Silver Bay Bagels
1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River
(732) 255-8131
Customers' Favorites
French Toast Bagel with Maple Butter & Powdered Surgar
Sausage Egg and Cheese Bagel with Cream Cheese
3 EGR Omelette 2 Eggs Your Way French Toast
Bagel with Bacon Egg Cheese
Pork Roll Egg \u0026 Cheese
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese
Silver Dollar Pancakes
French Toast Platter
Short Stack Pancakes
Breakfast Burrito
Breakfast Sandwiches *
Pork Roll Egg & Cheese *
Pork Roll & Egg *
Pork Roll & Cheese *
Pork Roll Only *
Bacon Egg & Cheese *
Bacon & Egg *
Bacon & Cheese *
Bacon Only *
Sausage Egg & Cheese *
Sausage & Egg *
Sausage & Cheese *
Sausage Only *
Deli Ham Egg & Cheese *
Deli Ham & Egg *
Deli Ham & Cheese *
Deli Ham Only *
Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon & Egg *
Turkey Bacon & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon Only *
Steak Egg & Cheese *
Steak & Egg *
Steak & Cheese *
Steak Only *
Deli Turkey Egg & Cheese *
Deli Turkey & Egg *
Deli Turkey & Cheese *
Deli Turkey Only *
Egg Only *
Egg & Cheese *
Egg White Breakfast Sandwiches *
Egg White Only *
Egg White & Cheese *
Pork Roll Egg White & Cheese *
Pork Roll & Egg White *
Bacon Egg White & Cheese *
Bacon & Egg White *
Sausage Egg White & Cheese *
Sausage & Egg White *
Deli Ham Egg White & Cheese *
Deli Ham & Egg White *
Turkey Bacon Egg White & Cheese *
Turkey Bacon & Egg White *
Deli Turkey Egg White & Cheese *
Deli Turkey & Egg White *
Steak Egg White & Cheese *
Steak & Egg White *
Bagel w/Spread *
Bagel w/Butter *
Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Special Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Peanut Butter *
Bagel w/Peanut Butter & Jelly *
Bagel w/Nova Lox Spread *
French Toast Bagel w/Butter *
French Toast Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Mini Bagel w/Butter *
Mini Bagel w/Cream Cheese *
Mini Bagel w/Special Cream Cheese *
Mini w/Nova Lox Spread *
Roll w/Butter *
Roll w/Cream Cheese *
Bagel w/Cheese *
Bagel w/Jelly *
Breakfast Platters *
Omelette *
Egg White Omelette *
Egg Platter *
Western Omelette *
Egg White Western Omelette *
Order Pancakes *
Order French Toast *
Pancake Platter *
French Toast Platter *
Short Stack Pancakes *
Short Stack French Toast *
Chocolate Chip Pancakes *
Silver Dollar Pancakes *
Single Pancake *
Side Home Fries *
Bagels *
Plain Bagel
Everything Bagel
Egg Bagel
Whole Wheat Bagel
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sesame Bagel
Poppy Bagel
Egg Everything Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel *
Salt Bagel
Onion Bagel
Garlic Bagel
Pumpernickel Bagel
Blueberry Bagel
Chocolate Chip Bagel
Oat Bran Bagel
Marble Rye Bagel
Rainbow Bagel
Kaiser Roll *
French Toast Bagel
Mini Bagels *
Mini Plain Bagel
Mini Everything Bagel
Dozen Mini Bagels *
Sides *
Side Home Fries *
Side Of Meat *
Side Of Eggs *
Muffins *
Muffin w/Butter *
Crumb Cake *
Fruit Cup *
Yogurt Parfait *
Side Of White Toast w/Butter *
Side Of Rye Toast w/Butter *
Side Of Wheat Toast w/Butter *
Everything Crunchies *
Hot Sandwiches *
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich *
Hot Turkey & Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwich *
Potato,Peppers & Egg Sandwich *
Grilled Cheese Sandwich *
Tuna Melt Sand *
Deli Sandwiches *
White Fish Salad Sandwich *
Tuna Salad Sand *
Chicken Salad Sand *
Turkey Breast *
Roast Beef *
Cold Deli Ham & Cheese *
BLT *
Egg Salad Sand *
Sloppy Joe *
Chicken Salad Club *
Turkey Club *
New Yorker *
Coffee Bar *
20 oz COFFEE *
20 oz Hot Chocolate *
20 oz Hot Tea *
Iced Coffee *
Jug of Joe *
Cold Drinks *
Tropicana Juices *
Chocolate Milk *
Snapple *
16 oz Fresh Squeezed OJ *
Soda Can *
Water *
Powerade *
Pt Whole Milk *
1/2 Gallon OJ *
Bai Drinks *
Naked Juice *
Starbucks Frappuccino *
Monster *
Pure Leaf Unsweet Tea *
Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Plain Cream Cheese *
1 lb Plain Cream Cheese *
8oz Breakstone Butter *
1/2 lb Vegetable Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Scallion Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Honey Walnut Cranberry Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Strawberry Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Jalapeno Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Olive Pimento Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Nova Lox Spread *
1/2 lb Philly Low Fat Cream Cheese *
1/2 lb Tofu Cream Cheese *
Salads *
1/2 lb Macaroni Salad *
1/2 lb Coleslaw *
1/2 lb Potato Salad *
1/2 lb White Fish Salad *
1/2 lb Tuna Salad *
1/2 lb Chicken Salad *
1/2 lb Egg Salad *
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Silver Bay Bagels gets 5 gold stars. Wish it was near me in Florida. The bagels are always fresh and the breakfast platters are grand was suprised that it was 3 eggs! It's just a quaint home town vibe with a welcoming atmosphere and seems everyone knows each other. Really like the coffee nook where you get to pour your own coffee, hot or cold. Then if you get cold or you need to cool off the hot cup they have an ice machine with coffee ice 🧊! How cool 😎!
December 2025
There are a lot of bagel shops in this area but Silver Bay is best especially if you DON'T prefer fat bagels, which I do not. Their bagels look and taste like they should. Like everywhere prices are not what they used to be and a bit pricey for simply a dozen bagels.
August 2025
You May Also Like
Fiore Rosso Restaurant & Catering - 1825 Hooper Ave
![]()
Italian, Seafood
Sweet Carolina Barbecue Company - 1839 Hooper Ave
![]()
Barbeque, American
I'm not necessarily a bagel connoisseur, but I felt the bagels were quite tasty, though a little on the thin side ...which is my only negative comment. Conversely, I've had bagels from other stores that were overly puffy and thick, too bready and less tasty, and I couldn't...