Bordentown Bagels

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We're from Elizabeth. Stopped at this bagel place which to our surprise was delicious!!
We've been to several bagel places but this one is number one so far. So, they aren't stingy with the ham or turkey. There white chocolate iced coffee is amazing. Got a homemade macaroni salad which was creamy and good. Quick and friendly service. Will be coming back. Oh and they make homemade flavored cream cheeses too!!
Only down side, it's take out
I can see why this place is busy and has the great reviews that it has. The flow seems interrupted when ordering. Not being from the area made it seem overwhelming but honestly, it was all worth it in the end!
Dozen bagels, lots of cream cheese choices. Try the cannoli cream cheese. Sweet without being overpowering.
I will definitely be back when I am in the area again.
(Someone in line suggested the toasted BLT.)
From the owner, to the entire staff, this bagel shop is the very BEST AROUND!!! I called about a week ago, to place a large order and the owner was very considerate with not trying to rush me. To once I showed up, was very hospitable, considerate, helpful and kind. If your looking for a bagel shop that can over-exceed your expectations or hopes, this is the very best and will make you come back time after time after time! Trust me, youll thank me afterwards.

More Reviews