Platter *
French Toast Platter *
Short Stack Pancakes *
Short Stack French Toast *
Chocolate Chip Pancakes *
Silver Dollar Pancakes *
Single Pancake *
Side Home Fries *
Bagels *
Plain Bagel
Everything Bagel
Egg Bagel
Whole Wheat Bagel
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sesame Bagel
Poppy Bagel
Egg Everything Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel *
Salt Bagel
Onion Bagel
Garlic Bagel
Pumpernickel Bagel
Blueberry Bagel
Chocolate Chip Bagel
Oat Bran Bagel
Marble Rye Bagel
Rainbow Bagel
Kaiser Roll *
French Toast Bagel
Mini Bagels *
Mini Plain Bagel
Mini Everything Bagel
Dozen Mini Bagels *
Sides *
Side Home Fries *
Side Of Meat *
Side Of Eggs *
Muffins *
Muffin w/Butter *
Crumb Cake *
Fruit Cup *
Yogurt Parfait *
Side Of White Toast w/Butter *
Side Of Rye Toast w/Butter *
Side Of Wheat Toast w/Butter *
Everything Crunchies *
Hot Sandwiches *
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich *
Hot Turkey & Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwich *
Potato,Peppers & Egg Sandwich *
Grilled Cheese Sandwich *
Tuna Melt Sand *
Deli Sandwiches *
White Fish Salad Sandwich *
Tuna Salad Sand *
Chicken Salad Sand *
Turkey Breast *
Roast Beef *
Cold Deli Ham & Cheese *
BLT *
Egg Salad Sand *
Sloppy Joe *
Chicken Salad Club *
Turkey Club *
New Yorker *
Coffee Bar *
20 oz COFFEE *
20 oz Hot Chocolate *
20 oz Hot Tea *
Iced Coffee *
Jug of Joe *
Cold Drinks *
Tropicana Juices *
Chocolate Milk *
Snapple *
16 oz Fresh Squeezed OJ *
Soda Can *
Water *
Powerade *
Pt Whole Milk *
1/2 Gallon OJ *
Bai Drinks *
Naked Juice *
Starbucks Frappuccino *
Monster *
Pure Leaf Unsweet Tea *
Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Plain Cream Cheese *
1 lb Plain Cream Cheese *
8oz Breakstone Butter *
1/2 lb Vegetable Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Scallion Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Honey Walnut Cranberry Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Strawberry Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Jalapeno Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Olive Pimento Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Nova Lox Spread *
1/2 lb Philly Low Fat Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Tofu Cream Cheese *
Salads *
1/2 lb Macaroni Salad *
1/2 lb Coleslaw *
1/2 lb Potato Salad *
1/2 lb White Fish Salad *
1/2 lb Tuna Salad *
1/2 lb Chicken Salad *
1/2 lb Egg Salad *
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
There are a lot of bagel shops in this area but Silver Bay is best especially if you DON'T prefer fat bagels, which I do not. Their bagels look and taste like they should. Like everywhere prices are not what they used to be and a bit pricey for simply a dozen bagels.
August 2025
Place was very busy. Ordered two sandwiches. Took a little longer than average. They have good staffing, just a lot of orders. Food is good, Prices are average for location. Parking can be a struggle. Will go back.
July 2025
Good food here by hard working people. Lots of fresh bagels. NY bagel w/ lox was great. Fresh orange juice was good. Clean place. Not too busy on Tuesday 8am, but steady flow of people in and out. I imagine they get busy weekend mornings.
July 2025
You May Also Like
Fiore Rosso Restaurant & Catering - 1825 Hooper Ave
![]()
Italian, Seafood
Sweet Carolina Barbecue Company - 1839 Hooper Ave
![]()
Barbeque, American