Silver Bay Bagels

1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River
(732) 255-8131

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

My first time purchasing at Silver Bay Bagels was on Thanksgiving morning. They were crazy busy and handled the traffic with ease, but luckily I had put the order in the night before.
I'm not necessarily a bagel connoisseur, but I felt the bagels were quite tasty, though a little on the thin side ...which is my only negative comment. Conversely, I've had bagels from other stores that were overly puffy and thick, too bready and less tasty, and I couldn't...
Silver Bay Bagels gets 5 gold stars. Wish it was near me in Florida. The bagels are always fresh and the breakfast platters are grand was suprised that it was 3 eggs! It's just a quaint home town vibe with a welcoming atmosphere and seems everyone knows each other. Really like the coffee nook where you get to pour your own coffee, hot or cold. Then if you get cold or you need to cool off the hot cup they have an ice machine with coffee ice 🧊! How cool 😎!
There are a lot of bagel shops in this area but Silver Bay is best especially if you DON'T prefer fat bagels, which I do not. Their bagels look and taste like they should. Like everywhere prices are not what they used to be and a bit pricey for simply a dozen bagels.

More Reviews